We played the game, and I was kinda nervous. I couldn't really get it up at first. I kept glancing at the other guys' cocks, then would be worried someone saw me look. They all seemed bigger than mine by a long shot. I mean normally I used 2 or 3 fingers and my thumb only. Some of these guys were actually using 2 hands to get off.
I was thinking this and remembered that I had to get off as fast as possible. My cock was now hard and throbbing... all 4 inches of it! I felt compelled to check out the other guys cocks more. To sneak peaks at the thick shafts, huge glistening heads, and also their proportionately big balls. All those large packages really caught me off guard, and I was fascinated by them. But I had to concentrate.
The room had grown silent except for some heaving breathing and tiny slippery squeaky noises. I look down and started jerking at top speed. I grabbed my ball sack with my other hand to hopefully speed things up. I glanced around again and then really started to feel embarrassed. You see, my balls were also proportionate to my penis size. They would hang down like little grapes sometimes. Right now, though, they were pulled up tight like a single small hackysack. My penis became less rigid as it seemed like all my blood was rushing to my face with shame.
I tried to think of hot babes, but I didn't get fully had again until I stole more glances at the cocks around me. I was rubbing in my precum when the guy to my left started grunting. He took a step forward and aimed at the cracker sitting on the blue plastic plate. It was the kind used at picnics and had a deep lip. He squirted against the side, then moved a bit closer and got a big glob directly on the cracker. He pumped his fist and shot a few smaller squirts in lines across the cracker.
A few other guys started moaning and everyone was pumping like crazy. One big dicked guy stepped up and kinda dripped a small load on the target. That left 3 guys besides myself and I reminded myself of the consequences of losing this perverted game. At first I had wanted to show off how huge a load I had. But now I had mixed feelings as I knew it would draw attention to my small wiener.
The biggest guy came up next, and he had a really big load with about 8-10 shots of thick cum. The finished guys started cheering this display which was quite impressive. He was more like a super soaker where as my orgasms were kinda like little water gun shots. The cracker was mostly covered now and the plate itself had quite a bit of cum puddling up. It was a small Ritz cracker on that big plate.
The next guy had more of a cum spray or sprinkle, which went everywhere: the floor, table, plate and maybe the cracker but it was hard to tell. I was getting close when everyone started cheering and shouting, "Who's it gonna be?!"
The remaining guy stepped forward and really started tensing his whole body. He was squatting and rocking back and forth over the cracker. The guys started cheering for him, so I also moved in with my small dick. with our cocks just inches away I couldn't help but stare. I had to win! Probably they wouldn't make the loser go through with it, but what if they did. It seemed like the cracker was absorbing all but the thickest globs of semen.
My opponent started moaning, so I jerked even harder. I started to feel an orgasm building... but it was too late! The other guy froze and stopped pumping his schlong. My hopes were dashed as he started spurting on the plate. He only had about 5 good blasts, and everyone was cheering for him and taunting me. At first I didn't stop masturbating. I was kinda in shock I suppose.
"Eat that cum cracker, bitch!" one of the guys shouted as he spanked my ass like a football player. Someone else laughed, "You can stop, dumbass. You lost already!" But it was too late once again! The slap to my ass pushed me over the edge. It wasn't meant to be sexual, but the touch sent shivers through my body. I left go of my dick. It twitched as I fought back the inevitable explosion.
I heard: "I guess he wants to eat his own cum too!" and "What's up? that's not enough cum for you?" But I couldn't help it, I had to lean against the table with both hands as my knees buckled. "It's tiny!" someone snickered, then "holy shit you're right!" The room erupted in laughter as my tiny peepee erupted in front of me.
My first shot was high pressure and slid and pooled up against the lip of the plate. A few "whoas" were heard and then I shot a long stream right across the cracker. My 'lil cock was just pointing out into the air. All by itself looking very skinny since my cock head was almost normal size.
"Oh god" I moaned quietly as much from embarrassment as from the pleasure of jizz traveling down my shaft. It didn't have far to travel I noted as my prostate convulsed, my shaft jumped and I pumped out (hands-free) perhaps the biggest gooey glob ever. The guys were cheering me on now!
"Man! What the fuck! Now way! Is that possible? Who would'a thought it. Damn!" was the response. So, I kinda felt proud but still definitely ashamed. I didn't know if I should grab my dick now or if that would help distinguish just how small it was. I knew if I took it in my hand that the head would barely stick out. If I used 3 fingers to stroke my shaft then I'd have to stick my pinky out, and that seemed kinda gay. Like drinking from a little teacup with you pinky extended. So I just stood there with my tiny erection as it pulsed and squirted 2 more times.
The guys were clapping, laughing and hooting at the show I was putting on. It felt so good that I just had to rub my penis. I decided it couldn't be any more humiliating than my little dick all alone, throbbing and squirting out in the open, in front of everyone. I grabbed it with my middle finger and thumb around the head. My pointer finger was sticking out and my pinky was touching my little balls. This felt awesome and I lost myself as my orgasm redoubled in intensity.
I shot 5 more large squirts and actually aimed at the cracker in my delusional excitement. The guys were still cheering as a dripped and oozed out a few more globs of cum. As I came to my senses I became aware that they were chanting, "Eat it! Eat it! Eat it!" and also telling me to "Slurp up all that cum!"
I looked down at what seemed like a gallon of cum. There were a few different textures and shades of white. Now that I was completely spent all traces of horniness left my mind. I blushed a deeper shade of red and felt my penis start to soften. It curved down and dangled as they taunted and hounded me.
I really started thinking they'd make me go through with it. I mean the crowd was on fire. I looked around but didn't see any sympathetic faces. One guy was on his cell phone off to the side, but that was no comfort. The other guys were getting really lewd and I was worried the person on the phone might hear some of it.
I was kinda still rubbing my penis a bit. It was shrinking still, smaller and smaller. My shaft was now shriveled up to a wrinkled one inch. I tried to stretch it out, but it was like a thin strand of taffy sticking out of my pubic hair. My head was still a bit engorged which made the shaft look even more ridiculous and thin.
Someone lifted up the plate towards me, and I flinched as it almost spilled on me. There was a huge pool of cum sloshing around the perimeter of the plate. I tried to back away, but two guys moved to block my exit. I thought about making a dash for the door, but I was buck naked with my clothes somewhere across the room. Plus we were in a coed dorm. I doubt that I'd want to run around nude even in an all male dorm. This wasn't even my dorm! I couldn't exactly run across campus with my tiny penis flopping around.
I reached for the cracker with a trembling hand. I really didn't want to touch that cum, my own and all of theirs. The plate moved closer to my face threateningly. I touched warm liquid as I tried to pick up the cracker. It was too soggy and broke in half. Some cum oozed off the cracker, which got some "eeewwwwwws!" and "so gross!"
I opened my mouth with a disgusted look on my face I'm sure, but I froze up staring at the cum covered, half a cracker. Cum had mostly pooled up in the little holes of the cracker. A couple strings of thick cum were dangling off the side of it. Then someone pushed on my wrist, making me shove the cum cracker right in my mouth. I didn't close my mouth in time and I tasted a warm, salty brine.