A Sisters Fear Ch 05

As soon as we got out of Kelley's car we were greeted by Natasha who performed her customary leap and wrapped herself around me and I had to carry her into the house.

"Hello you two, glad you could make it." Mum called from the kitchen.

I put Natasha down as Kelly wandered into the kitchen.

"What you been up to today?" I asked Tasha.

"Not a lot. I want to ask you something" she put her mouth close to my ear "when Kelly sat on your lap, why was her nighty pulled up?" She whispered.

Oh shit, I thought, how should I answer that?

"It just happened."

"But how?" She whispered.

"I don't know how it rode up" I paused "What do you think happened?"

"I don't know, you tell me?" She whispered again.

"We were being silly, well Kelly was trying to tickle me then I got something in my eye?"

"Is that the truth?"

"What do you think?" This was getting dangerous.

"But your thing must have been close to her, you know?"

"Her what?" I said.

"You know, her vagina"

"It may have been. Why do you ask?"

"Didn't you feel it touching you?"

"I may have done" I replied cooly. "But I was more concerned with my eye."

"Did she feel you?"

"You'd have to ask Kelly that."

"But I could see that you were hard and you were kissing so she must have felt it touching her."

"I kissed he to say thank you for getting the stuff out of my eye, I have no idea if she felt me touching her I didn't notice anything and how did you know I was hard?"

"I could see you were hard, I have seen you like that before." she looked embarrassed.

"When have you seen me hard?" I asked.

"That's my secret." She replied.

I would have to be careful in future.

"I thought that perhaps you and she were in love and well you know."

I nodded.

"I know what you mean, but we are brother and sister and that's illegal."

"But if you love someone, even your brother it should be okay." She had the most serious expression.

"I know what you mean and I feel the same but it's against the law."

She was silent for a while.

"Does that mean that me or Kelly can't share your bed?"

"No, next time there's a storm we won't get arrested and you know that if you have a bad dream, Mum and I will let you sleep with us" I paused " can I ask a favour?" She nodded "If you ask Kelly if she felt me will you tell me what she says?"

"I will." She said.

"Our secret, ok?" I whispered.

"You bet."

"You can't tell anyone or we could be in trouble, big trouble." I stressed.

She looked at me and just at that moment Kelly and mum walked in.

"What are you two up to?" She asked.

"I was telling Alan about Sam." Tasha said.

"Carry on, what else has he done?." I picked up on her lie.

"He keeps telling all my friends that I'm his girlfriend!" She folded her arms and looked angry, she was a brilliant actor!

I put my arm around her and pulled her close.

"Listen, when your friends tease you all you have to say is yes I'm a girl and he is my friend just as m I'm your friend but I'm not kissing him or you. Ok?"

"I'll try that." She said.

Mum winked at me.

"We have decided that as its Saturday we are going for a takeaway. What do you want?" We all placed our orders and mum and Kelly left.

I picked up my bag and went to my room to unpack. Tasha followed me.

"If Kelly sat on your lap and your penis accidentally went into her, would you get into trouble for that?" She asked.

"What sort of a question is that?"

"I just want to know that's all."

"Do you know what an accident is?" I replied.

"Em."

"It is something that happens that is beyond your control. If I opened the wardrobe and the door fell off and hit me in the face, that would be an accident. If I was sitting on my bed and I was hard and if Kelly sat in just the right place and I ended up inside her that would be an accident."

"Ok but it would have to be an accident?"

"Yes." I replied.

And with that she left. What was she thinking?

By the time I sorted my clothes out Kelly and mum were back with the food. We sorted out the orders and tucked in.

As we finished the phone rang.

Kelly answered it and handed the phone to me, it was Debbie.

"Al my dad has said I can't stay over tonight."

"I did think it was ambitious." I replied.

"Can I see you tomorrow?"

"Yes, what time?"

"Mum and dad will be visiting my uncles around 12, will that be ok?"

"I'll see you then." I replied.

"I can't wait, bye" she hung up.

"I had better make a move soon." Kelly said.

"Why not stay, you can always sleep with Alan?" Mum sounded odd.

"I should get home, the flat will need a good tidy up before Al starts staying over." Kelly replied.

"Okay, just a suggestion."

"What time do you want me to pick you up tomorrow." She asked me.

"Around 7." I suggested.

"Okay, I'll see you all tomorrow."

