The parents made the kids put their swimsuits on. The kids were more than happy to. It was a chance to escape Dad's shattered, sharp-edged gaze. Then Mom told them to go out on the dock and give her and Dad a minute to talk. Yes ma'am.
Dad, of course, was in shock. He scarcely shrugged when Mom said 'This should help,' and set two more special pills in front of him on the counter with a plastic cup of lukewarm tap water. He downed them distractedly. Chugged the water. Filled and chugged a second cup of water. Then sat down in the nearby dinette chair and stared out the window. The world outside was hard to look at.
"I know," Lacy nodded.
Dad looked at his wife. She was leaning on the edge of the counter, arms folded under her breasts. She had a look of serious concentration on her face. Dad was furious, and confused. Mom looked only concentrated. Dad felt the urge to yell, but suppressed it for fear of being heard by the children out on deck. He really, genuinely couldn't bear to be around them right now.
Mom, for her part, had a very strong sense that this was it. The make-or-break conversation that could change her family, for better or worse. In the time it had taken for Tracy and Seay to slink upstairs and change back into their suits, and then to send the kids out on deck, Mom had already rehearsed in her mind's ear a couple of different conversational flow-charts. She felt like she might realistically pull this off. All that was left now was to wait for her husband's next question. Then she would have a sense of how best to proceed.
"What are we going to do about them?"
Ah, so he's already thinking in terms of the long-term. He wants to know where we're going to take this. Mom was pleasantly unsurprised. Clark was a bit of a dope sometimes, but his heart had always been in the right place.
"Okay," Mom nodded. She sat down at the dinette opposite him, and took a breath before she began. "So, here's my take on the situation."
Dad waited.
"We have a very rare opportunity here."
Dad sighed frustratedly. Took a long beat. Then offered his hand as he asked, "How do you figure?"
Mom took it.
"We are being presented with a choice, Clark," she told him. She was trying very, very hard to keep herself from getting emotional. Feeling Dad's warm, safe hand in hers had triggered an unanticipated cascade of instinctual, disinhibitory responses. Her heart wanted to melt. But she willed it to cool down. They needed to maintain homeostasis for just a little bit longer. "It's a choice that I think we have a responsibility to get right."
"A choice?" Dad snorted in surprise.
"Clark. I know how it must feel. The first time you realize incest is more common than you thought. That it can even happen to you. Believe me. I know it's a lot."
"L-Lace, how can you -?! I don't even -"
"It's a lot," she repeated. "It feels like too much, at first."
"I - " Dad shook his head. "I guess. You clearly want to say your piece. Go ahead. Get it out."
"It is. A lot. But please. Just for a minute. Can you step back, and look at the big picture with me? From your perspective, and my perspective, AND their perspective?"
Mom actually did wait a beat for Dad to answer.
Dad shrugged stiffly. "I already said I'm listening, Lace."
"We do have a choice. We can condemn them, or we can not."
"That's the choice -?" Dad started to laugh. Mom's eyes grew sad, and he stopped himself. "Lace, come on. For real?"
"I'm not trying to make excuses for them. They crossed a very serious line. You're right. But before we can talk with them about that, I need to tell you, I think we might disagree about what line was crossed."
"Uh-huh. Right."
"Tell me. What line would you say they crossed?"
"Seriously?"
"Seriously."
"Well, forgive me for stating the obvious here," he waved his hand as if gesturing to something already very obviously sitting right next to them, "but for all I know, our son and daughter are having sex. Penetrative sex? I don't know. With protection? I don't know. Do they CARE if they get pregnant? I don't KNOW," Dad pounded the wimpy table, joggling its base, startling Mom, who was still holding his other hand. "Sorry," he muttered. "But. So. That's the line."
"I see. And so for you, the line is... incest."
"In-?! I-in a word," Dad falter-scoffed. "Sure."
"But, Clark," Mom whispered, and a subtle change came into her voice. She was Lacy again. "You might recall I have some experience in just this matter? And I can tell you, with total confidence in my heart, there is a safe, healthy way to make this work."
"You... did mention that," Dad squinted at her.
Mom looked out the family room windows, at the lake, the kids on the dock, and beyond. She could tell Dad was feeling impatient, defensive, very, very angry. But so was she, to be fair.
"We can choose to see our children for who and what they are, and accept that this is happening; or we can close our eyes, pretend we see whatever we want, and tell ourselves that this is not going to continue happening."
Dad frowned, but didn't interrupt.
"We can choose to help guide them through this - because yes, it will continue in some way or another, whether we ground them for life or not. Even if we do everything in our power to stop it - which may ultimately not just fail, but irrevocably sever them from us - the fact of the matter is, they have not finished their love story."
The tears were damnably close to pouring. She kept them back.
Dad did too. His throat worked a knot.
Mom, Lacy, reached across the table and laid a hand on his wrist. "Clark," she whispered, and then he looked up at her and his expression softened into a kind of desperate, tearful plea. "This is going to be okay. But you have to trust me. We have to do this together. We can do it, but only if you believe we can."
"Lacy, they were -"
"Being kids." Mom finished Dad's sentence for him. "Just two stupid, horny teenagers. Who happened to be siblings."
"But - " Dad's nostrils flared as his face clenched with revulsion. The memory kept hitting him in waves. "But - with... each other?!"
"Again, I'm not trying to excuse what they did. But it's not like we ever explicitly told them not to. I just want you to be open to the possibility that we can make this story a happy one. We choose to give them whatever consequences lead us to the happy ending."