Tim looked into Mary's eyes as she stood in front of him. She was blushing, and her worried expression just made her look more attractive.
Tim gave her a small nod, and her hands moved to the button on her shorts. Tim dropped his eyes to take her all in. She was wearing tennis shoes and tiny white socks. Her legs were slender and tan, and when his eyes had moved up to her snug shorts, he saw that her fingers were trembling slightly as she fumbled for a moment with the button before it snapped open.
She paused for just a second, then pulled down the zipper and tugged the shorts open. She had just started to wriggle when Tim held up a finger and softly said, "Turn around for this part."
Mary swallowed at that, but then complied. When she'd turned so that her butt was facing Tim, she pushed her shorts down over her ripe, round ass, and then gave a wiggle that caused them to drop to the floor. She could feel Tim's eyes on her rump, and she was both embarrassed and turned on.
"Very nice," Tim said from behind her. "You can face me again."
When she turned, she saw a small smile on Tim's handsome face, as he delayed raising his eyes from her crotch to her face just long enough for her to see where he'd been looking. She felt her face flush, as she fought the temptation to cover her panties with her hands, since that would just make her look more like a naughty girl than she already did.
Tim's eyes sparkled as he said, "Please take off your shirt next."
Mary opened her mouth to complain, but then thought better of it. She pulled the polo shirt up over her head and off, and dropped it on the floor on top of her shorts. She wore a cream-colored bra, and she knew without looking that her hard nipples were obvious.
"Now the bra," Tim said.
Mary hesitated. "I just want--"
"You said you wanted to make it up to me, right?" Tim interrupted. "Well, this is how you make it up to me."
She looked at him for another few seconds, then reached behind her and unsnapped her bra. Before she could think about it, she pulled the bra away and dropped it on the floor.
Tim's eyebrows lifted slightly as he saw her very nice breasts bounce as she removed the bra. He'd guess that she was a 36-C, but her tits showed no sign of sagging. Her erect nipples were more pink than he'd expected, given her brown hair and olive complexion.
"Nice," he said softly. His voice seemed to make her shiver, and she couldn't stop herself from nervously cupping her breasts in her hands.
Tim smiled at that, and at the red flush that now extended down from her face to the top of her chest. He slowly slid his eyes down to her cream-colored cotton panties. "Just one more thing."
"Do I have to?" Mary said, noting the tremble in her own voice.
"What was I wearing last night?" Tim asked.
"Just your shoes," Mary mumbled. It was quiet for a moment. She looked at him pleadingly, but he just watched her.
Her mind made up, she quickly hooked her thumbs into her panties and pushed them down until they cleared her curvy tush and slid to her ankles. She made a little side-step with one foot, and then the other, and then she was naked in front of Tim.
Tim took in her lean, sexy body, including her brown pubic hair, which was neatly trimmed but not mostly gone, as seemed to be the fashion lately. He could see that Mary was struggling to not drop a hand down below to cover up.
"Embarrassing, isn't it?" Tim asked, and winked at her.
Mary couldn't trust herself to speak, so she just nodded her head.
Tim quickly got up from his chair, surprising Mary. He took her by her left arm and took a step toward his front door, tugging her with him.
Mary was startled, and said, "What are you doing?"
Tim just said, "You'll see," and pulled her briskly out of the living room. She started resisting more as they got closer to the front door.
"Hey," she said, "seriously. What are you doing?"
Tim didn't answer. The closer he got to the front door, the harder he had to tug his confused, naked neighbor. When he reached it, he opened it less than halfway and stuck his head out, looking up and down the street. He could feel Mary's generous breasts and hard nipples press against his back as she cowered behind him.
"What are you--"
Tim turned back to her, leaving the door partly open behind him. She moved back to keep herself out of sight from the street. "The coast is clear," he said. "So I want you to scamper over to your house, get your bottle of vegetable oil from last night, and bring it back here to me. But you are not to put any clothes on before you come back."
"Oh come on!" Mary looked horrified.
Tim just smiled at her. "I ran a lot farther than that last night, totally naked."