Hey Everyone,
Thanks for making it through to Chapter 3. I'm hoping that the fact that you're here means that you've enjoyed the first two chapters. This is the first story I've been confident enough to publish. If you've enjoyed it, I'd really love it if you could drop a comment letting me know what you like or what you'd want to see more of in future stories. Hopefully that'll help me write more.
Ok, on with the show.....
--------
Molly was still pressed against Hailey's chest.
Their legs tangled. Their breath slowing. Their bodies sticky from what they'd done to each other. She lay on her side, one thigh thrown over Hailey's hip, her palm splayed flat across the other girl's stomach as if touch alone could keep this peace in place.
Hailey's fingers toyed gently with the ends of Molly's braid.
Neither spoke.
And for a long moment - maybe the longest of the day - no one moved.
Reese was lying nearby, watching them. Her face was unreadable. Blank. She looked at their hands. At the way Hailey's fingers stroked Molly's shoulder. At the way Molly had curled into her after the orgasm - like she was safe now.
Like she was done.
And for a flicker of a moment, Reese believed it had worked.
She believed she'd taken it for her.
Lauren shattered the silence.
"Bend her."
Molly turned her head, eyes wide, lips parted.
Reese sat up too fast - her body screamed, but she ignored it.
"No," she said, voice hoarse. "You said-"
"I said she was one of us," Lauren said softly. "Not that she was spared."
Molly blinked.
Then sat up slowly.
Her fingers brushed her thigh - a nervous tick.
Then she nodded.
Reese's heart dropped.
"You don't have to," she said, louder now, voice shaking. "You don't-Molly, you don't."
But Molly looked at her sister.
And smiled.
"I do."
She stood.
Still naked. Her thighs still slick, lips still swollen and tender from Hailey's fingers. She walked toward him slowly - not seductively. Just ready. Each step deliberate. Her chest rose with deep breaths, her arms at her sides.
He sat on the couch.
Still hard. Still heavy.
Still waiting.
She stopped in front of him.
"I want to matter," she said. "Like she did."
She turned.
Bent.
Arms resting on the edge of the couch. Hair falling to one side. Legs slightly parted. Her ass raised.
It was perfect.
Not because it was flawless - it wasn't. There were stretch marks at the base. A faint tan line from running shorts. A little tremble in the glutes from nerves.
But because she offered it.
Openly.
Reese was crying now.
Not loud. Just there. The kind of crying you do when the air betrays you.
Hailey sat motionless.
Lauren approached Molly from behind.
Spit in her hand.
Reached between her cheeks.
And rubbed it in.
Molly gasped.
Lauren smiled.
"Good girl."
He stood now.
Moved behind her.
Reese tried to speak - but the words stuck.
She watched.
Watched as he grabbed Molly's hips.
Watched as he lined his cock up.
Watched as he pushed - slow, steady - the fat, spit-slick head pressing against her untouched asshole.
Molly whimpered.
Her fingers gripped the couch cushion.
He didn't thrust.
He pressed.
Slow.
Molly's mouth dropped open.
Her back arched.
And her ass opened for him.
Inch by inch.
Breath by breath.
She took him.
And Reese watched it happen.
Watched Molly's face turn to disbelief, then pain, then something even worse:
Pride.
And that's when Reese knew.
Her sacrifice had meant nothing.
He didn't move right away.
Just stood behind Molly, cock heavy and slick at the tip, resting it against the cleft of her ass like it belonged there already. She twitched when it touched - not from fear, but from the weight of the moment. Her breath caught. Her hands curled tighter into the cushion. Her back arched just slightly, her thighs pressing inward, instinct trying to close what she had just offered.
The room held its breath.
And then he spoke.
Not to Molly.
To Reese.
"Lube me."
The words landed like a fist to the chest.
Reese flinched.
She was still seated, legs curled beneath her, face wet, arms wrapped around her stomach as if she could hold herself shut. But now she looked up. Her eyes went from him to Molly's bare, trembling ass - open, vulnerable - and back to the cock he wanted her to touch.
Lauren watched closely.
Silent.
Smiling.
This was the final lesson.
Reese rose on shaking legs.
She stepped forward.
Each footfall felt like it was happening underwater - slow, detached, wrong. Her hands twitched at her sides. Her chest ached. Her throat burned with everything she wanted to say but couldn't.
When she reached him, she dropped to her knees.
Her eyes didn't meet his.
Her hands lifted.
One wrapped around the base of his cock - warm, thick, veined and pulsing with want. The other spat into her palm. Then again. Then slowly - reverently, shamefully - she rubbed it in.
She stroked him.
Coating him in spit.
Sliding her hand from base to tip. Then back again. Slow. Obedient.
Molly moaned ahead of them.
"I'm ready," she whispered.
Reese's hand froze for half a second.
Then moved faster.
She spread the slickness around the head, under the ridge. Down the shaft. Her fingers slid under to cradle his balls. She didn't look at him. She didn't speak.
She just prepared him.
Prepared the cock that had ripped her open. The cock she'd bled for. The cock she'd begged to spare her sister.
And now she was helping it go in.
She pulled her hand back.
Sat down slowly.
And watched.
He gripped Molly's hips.
Lined up again.
And this time - he didn't pause.
He pushed.
Reese's lube made it easy.
The head slipped in.
Molly cried out - a mix of pain and delight.
He fed more in.
Inch by inch.
Molly's ass spread around him, swallowing his cock with a slowness that made the whole room ache. Her back arched. Her toes curled. Her fingers clawed the cushion.
Reese watched it all.
And hated how wet she was.
The head of his cock vanished into her ass like it had always known the way.
Molly's moan was long and broken - not a scream, not quite a sob, but something in between, something from the space behind her ribs. Her fingers clawed the couch. Her toes dug into the rug. Her back arched higher without meaning to, offering more without understanding why.
Reese watched from the floor.
Knees pulled to her chest. Cum dried between her breasts. Her hand still sticky from stroking the cock now buried inside her sister. Her jaw trembled with the effort of keeping her mouth shut.
He pushed deeper.
Molly gasped. Her head snapped back. Her spine bowed in submission.
"F-fuck-fuck-he's-oh God-"
He didn't stop.
He didn't slow.