She was my sister and I loved her. But when Mom called and told me I had to have her up to the school for 4 nights I was pissed. It was the 4 day weekend -- Founders Day into Memorial Day -- and I'd been looking forward to the college parties and particularly to getting closer to Sandy- my new girlfriend. I was a sophomore and woefully undernourished in the pussy department, but Mom doesn't take no for an answer. She and Dad were off to Barbados, there was no one else, she didn't trust Annie over at any of her friend's homes, etc. etc. So that was that. They were celebrating Annie's 18th birthday Wednesday night and Thursday they'd be off and she, Annie, would be on her way here (and did I remember to get Annie a present?)
It was only 2 days later that I found out Annie wasn't coming alone. She called to make arrangements to meet at my dorm and casually dropped the bomb that Beth was coming with her. Beth is this super hot friend of Annie's who I'd known for 10 years, and had lusted after from afar in the way you do with a sister's hot friend. I had figured my getting her was pure fantasy until the night of my high school graduation. That's when she took me in my bedroom with the family partying below us and gave me what was still the best blowjob of my life. "Don't ever say I didn't give you something special for graduation Jeff," she said after with a big grin and a fat strand of sperm dripping from her chin. Then she was gone. I hadn't seen her since, so I marked it up to a blowjob where nothing leads up to it and nothing leads away from it. But now I reconsidered that and reconsidered the benefits of having Annie up with her best friend. Perhaps Sandy would have to wait.
Annie and Beth had been best friends since the 4th grade when we moved to town. Beth was a couple of months older but when both girls ended up repeating 5th grade for medical reasons (now all cleared up) the bond between them was really sealed. Annie was athletically lean from volleyball and basketball, tall, pretty, smart and funny. Beth got all the curves Annie lacked; she had just about a perfect body and face. Maybe she was a touch ditzy and more than a touch slutty (as my surprise bj demonstrated), but I was more than fine with the overall package. Annie was pretty, with maybe small B-cup tits, while Beth was the gorgeous cheerleader type -- C-cups for sure, a killer ass and the face of an angel. For a moment I worried whether Annie knew the special gift I got from Beth, but there had been no sign of it. I was already wondering if there was a way to lose Annie for a few hours so Beth and I could create more secrets to keep from her.
Annie got out of my Dad's SUV looking like a wholesome, well scrubbed tomboy. Fashionable, but not very tight, jeans and a couple of those spaghetti strapped shirts she loved. Beth got out the other side and winked over at me as I hugged Annie. She came in for her own hug. Beth was dressed like Junior Sluts on Parade, a plaid mini skirt to mid thigh, cute little fuck-me shoes, and a tight blue tee which hugged her free range tits. The shirt knocked off work somewhere north of her naval and nicely showed off her flat tummy and jeweled belly button. I wanted to cum just watching her walk over for the hug. Her eyes were made up, her long brown hair shined and she smelled like heaven.
Since it was still Thursday morning I had to get to one more class. Beth's hug had me pretty hard but I hid it well and asked the girls if they wanted to come along with me. Annie laughed and said they'd rather hang at the dorm. Off I went feeling kind of like a dope for walking away from that very hot piece of ass my sister had so considerately brought along for the ride!
Problem was I got back from class to find Frank hanging all over them -- or more exactly Annie hanging all over him with Beth laying on my bed watching. Beth's legs were together but the skirt was so short that I figured Frank had a view of her panties from his angle, even as he was bending over Annie to show her some chords on his guitar. Frank is my roommate, and a pussy hound way beyond my ability. He claimed to have fucked nine different girls before Christmas break our freshman year, and most of us believed him. I knew as soon as I saw the scene that he was working to fuck one of what I sort of thought of as my girls, leering over towards Beth as Annie practically rubbed her cute tits on his shoulder.
I looked at Annie and saw a girl flushed and excited by his attention. Then for one second I imagined leaving Annie to him so I could get alone with Beth, who was looking very sexy in the horizontal position. Then I thought of Mom and Dad and realized I needed to save Annie from Frank. His official count of pussy scored had recently crept (he said) to 24, and no way could I let him fuck my sister as number 25, not after the way I'd seen him treat other girls. Plus I was pretty sure Annie was a virgin, and a pretty pure virgin at that.
Frank actually already had a weird history of attraction with Annie. A year earlier my family had vacationed in St Martin's and I'd made the mistake of leaving my photos of the trip lying around. Frank found it and started in not only on Annie -- who was cute but not spectacular in her bikini -- but even on my mother. About Mom he made the usual MILF jokes (focused mainly on her tits which were actually well hidden in a modest bikini) and asked when she was coming up to visit. But the comment that most irked me -- I had to pretend to be amused but believe me I wasn't -- was about the picture of Annie bent over smoothing out her towel after a swim. Frank went on and on about her ass and how (he said) you could get a nice glimpse of her pussy outlined by her tight bikini bottoms. In his memorable line: 'Dude, you can totally see the outline of her cunt in that shot.' I knew he was just trying to get me going, but it still bothered me. It was hard to hear her young pussy described that way. But sure enough when I was next alone, I had to look closer and there it was -- a perfect outline of the lips of her pussy in the wet suit. The material had sucked up into her snatch just enough to make the camera shot perfect (if that's what you were looking for.) But I for one was not. Fuckin' Frank!
I got Annie out of there on the pretext of showing her the new gym where she might play basketball once she got to college. Beth said she'd stay behind, and I tried hard not to whine her in to joining us. I figured I had 4 nights to close the deal with her and that I'd better not rush things at the start. But leaving Frank alone with Beth was one of the harder things I'd ever done. It made me feel angry, sad and noble all at once.
Annie and I ended up goofing around at the gym -- playing a little one on one b-ball. She was a pretty good player, although with 6 inches of height on her and probably 60 pounds, it wasn't too hard to stop her drives to the hoop. One time an accidental contact sent her sprawling on the baseline, her rump in the air, and I flashed back on the picture that got Frank going. The skin tight short-shorts she'd put on for the tour left little about her ass (which is nice) or her crotch (notice I didn't call it her 'cunt'?) to the imagination. I tried to wash away the image by thinking of Beth's much rounder, fuller ass and what I'd like to do with it, but the Annie-image was still in there. And now it had company.
We hacked around the gym and the campus for 2 hours or more, and then went back to the room to shower for dinner. It was empty. With Annie in the shower I got Frank on his cell phone and made plans to meet out at the local Chinese place for dinner. He'd taken Beth down to show her the lake and campus and his lacrosse field house. Two hours after that we were done with dinner. Then the girls went back to the dorm to change for the big party. Frank and I were hanging out on the campus waiting.
He handed me a key and said "Hey, Bill wanted you to have this."
"OK, why is that?"
"So you'll have a place to sleep tonight."
"Huh?"
The plan of course had been for the girls to stay in our room on the floor. Their sleeping bags were already there, and already I'd pictured Beth a hundred times climbing into hers dressed only in skimpy lace shorts and a top. But light dawned on me,
"You mean you want our room to yourself?"
"Well, not exactly myself." He laughed then. "Uh... Beth and I are going to need some privacy, and Bill is gone for the night back home. So he gave me his key -- but only on the condition that you stay there, not me. He said something about not wanting my cum all over his sheets when he got back, but he was fine with you staying there. And there are 2 beds so you and Annie can both be comfortable."
Damn. Of course he didn't know I had a history with Beth so I couldn't fault him for that -- but still, damn him. I was afraid of the answer but asked anyway -- "You mean you two already got into it this afternoon?"