Torc and the others rummaged the kitchen for food while Toby carried me to the bathroom. "Poor kitty. Did the big bad men make your pussy sore?" He taunted after he locked the door and sat me on the sink counter before turning to the tub.
I sat there, hands still cuffed behind me watching silently as he ran hot water too tired to fight. What would be the point with three males between me and the door, should I get past this one?
"Why are you doing this to me?" I demanded quietly.
"Because we can. We're horny, you're available, and we have this cabin. You are not the first girl we've shared, and you won't be the last. But you shouldn't act all sad. I watched you cum again and again. This is turning you on. Ever been with a white boy before?"
I shook my head.
"Well, damn. That means Torc got that. How was it?"
"How was what? Being handcuffed and tackled by a stranger? Or maybe when he and his buddies raped me. Like you plan to do."
Toby chuckled and shut off the water. "You can't rape the willing, and though you fought it, you were willing."
"Last time I checked, no meant no. I don't want this! Any of it!" I swiped at my face with my shoulders trying to clean myself. Toby walked back to me and grabbed my upper arms.
"Really? Then why come up here alone? And tell every male around you that you are alone? I think you were trying to call attention to yourself."
"Of course you would say that. I told the truth. Two, I thought, innocent people asked the question. It was your people who invaded my privacy, my cabin, me. What's next, lynching at dawn?"
"Stop it. Had you been a blonde bitch from a rich family you'd still be sitting there with dried cum on your face. I told you we've done this before. The check up on your health was for everyone's benefit. All you need worry about is getting pregnant."
I snorted. "Why doesn't that comfort me?" I jumped down from the counter. Might as well clean this off. Sliding into the hot water was heaven to strained muscles. Although once in the water, I wasn't able to do anything but soak. Which was fine until I heard a zipper.
"What are you-? oww!" I cried as he roughly grabbed my hair, wrapping it around his hand.
"Have you already forgotten that you owe me an apology? You kicked me in the balls. Open you mouth!" His cock was as massive as his brother's.
"Are younnmmfmmff?!" When I opened my mouth he filled it with his shaft. I tried to bite down but he yanked my head to the side. I screamed but he shoved himself down my throat.
Lips stretched to capacity, water blurred my vision as he moved my head back and forth. All I could concentrate on was breathing when the head of his cock backed into my mouth freeing my throat.
Toby closed his eyes and moaned, "That's good. Now suck on it with those pretty lips. Show me how sorry you are." In retrospect, it probably wasn't the smartest thing to get into the sunken tub, which put my mouth at crotch level.
But then, the bastard caught me off guard. I actually forgot why he was here. Just because he hadn't fucked me yet was no reason to think he wouldn't.
A fact that was painfully being shown to me as Toby's cock swelled and his cum spurted down my throat. He sat down heavily on the tub's platform, his still hard weapon popped from my mouth.
It slapped against his abdomen and stood at attention. Toby petted my head hard like a good dog, breathing hard. I whimpered, knowing that if he was still erect, he wasn't done.
"This is going to be a good three weeks."
"You can't keep me here!"
"Can't I? You didn't think you'd be so well fucked by four white guys did you? And here you are, our little plaything. All of us have a fun group activity that ends with you dripping cum. I know Torc brought his collection of porn. You'll suck us off while we watch. Ben likes poker; winner gets to fuck you. Matt likes to role-play; so prepare to be screwed like Goldicocks or Red Riding Cock. Me, I want to let you go."
I opened my eyes startled, "Let me go? Yes! Yes, lets do that! I won't tell anyone anything!"
"I know you won't, but you didn't let me finish. I want to let you go so we can track you down. Once whoever finds you fucks you, they let you go and someone else gets to play. Fun huh?"
"No!"
"Why do you insist on lying? You've been wet since we've been here, and yet you always manage to portray the victim. Sure I can play along." Toby stood and removed the rest of his clothes. His erection remained turgid and an angry red the entire time.
"Now what are you up to?" I asked worriedly.
"Just a test. Now, water is not a very good lubrication when it comes to sex, agree?"
Confused, "I suppose," I started.
"Then you should be practically dry now. The water should have cleaned away most of everyone's cum by now. And if you weren't enjoying yourself, you wouldn't have continued to be wet. My test is simple: I plow a couple of fingers into your pussy. If you are still wet, I fuck you and nothing changes. If not, then I fuck you and then you can go, we'll leave you alone."
"Either way I'm screwed." I grumbled ignoring Toby's laughter. I didn't feel aroused, in fact I felt more annoyed than anything. "Whatever. But don't hurt me, asshole." Leaning back, I waited.
Instead of reaching into the water like I expected. He grabbed my hair again and pulled me up and over the edge of the tub. Pain exploded behind my eyes. As I shrieked in pain and shock, he spun my body so my belly slammed down on the edge, ass in the air.
Keeping the hand he had in my hair holding my head, he hopped into the tub behind me.
"Just try to relax." Was all the warning I got before two thick digits rammed straight up my channel. This made me scream. "Now you are over reacting." He retracted his fingers and pushed them in again. Then wiggled them making a wet squishy noise. "You sound wet to me. Tell me you don't like this. Go on."
"I-I doonn-," I started, but he kept moving his fingers bumping my clit with the other digits. I closed my eyes and rotated my hips back to him. That is when he smacked my ass. Hard. My eyes snapped open and my body went rigid. He yanked his hand from my snatch.
"You are a lying bitch aren't you? You thought I would masturbate you? I only reward deserving cunts. Although you have stayed wet this whole time, I suppose I could give you a treat. Has anyone ever fucked you, here?" He jammed his pussy-covered middle finger into my ass and sank it passed the second knuckle.