On the doorstep we kissed and I watched her drive away. As I shut the front door I thought that tonight would be the last time I slept alone for nearly a week.

The rest of the evening I spent watching tv with mum and Tasha, who was curled against me.

"I'm off to bed, don't you two stay up late." Mum said.

As soon as she was upstairs Tasha sat up.

"Kelly told me." She said.

"What did she tell you?" I was still stretched out on the sofa.

"Everything."

I thought she may be lying.

" Everything what?" I asked.

"The first time after the storm in the morning" I was frozen "and when I caught you when she was on your lap."

I was stunned, why the hell had Kelly told her?

"I wish I'd been Kelly."

"Okay Tasha what do you want?" I wondered what she would demand to keep quiet.

She looked embarrassed.

"I want the same as Kelly." She said.

"I can't do that" I took her hand in mine. "We could get into serious trouble. I'd be sent to prison and you'd end up in care" I squeezed her hand gently "you are too young. Kelly and me are taking a big risk but we are over the age of consent."

"Oh, I didn't know that." She looked very let down.

"Listen you have a lot of growing up to do and I think that your body and mind want to do things that you are way too young to do. Things that will hurt, maybe not physically but they can leave emotional scars. I don't want you to be hurt. More than anything I don't want to be the one that hurts you." I grabbed her chin and looked into her eyes "Lets enjoy what we have Okay?"

She nodded.

"You have to keep this to yourself, don't tell anyone."

"I won't, I promise."

"There would be massive problems if anyone found out." I emphasised.

She looked depressed but nodded her head.

"Come on lets go to bed." I said.

I pulled her towards me and kissed lightly on the lips.

"If it's any consolation I would love to be your first, now off to bed." I said.

"Really?" She brightened up when I nodded "Good night Al."

She went upstairs while I made sure everything was locked up and switched off. It was around 10.30 when I got to my room and undressed.

There was a small wrapped present on my pillow which took me by surprise. There was no note or writing on the paper so I opened it. Inside was a cassette with a note.

"Play me with your headphones on." It was mums writing.

I put the cassette in my player, put my headphones on and pressed play.

Muffled sounds like someone walking upstairs.

"What are you doing?"

This was followed by the sound of a door opening.

"It'll be fun and when she smells sex in her room she may think it's her imagination."

That was Kelly's voice!

"Sit on the edge of the bed." Kelly said.

Oh shit! That was the thunk we heard, the sound of a cassette recorder turning off, she'd recorded us!

"Oh God Kelly that's good! "

"God you are so hard" there was a pause "my legs won't take this."

I knew I should turn it off, my finger was on the stop button but I couldn't.

There followed sounds made by us moving around.

"Oh God you feel huge!"

I listened as Kelly gasped and slight creaking from the bed. Kelly's groans and gasping as I fucked her were turning me on. Listening to us have sex was unbelievable!

"I'm coming Al, oh Christ I'm coming!" Her voice was muffled.

Her yell as she came was so loud I jumped. The creaking sped up and suddenly stopped as Kelly yelled again.

I could hear myself panting for what seemed like minutes.

"Oh god Al, your still coming! " Kelly

"It's you Kelly, that was unbelievable" there was a pause "are you OK, it sounded like I'd hurt you?"

"Don't worry you didn't!"

The bed creaked a little.

"Mmmm, don't stop and don't pullout."

The bed creaked for a while longer.

"I could let you do that all day." Kelly said.

"I want to spend one day in bed with you, just playing and making love to my big sister."

"Ohh that's a date and soon!"

Silence for a while.

"You better get ready to catch." My voice said.

There was a click.

"What am I going to do?" Mums voice "what you two are doing is against the law. I should phone the police but do I want to have my family ripped apart because of this?"

I was shaking by now.

"What I want you to do is after 11 o'clock go downstairs and wait for me there, we need to talk."

Silence from the cassette.

I couldn't stop shaking. What the hell was she going to do?

I looked at the clock 10.40 shit!

Should I just get up and sneak out?

I could phone Kelly and ask her to pick me up?

No, if I did that it would only cause more trouble.

I decided to go downstairs and wait. Putting on my dressing gown I crept downstairs and waited. Time seemed to drag but 11 o'clock came and I heard mum creeping into the living room.

In the dim light I could just see she was wearing a red nightdress.

