Over the course of the next few months, Allen and Cleo came to terms with the direction their relationship had taken. Neither of them hid what happened behind the previously-barred doors of their own thoughts. Cleo wanted the security of understanding why Allen was dating her, despite her being an underfolk. Allen wanted to be respected even though Cleo could practically lift a car off the ground and throw it.
And, contrary to what either of them thought was going to happen, after over a dozen breakups and sloppy get-back-together fucks; they actually worked things out. Granted, Cleo was still smug and demeaning when they hung out, but it turned into more of an inside joke than anything. And it stopped being the majority of the face Allen saw of her. At the end of the day, Allen knew she loved and respected him as a person and a partner in what they had. Cleo managed to get past her incessant fear that Allen was going to "date up" and leave her for someone less dramatic and more demure. Or human.
Somehow, their fight turned everything around. Things finally coming to a head managed to drag everyone's emotional dirty laundry about the entire relationship out into the open. Between the two of them, they managed to sort most of it out and find a clear line of demarcation for what was and wasn't okay. Even as Cleo pulled up to Allen's apartment after work, things weren't completely resolved, but they were well enough sorted to be considered resolved.
Allen heard the front door open and Cleo's boots clatter on the faux-wooden floor.
"Come here kitty kitty kitty! I'm home!" she jeered, meowing as Allen came downstairs to meet her. The underfolk grinned as she caught his eyes. "There's my favorite pussy in the whole world."
Allen smirked. "And there's
my
favorite pussy in the whole world." He pressed his palm to the crux of Cleo's thighs and the underfolk's eyebrows came up in surprise.
"
Below
, Allen!"
The human's hand snapped away. "W-what? To much? I'm sorry."
"Don't be sorry; it was kinda hot." Cleo recovered quickly, leaning forward to give Allen a peck on his flushed cheek. "I like seeing that part of you sometimes."
Allen felt pinpricks all over his face. "Sorry. It just sounds weird. It feels so...wrong, I guess. I don't know. I just wanted to be...fuck I don't know. Like you always are. Confident?"
"Well, it was smooth as fuck until you freaked out." Cleo mimicked his action and pressed her hand to his crotch, daring him to run away. "Follow through next time and I might just drop to my knees and squeeze your dick with my throat right there in the doorway."
Allen felt a little twinge of arousal run up through his body.
He pushed it aside for the moment. "Anyway, moving on from the most embarrassing thing I've done in the past week, what do you want for dinner?"
Cleo shrugged, withdrawing her hand after a playful squeeze. "I dunno. Hot chili? We haven't done chili in a while and it's finally getting cold outside again."
"Chili sounds good. I don't have any cheese though. That cool?"
"Whatever's fine with me. I'm a simple girl with simple needs."
Allen wrapped his arms around her shoulders and she stood up to her full height, bringing him off his feet. They kissed and she walked them to the kitchen, unfazed by the almost two hundred extra pounds attached to her frame at the moment. Allen dropped off her shoulders at the sink got to work starting the chili while Cleo threw her work clothes in the laundry room and showered.
After dinner, they ended up finding a movie they could both tune out and just talked for a while as things settled down for the night. They had a usual routine that things followed past a certain point. If they didn't run off to the shower or the bedroom right after dinner, then it was probably going to be a slow night where they just griped about things and talked about everything and nothing at the same time.
Tonight, though, things weren't quite as routine as they seemed.
Situated in his usual spot on the couch as the little spoon to Cleo's larger frame, Allen felt his girlfriend's arm start to hoist him a little further up on her chest, past the point where her could rest his head in its usual place between her breasts. He looked back at her, but instead of a leer or a smirk like he expected, he found a sort of unsure expression on Cleo's face. It took her a few seconds to actually talk once they locked eyes.
"Hey Allen."
"Yeah?"
She bit her lip anxiously. "I have a sex question and I don't know how to ask without sounding like a huge dick."
"Oh...kay? Um, is everything alright?"
"Yes. I
really
like having sex with you. But I just have this thing..."
Allen reached up and placed his hand on hers. "Well just say it." Jokingly, he added. "I'm not too small, am I?"
Cleo made a little noise at that. "No. It's not size related." She paused. "Well, okay it
is
-"
Allen turned his head more to face her directly, but it didn't help him understand much better. The immediate thing that came to mind was-
"But it's not your dick," Cleo added before he could get any further down that mental rabbit hole.
"Is it
me
?"
"No. It's...fuck I don't even-" She squeezed him in an effort to make the awkwardness go away. "Just forget it."
Allen twisted around so that he was on his hands and knees over her, looking down at the Underfolk turning redder in the face than an exit sign. "Cleo, it's okay. You brought it up; just tell me."
"It's not important," she insisted.
Allen kept going. "Well it was important enough for you to say something about it."
"It's not. Just forget it."
"Cleo, come on. Now I'm worried."
She met his eyes for all of two seconds before looking away again. "Don't be. It's not important."
Allen rolled his eyes. "Just tell me already. Why are you being so weird?"
Cleo's voice sharpened. "Forget. It." Despite her tone, she fidgeted under him like she wanted to just leave. She tried to pry his arms away to get him off, but he refused to budge. It took considerable effort to make her understand he wasn't going to just be lifted away like a helpless doll anymore.
Even after their fight and all the reconciliation that had happened in the weeks afterward, she still held onto a few bad habits from before. Avoiding conflict by trying to physically leave and not address the issue was probably chief among them. Right now though, with Allen all but mounting her, refusing to move, she had nowhere to run.
There was some silence that followed her giving up on an escape attempt. Allen broke it after some thought. "You don't- Like, it's not my hair is it? I can-"
Cleo interrupted. "It's not your hair. Fuck, Allen, just forget it!"
The human threw a hand up in exasperation. "Then what could possibly be a size issue if it's not my dick and it's not my height? I just...I can't get much bigger physically without pushing weights every single day. I just don't have time f-"
Cleo's eyes finally met his with intent. "It's your load!"
Allen blinked. In the silence that followed, Cleo managed to turn an even brighter shade of red than before. It took the human a moment to collect enough thoughts to say something back. "My...my
load
? Like- like my, uh, my
cum
?"
"Yeah," came the meek response.
"What about the size of my- hold on is it too much?"
"No," Cleo answered unconvincingly, covering her face with both hands.