This story is part of a series. If you haven't read the previous chapters, click my username above. All characters are 18 or older. Thank you for reading.
* * *
Aunt Sandi - PART 26
When I got home from dropping Kayla off, Sandi and Amy were lying in bed talking. When I came through the bedroom door I heard Sandi excitedly saying, "Carlos being her father has advantages and disadvantages, really. On one hand, with a single phone call she could get us in real trouble if she wanted to, but she wants to be in our lives so much I don't think she'll ever say a word."
Amy looked at me and smiled, but continued talking to Sandi. "I think we can trust her. She's in love with Danny at this point and she'll do anything I say as long as she thinks she's getting what she wants."
I shook my head. "Man, you guys sound so devious and conspiratorial."
Sandi laughed and said, "Um, you were here when she told us her father works in the district attorney's office, were you not? We need to be very smart about this. There's a lot to consider."
I was already shrugging off my clothes and said, "I know, but you should've heard what she just told me before I dropped her off. She said she would do absolutely anything you want to be a part of our lives. She was saying crazy things like she'd sleep on the floor in a cage and have my babies and other stuff."
Amy sat up. "Why is having your babies 'crazy' stuff?"
Before I could answer Sandi jumped in. "She thinks we want to put her in a cage? That's a little out there even for me." Everyone laughed.
I looked Amy directly in the eyes. "I don't know what's gotten into you lately, but I told you I don't want to have kids yet. I think it's kinda crazy you're putting all these ideas in her head like I'm gonna start breeding her or whatever as soon as she moves in with us."
Amy's face dropped and she looked hurt, and I immediately felt bad. She said quietly. "I know, it's just something I've been thinking about a lot lately and it turns me on like crazy. I'm sorry."
I kicked off my socks and crawled up onto the bed and squeezed in between them. "I'm sorry, I didn't mean to hurt you, but I don't want you to think I've changed my mind about when I want to start having kids."
Amy wasn't quite ready to give up. She laid back down and said, "Well, Mia's already almost ten months old, and I've heard it's better to not have kids years apart because the closer they are in age the better it is for them developmentally."
Sandi echoed, "That one's true."
I leaned my head back and looked up at the ceiling. "You're both gonna gang up on me now, aren't you." They both giggled.
Amy added, "Don't you want her milk to keep coming?"
I laughed. "I mean, I like her milk a lot, but not so much I want to get her pregnant so I can keep getting it."
Amy could tell I wasn't going to be easily swayed and she let out a long slow exhale. "Fine."
I took that moment to make things worse. "So, I got a text from Jill asking me over. I suggested tomorrow night, so is that cool?"
Amy blew out another slow breath. "Oh, so you get to have your way but I don't get what I want? How is that fair?"
My temper was rising with the exasperated exhales and I was going to snap back with something I was sure to regret, but Sandi grabbed my arm and saved me. She said softly to Amy, "Honey, I know you're not happy, but you know as well as I do that talking about having babies isn't the same as him going to spend one night with Jillian."
She looked directly at me. "Your timing with that was dreadful and insensitive. That could've waited until we were finished with what she wanted to talk about."
I said, "Sorry, I thought we were finished." I looked over at Amy and said directly to her. "I'm sorry."
For a long moment there was only silence. Amy didn't say anything but she did turn on her side and put her arms around me. I pulled her in close and then Sandi did the same thing.
Amy finally spoke. "JJ already texted me about tomorrow night and it's fine. I already know what she wants but right now I need you to hear me about Kayla. She wants more kids, and not years from now. We talked about it for a minute when we were in the bathroom earlier. It's not like it's gonna be some huge disruption in your life since there'll be at least two women there all the time to look after them."
I hadn't really thought about it very carefully since I had assumed it was a new fantasy Amy wanted to explore, but it was sounding very real and important now. She was right though, there were going to be plenty of parental figures around to take care of kids and it wasn't even up to me alone to need to be able to support them financially since Sandi was able to do that easily. There really were few downsides other than my own reluctance.
"You really want this, don't you. It's not just a fantasy?" I asked.
Amy took a deep breath. "It started out as a fantasy, but the more I thought about how our lives are going to be, the more it made sense and now I really do want it, and I want you to want it too."
I asked, "What about you though? Are you wanting to get pregnant now too? I thought you said something like hating being fat and gross."
Amy giggled. "Yeah, but now I know we'll have all this support and I'm supposed to get my implant replaced in December and I thought that would be the perfect time to get it taken out and start trying."
"Wow." I let that word hang there in the silence before my thoughts found their way into words. "But what about school?"
She was ready for this too. "I don't think it'll be a big problem. Both our moms are stay-at-home so they'll be able to take care of the babies while I'm in class. I know it won't be as easy as I'm thinking, but I still think it'll be doable."
Again, all I could muster was, "Wow."
Sandi giggled. "You're a man of very few words."
I laughed. "I feel like this is something you two have been plotting to get me on board with and now you're even using Kayla and every other way to convince me. Have you talked about this with Mom and Lisa already?"
Amy giggled. "Of course we have, silly."
I shook my head. "Of course you have. I said 'devious and conspiratorial' as a joke, but clearly it's true."
They both laughed. Sandi said, "I'm pretty impressed you can see it for what it is. It's not quite a conspiracy but we did already talk about it with Dee and Lisa to get them on board before we came to you. We're women. We plan. Once we reveal what our plans are to you, it's a simple matter to convince you with some really good sex or an amazing blowjob. It's child's play, honestly. Speaking of amazing blowjobs..."
As if on cue, they both descended on me and started licking and sucking my soft cock. I whispered, "Devious, evil women."
Amy made a sound like "Mmm hmm" as she licked against my balls while Sandi tongued my tip. Even though I had already come multiple times that day, somehow they managed to extract one last load out of me.
When they were finished with me, we got under the covers and cuddled. Amy asked, "So will you think about it at least?"
In one last ditch effort I figured I would bring up the money issue. "But how am I gonna support all these kids? I wanted to have a good job first."
Amy giggled, "Um, unless you've forgotten, you have a wealthy aunt right next to you. She's rich, bitch."
We all laughed and Sandi had to echo it. "That's right. I'm rich, bitch."