I slept fitfully that night -- my feelings about what had happened with Doctor Hadfield and what he'd said kept flashing through my head. I was so confused -- the good-girl side of me rejected utterly the idea that I could be someone that enjoyed that sort of sex. But at the same time I could feel my pussy twitch every time I thought about what I had done.
I woke feeling both ashamed and desperately horny. I felt so tempted to let my hand wonder between my legs but resisted -- I was not that sort of girl, I was a normal eighteen year old with normal desires. Besides how could I know that normal sex wasn't what I wanted when I'd never done it? As I walked to school I came to a decision -- tonight I would seduce Craig and prove to myself I was normal.
I texted him that minute -- I love you Craig and have decided tonight is the night we do it. I'm ready -- are you?
I wasn't surprised by his quick response -- Definitely! Come over to my place, my parents are out until late.
I giggled at his enthusiasm -- Ok, see you around 7
That day I couldn't really concentrate on school -- I felt so naughty knowing that I would be having sex with Craig that night. But it felt kind of right too -- this was what teenagers did and there was nothing to be ashamed of -- I could tell my friends and not feel embarrassed.
After school I showered, put on my best underwear and then my normal jeans and tee-shirt. I grabbed my school bag and told my mum I was going to Craig's to study -- something I often did.
When I arrived he pulled open the door without me even knocking -- he looked excited and nervous and I suppose I did too. Between my legs my pussy spasmed -- I was horny for him and I felt relieved that I was.
"I love you." He said.
"I love you too." I replied but that was it. The next thing I knew I had grabbed him and was kissing him hard on the lips. He managed to close the door and we worked our way upstairs to his bedroom while still kissing.
I got onto his bed and pulled off my tee-shirt to reveal my bra and my pert, teenaged breasts. His eyes bulged. His face had gone red and he was breathing hard. He pulled his shirt off quickly and then his jeans. I looked down and could see his cock, already hard, making a little tent of his boxer shorts. A moment of disappointment came over me -- his cock looked quite small. I pushed those thoughts away -- maybe it would get bigger as we went on.
I pulled off my jeans too and then he said, "Let's get under the covers."
I was a bit confused but I understood he was a bit embarrassed -- unlike me this was his first time. Once under the duvet we yanked at each other's underwear until finally we were both naked. He quickly grabbed my breasts and squeezed them softly. I moaned a little and he looked up, concerned.
"Am I hurting you?" He said worriedly.
"No," I said, "It's nice."
"Oh, ok."
He moved his hand down to my pussy and I let my legs fall apart slightly.
"You don't have any hair down there!" He said, startled.
"I know." I said, "Do you like it?"
"Ummm...I guess so." He sounded unconvincing and now looked worried again. This was not how I had imagined it.
I reached down and took hold of his cock and couldn't help feeling crest-fallen. It was about four inches long and quite thin. Craig gasped, a look of pleasure on his face.
Between my legs he started to rub my, by now, wet pussy. His fingers prodded and poked but seemed to miss both my entrance and my clitoris. I felt frustration welling up in me so I grabbed his hand and put his fingers on my clitoris.
"There." I said. "Rub me there."
He managed it for a couple of seconds but then lost it and was prodding and poking again. In the end I just said. "Let's do it."
"Ok." He said excitedly. "I've got a condom I bought today."
For a second I almost said not to worry, that I was on the pill now, but for some reason I didn't.
"Great, I said."
He fumbled around with the condom for what felt like five minutes before he finally had it on.
I laid on my back and spread my legs. He looked at me nervously.
"Umm...can I go underneath?" He asked.
I was confused -- didn't he want to be in control of it? Wasn't me underneath how most people did it?
He looked so worried that eventually I said ok and we moved around.
With the duvet now off us I could see his young body fully for the first time. He liked to work out and was toned but somehow it left me feeling cold. His eyes devoured my young body -- I saw his cock twitch as my pert, young breast came into view.
I straddled him and took hold of his condom covered cock -- it had grown no bigger and was just a hard little sausage between my fingers. He groaned at my touch. I guided it between my now cooling pussy lips until I felt it at my entrance. I slowly lowered myself down and felt Craig's cock enter me. All too quickly I felt my bottom touch his hips.
"Oh, god!" He said below me, his voice hoarse. "That feels amazing!"
Above him I did not feel so excited. I could feel his small cock inside my, thankfully still tight, pussy but it didn't exactly fill me up. I moved up and then sank slowly down -- Craig gasped again. He was enjoying it but I felt like something was missing -- I wanted to feel the intense lust I had felt before but it just wasn't there.
"Do you like that?" I asked. "Do you like your thing inside me?"
He looked up at me. "Umm...yes, it's lovely." He said a bit confused.
"Am I a naughty girl doing this?" I said in my best sultry voice while still moving up and down slowly.
"No." He said quickly. "This is an expression of our love, Emily." His face was concerned.
"Yes," I said, all my horniness suddenly draining away. "I love you."