"What am I going to do." She knelt by the side of the chair.

"I don't know, I cant give you any excuse about what I, we have done." I was still shaking.

I felt her hand on my arm.

"Your shaking!" She whispered.

"I'm terrified, that's why I'm shaking!" I managed to get out.

She rubbed her hand along my arm.

"Listen, I can't stop you and Kelly, I'm not even going to try to stop you" she paused as If letting it sink in "I have a confession, when I was around your age" another pause "your uncle Mat, my brother and I had sex." This came out in a rush.

My mind was still digesting the fact that she wasn't going to stop us, so when this came out I was a little shocked.

"Really?" Was all I managed.

"Yes, we did for years."

Uncle Mat had been a really nice man, when we were younger he always visited on weekends and stayed sometimes for weeks, Now I knew why.

"I may as well tell you. He never married because of me and I loved him so much that no other man would do."

When he had died in an accident mum had been devastated and cried for days.

"Oh mum, things make more sense now, when he passed away I wondered why you were so upset." I reached out and took her hand.

"Both of us wanted to be together but he thought it best if he just visited. When you were at school I would often visit him, god I miss him so much."

I couldn't think of anything to say.

"Are any of us his children?" It sounded like a crude question.

"No Alan. I wanted to have his children but he always said it was wrong. Kelly was his idea we went out together and I told him I wanted to have children we then picked someone in a pub, Mat said it would be his child. We did the same for all of you." She said.

I thought long and hard before my next question.

"Why have you never had another man?"

"Good question" she moved a little "can we sit on the sofa it's a bit cool down here."

I said yes and I sat close next to her.

"After he died Mat left everything to me, thats why we have this house. There have been flirts with men but I loved Mat."

"But you must have had the urge?" as soon as I said this I knew it wasn't the right question.

"Of course, that's one of the reasons we have hands, I can always satisfy myself. But the feeling of a man inside you..." she stopped "sorry Alan that may be more than you wanted to hear."

She had her hand on her thigh so I covered it with mine.

"Don't worry, we are all human."

"A few things have me puzzled." She turned a little to face me.

"Okay."

"What are you going to do about Debbie?"

"Kelly has said that I should keep seeing her. She thinks it would help hide what we are doing." I told her

"Kelly's a clever girl but what happens if Debbie finds out?"

"We will deal with that if it happens." I lied.

"If you plan on doing" she emphasised doing "them both you are going to be knackered."

I had to chuckle at that.

"Your only young once." I replied.

"Oh that's so true."

We lapsed into silence for a little while.

"Natasha is growing quick. She is bound to find out."

"I know." I couldn't think of anything else to say.

"Please wait until she's old enough. She will want the same as Kelly, I can see it in the way she looks at you, she loves you so much."

"I know and I promise." She had moved her hand onto my right leg.

"I shouldn't ask but." She paused " why did Kelly scream?"

"Oh lord" I felt embarrassed "Well..."

"You can tell me." She was.

"She keeps telling me that I'm big."

"Are you?" She asked.

"I don't know, what's the average size?"

"Hummm your dad wasn't that big, how long are you?" She asked again.

"I really don't know!" I lied.

"I shouldn't ask this but..."

"You want to see?" Was this happening?

She nodded so I stood up and opened my dressing gown.

"Well I have seen you like this and you don't seem to be that big, I think you need to be hard."

I think the thought of my mother and her brother doing the same as Kelly and I or perhaps it was remembering the sound of Kelly yelling on the cassette tape. What ever it was things began to stir.

"Oh my God!" She whispered.

I looked down, in the dim light I could make out her face, she looked shocked. My cock was sticking straight out, not completely hard, her hand now rested on my left leg.

"No wonder she yelled." she was watching my cock intently.

Within a few seconds I was fully erect.

"I don't know what to say!" She hadn't looked away.

I felt her hand lift from my leg and her fingers traced down my dick then back to the tip making me shudder. I thought I'd be confused or maybe revolted being touched by her but I was turned on, perhaps I was turning into a male whore?

"I can't stop touching you!" She whispered.

I didn't reply. I just wanted to see what she would do. Knowing her hand was touching me brought back a memory, she had showed me how to wash myself. She had asked me to stand up and had pulled my foreskin back and washed me telling me how to do it right, I remembered the feeling of her fingers. Then a couple of years later she had asked me to show her how I washed myself. I had done so and she had taken my cock in her hands and checked it.

