They looked like they could be twin sisters. Two hot athletic blue eyed blondes. Lee and Ann. Amazing and beautiful young ladies. There was some confusion for me when we first met. I had met Ann and instantly bonded. I swore she blew me off when I called her home on the landline the next day. It sounded like her. Turns out, it was her sister Lee and she never passed on my message.
Eventually Ann and I started dating. Once I met her older sister Lee I understood the confusion. She looked and sounded just like her sister. And, quite frankly, I found her incredibly attractive. I admit that I would often fantasize about Lee, even during sex with Ann. I imagined her catching us or secretly watching us have sex and becoming aroused and masturbate. Or even better, I fantasized that she would join us for a threesome.
There was this one time when we were all camping. Lee suggested that her and Ann should pretend to be twins and they were both dating me. As much as this aroused me I did not take the bait. I did, however, remember that moment. It was nice to know that the older sister was attracted to me. At least enough to want to play the role of my girlfriend. This made me incredibly horny. Later that night we all sat around the fire. She was directly across from me. I remember making eye contact with her. She spread her legs and lifted one onto her chair, giving me a perfect view of her hot pink panties. When I looked back up from her honey hole she was sporting a big smile. This aroused me and my semi-erect cock instantly swelled. I was wearing swim trunks with no underwear, so my erect penis created a pop tent between my legs.
Lee noticed. Her eyes focused on my erection. Ann noticed too. I felt my girlfriend's hand on my knee. Then she slowly slid her hand up my thigh to the crotch. She turned to me and put her leg over mine in an attempt to either hide my erection or her devious intentions. I felt her hand slide under my shorts. She grasped my cock and adjusted me so I was no longer restrained. It was so hard that the very tip of my penis poked above my waistband.
I tried to adjust myself but made eye contact with Lee who was gazing in my direction. I noticed that she had one hand curiously high on her own thigh. I watched as she slid her hand up to her own crotch. She was leaning back which made her panties tighten up over her vagina. Camel toe. I was blown away when our eyes finally locked and he smiled. She looked down to her crotch. I followed the instructions and looked down. I saw her slide fingers between her pussy lips very quickly. Quick enough for no one else to notice. Except me.
Nothing ever happened between Lee and I. We held these memories for over 25 years and never talked about it. But, being honest, I have fantasized about having sex with the older sister since we met. I would stay at their house, in her room. I saw her panties folded on her dresser. I could smell her perfume between her sheets, I would pull down my underwear and masturbate as I thought about her hot body between the same sheets. I imagined that she was doing the same thing when I wasn't visiting. I imagined her naked in her bed.
I fantasized that she was thinking about my naked body while laying in her bed. I imagined that she would masturbate and experience an orgasm as she thought about me. I even fantasized that she would join her sister and I for some taboo lesbian FFM action. When it was too much to handle and I needed a release - I would sneak out and into Ann's room. I would watch her sleep. She looked so amazing, beautiful and sexy. I would often pull her covers down to expose her half naked body. She looked so amazing in her white cotton panties and night shirt. Her ass. Her pussy. Everything about her aroused me.
There was this one night. The parents were up to camp. It was just Ann and Lee and I. The middle sister and younger brother were away. I was admittedly aroused by the idea of spending the night alone with the hot blonde sisters. Lee flirted casually with me throughout the night. Ann either didn't notice or care. Or, she secretly had a fantasy about a threesome with her older sister and I. Wishful thinking.
I planned on sleeping on the couch that night. After the three of us ate takeout dinner and watched two movies, Ann and Lee headed off to bed. I prepared the couch and shut out all the lights. It was a hot summer night, so I removed my shirt and laid on top of the blankets wearing just my boxer briefs. I was a little restless so I turned the TV back on and browsed the guide for something to watch. I had a clear view down the hallway. Ann and Lee's room, plus the bathroom. My mind wandered and began to think about catching Lee in just her panties walking down the hall towards me, making her way innocently to her bathroom.
Instead, I watched my girl Ann exit her room wearing just a pair of panties and a cropped Led Zeppelin t-shirt. I admired her body as she made her way into and out of the bathroom. She noticed that I was still awake. The light from the TV gave it away. She approached me with a goofy look on her face. Almost trying to cover herself with her arms.
"Hey baby," I said. "I have to say. You look super hot in those panties and tee. It makes my cock hard."
"Stop," she says quietly with a grin. "I think Lee is still awake."
"Even better," I say, pulling down my underwear to expose my swollen cock. "She can watch."
"Stop!" Ann says. "You're so bad."
She giggles and turns around to walk back to her room. I sit up and reach out, grabbing her by the waist. She doesn't resist. I pull her back and slide my hands around to the front, down to her vagina to rub her puffy pussy lips. I slide one hand up under her shirt to her naked breasts and gently rub. I pinch one of her nipples then the other. They get hard, just like my dick. I sat up and pulled her to my lap so we could grind. My cock fits perfectly between her firm ass cheeks, I can feel her hotness. I adjust so that the head of my cock is pressed against her hot hole. I reach down and slide her patnies to the side allowing my cock to enter her hot vagina. Just then we heard a noise from the hallway.
"Oh shit," Ann says. "We can't do this. My sister is still up and she'll hear us for sure."
