Mike was a deep-sea charter skipper. He has taken charters out fishing for big fish for nearly twenty years. He had been living and working out of Key West for the last ten years. He has an older Viking fishing boat. It wasn't a beauty by today's standards, but it could still go nearly 40 knots and stay out long enough. Mike had been taking charters nearly every day for two weeks, and he needed a break. A break for him was to go fishing by himself. He liked the solitude.
Mike headed out of Key West early one afternoon searching for tuna or sailfish. He stopped a few hours later in an area he has had success in the past. He stopped the engines and went to the back. He set a couple of trolling lines off the back, and went back in. He started up and began moving at 5 knots, dragging the two lines.
The first couple of hours was nothing. It was beginning to get dark. He was going to stay a little longer before starting in. It would take a couple of hours to get back, but he wasn't worried. He had brought it in late at night many times, and he didn't think much about it. Another couple of hours passed uneventfully and he was beginning to think about calling it a day when he had a strike.
He stopped the boat and headed back to the lines. One was singing as it went out. He grabbed the pole and strapped in. It was really moving. He let it run until it started to slow down. He then began to slowly real it in. He would gain a little then lose a little. The next hour was the normal cat and mouse game. He was slowly bringing it in. He just had to stay at it. It was late now, but the sky was bright with stars. He always loved a clear night on the ocean. It smelled so fresh and looked like you could see forever. A couple of hours in, he wished he had brought a friend with him. He couldn't drive the boat closer to the fish and handle the pole at the same time. He would have to make the fish come to him, and that does not usually work very well. After another hour, he thought he was making headway. He was steadily reeling in. He wasn't sure how much line was still out, but he was definitely getting tired.
Just as he was contemplating cutting the line, he saw a flash in the moonlight. He then pulled harder and saw a brief glimpse of a fishtail. He may have it by the tail. That is very unusual. But the sight of the actual fish gave him more energy and he attacked it harder. It was nearing midnight when he had the fish within sight. He did have it by the tail, but it looked like he had snagged it good. It kept pulling away from him, but he was able to wear it down. The water was dark, and he could not see into it.
He finally had the tail near the side of the boat. The rest of fish was still out of sight. He grabbed the spar and hooked the fish in the tail. He wrapped the line around the pully and started winching it in. He was really excited when the tail came up to the top of the deck. It was BIG. Maybe five or six feet long. He had never caught anything like that before. With one last pull, the fish flopped over the side and landed in the boat.
What he saw stunned him. He was staring at a mermaid. Half fish and half woman. They don't exist, but he was staring at one. She or it was so exhausted it just lay there. It was bleeding from where he had grabbed it. He didn't know what to do, but he didn't want it to get overboard before he could decide. He grabbed it by the tail and dragged it into the cabin. He rolled it into a blanket and locked the door.
He decided it would take a couple of hours to get back anyway, so he might as well head home. He pushed the motors to the limit to get out of here. He had images of other mermaids chasing him. He knew that was stupid, but so was having a mermaid in his cabin. When he was nearing Key West, he decided to stop in a quiet lagoon while he decided what to do. When he was anchored, he went into the cabin. She was NOT a mermaid any longer. She was sitting on the couch, wrapped in a blanket. Her leg was bleeding where he had speared her. She was terrified and watching his every move. He put his hands up and said "I won't hurt you. I know you don't understand me, but it will be okay."
She was screwing up her face. He could tell she was thinking, however they think. He was still wondering when she opened her mouth. "You must put me back in the ocean. I will die if you do not."
He was stunned. She spoke and it was English. "You speak English?"
"We can learn a language easily. We speak to all fish and mammals in the ocean. Once we hear the language, we can figure it out. You must put me back in the ocean."
Yeah, like that would happen. He had taken pictures of her laying on the cabin floor before he had rolled her up in the blanket. He wanted proof because he wouldn't believe himself if he told anyone without proof. "Let me fix your leg. So, you do get legs when you dry out?"
"Temporarily, yes. But I will dry out completely if I am out of the water for more than a day. I can't survive without seawater, and I need a lot of it."
"Ok but let me bandage your leg. That is the least I can do after harpooning you." She nodded, and he took a first aid kit out. He cleaned the wound, put some antiseptic on it and wrapped a bandage around it.
They sat looking at each other for several minutes. "I just can't believe you are real. I mean, come on. No one has ever caught one, or seen one?"
"We try VERY hard to make sure we stay away from humans. All the encounters we have had end badly for us."
"I understand. We are an arrogant, self-centered species that thinks the entire world is our plaything. You are wise to stay as far from us as you can. I guess that explains the whole "siren song of destruction" thing that humans believe."
"We have protected ourselves from your kind on a few occasions. However, we would much rather just stay away from you."
"So, what do we do now? If I let you go, will your people have to wreck my ship to protect your secret?"
"Not necessarily. There have been encounters that have ended mutually without incident. There are humans that know of us and leave our secret alone. There are even humans that we occasionally interact with on an emergency basis. They can be trusted to keep our secret."
They stared at the floor for the longest time.
He made a decision. "I have no more right to imprison you than your people would me. I must return you to where I found you. Can you survive until nightfall? We don't want to do anything during the day that might be seen."
She got so excited she forgot where she was for a second. She jumped up and hugged him. "Thank you, thank you. My life can continue. I spent the time fighting your line thinking I would be the one that would expose my people to harm. You are not what you describe as your species." She sat back down, embarrassed.
"I would like to think I am not a bad person. Besides, even though I would never be able to tell anyone, I would know in my heart, that I had met a mermaid, and a beautiful one, at that." She looked down and blushed.
"I will be okay until the sun goes down. Maybe we can be out there by then?"
"Yes, I will need to get some fuel, so you will have to stay hidden while I am in the harbor. We can keep you down here." He pointed to his bedroom cabin and opened the door for her. She looked inside and smiled.
"Thank you. What is your name, by the way?"
"Mike, Michael Mitchell." She went into the bedroom and lay down. Mike went topside and set off for the harbor. When he arrived and had docked, he looked in on her. She was fast asleep.