Her face was now inches away from my cock and she seemed frozen, I thought she was going to get up and walk away. Her other hand came up and she started to feel me with both of them, suddenly she sat up straight and leaned forward planting a kiss on the end of it. Then she sat back on the sofa. I remained standing for a few seconds then sat beside her.

"Are you ok?" I asked.

She nodded, then looked at me, stood up and in one motion she was straddling me, lifting the nightdress she was then holding my cock. Before I knew it the head of my aching cock was inside her.

"I'm sorry Al, I'm so sorry I shouldn't be doing this."

I remained unmoving, I didn't know what I should do. Slowly she pushed down until I was fully inside her.

"No, no, no!" She was unmoving "I've got to stop." Still she didn't move.

I could just see her face in the dim light. She looked red as if embarrassed.

"Jesus, that's so good" she hadn't moved, my cock was deep inside her "Al make me stop, push me away please!"

"Why?" I put my hands on her hips "when you are enjoying it?"

"I am but it's wrong, oh fuck." She was taking deep breaths.

"Just enjoy it."

She looked at me and we locked eyes. She lifted her hips and slowly lowered herself.

"Fuck!" She paused then her hips began lifting and lowering steadily "Its been so long!"

Other than my hands I had remained still, now I lifted my hands and felt for her tits. As I touched them she stopped and lifted her nightdress. I placed my hands on her breasts, I was surprised at how firm they were. Her nipples felt tiny but rock hard. All this time she had remained motionless with my cock inside her. She suddenly whimpered and her hips started their dance again.

"Don't come inside Alan, please don't!" She whispered.

Before I could say anything her hips sped up.

"Oh yes." She kept repeating as her hips slapped down on to me.

She stopped her movement abruptly, then slowly lifted her self up until just the head of my dick was inside her. I watched and in the low light I watched as she reached down and felt her fingers curl around my shaft.

"So big!" She murmured.

She lifted herself off and turned her back to me, reached around and grabbed my cock and I felt the warmth of her around me again. As she pushed back against my cock she let out a long whimper. I could see about an inch of my slick cock then she started almost frantically riding me.

I was desperately holding back but I knew I wouldn't be able to hold back my orgasam for too long.

"Oh fuck I'm coming, your making me cum!!" She gasped.

She slammed her hips down hard against me and let out a long hiss.

"Oh my god!" She stayed still and seemed to shiver I could feel her pussy grip me. " don't come inside me Al, please don't."

We stayed like that for a while as she came, occasionally lifting herself up and slamming down against me.

"You better get off me now." I whispered.

She lifted her self off my cock and as she did I erupted. Most of my cum spattered on my stomach and a little hit her pubic region.

"Shit I need to wash!" Mum said and literally ran from the front room.

I lay there for a while still not sure that I wasn't dreaming. There was a box of tissues within arms reach so I cleaned myself up.

I waited to see if she would come back downstairs. I could hear the sounds of taps running in the bathroom and when they stopped I decided to go upstairs. I grabbed her nightdress and left the front room. Getting to the bathroom I tapped the door.

"Wait, I'll be out soon." She said quietly.

I went to my room and sat on the bed. After a couple of minutes she came into my room with a towel wrapped around her.

"Alan I'm so sorry I just don't know why I did that..."

"Hey" I interrupted "it's okay you don't have to apologise."

She sat next to me.

"I feel bad about it."

"Why?" I turned a little to look at her.

"Your my son thats why!"

We fell silent for some time.

"Okay. I won't accept your apology because we both enjoyed what happened. Go to bed and tomorrow we start afresh. It happened and we can't change that, lets move on." It sounded wrong but I think she understood.

"Thank you son" she kissed my forehead and before she left said "when did you become so adult?"

I sat thinking for a long time before climbing into bed.

All night I had wild dreams involving Kelly, Debbie and mum. In one of them I had gotten all 3 pregnant and they were giving birth at the same time!

In the morning I dressed and went downstairs. The phone rang just as I was about to enter the kitchen, it was Debbie.

"Hi Alan, I have to go to see my uncle." She sounded fed up.

"Damm."

"I was looking forward to seeing you as well."

"So was I, all of you!" I said quietly.

"Me too."

"You have Kelly's phone number, if there's any chance of getting away I could persuade her to pick you up."