SUNDAY MORNING & AFTERNOON
Fresh out of the shower, I used a washcloth to wipe the condensation off the bathroom mirror, wondering if I could still make eye contact with my own reflection. What had transpired over roughly the last 36 hours had changed my life forever. And not just mine. There could be no going back. Could I live with myself? Could I continue doing what I had just done?
As I began to ponder this existential line of thought, I felt a pair of soft slender hands graze along my naked midsection from behind. One hand reached up along my still-wet chest; the other reached lower and gently circled its slender fingers around the shaft of my long, flaccid penis. I looked down and watched that little hand, and my penis began to thicken once again.
Could I live with myself? Yes.
Then I felt the girl press her moist naked body against me from behind. I caught her reflection as she peeked around, her hair still as wet as mine from the shower we'd just shared.
My 18-year-old daughter, Cait, smiled at my reflection, and I smiled back.
Could I continue doing what I had just done? Yes.
I also found myself pondering the profound declaration my new incestuous lover had made early this morning:
I would love to share you with Mom...at the same time
.
My cock thickened even more. Cait let go.
"Oh no," she said, chuckling. "We just washed hours of sweat and cum off of ourselves, and my pussy is soooo sore right now."
I turned to her, smiling. "Don't worry, pumpkin. I definitely have to recharge my batteries again. I will let you recover."
"But we still stay naked, right?"
"Of course!"
She giggled with delight, causing her pert round tits to bounce hypnotically. She gave me a quick but passionate kiss, then twirled on her heel and raced out of the bathroom, grabbing a towel and wrapping it around her wet hair as she moved. She called back over her shoulder, "Coffee in five minutes, breakfast in ten!"
In a remarkable repeat of the previous morning, Cait and I idled away in completely normal small talk as we munched on breakfast. Just dad and daughter: but nude. We went with lighter fare this time, some yogurt with granola mixed in, washed down with OJ and coffee. I noted that it was going to be a warm and sunny day, and Cait suggested we enjoy the pool.
I grinned at the suggestion. In recent months, through a combination of adding trees, hedges and repairing fences, our back yard was now well shielded from view by any of our neighbors. Unless someone walked right up to the fence and purposefully peeked through a narrow gap, there'd be no way to know that naked people were splashing around. I had originally intended this to be able to freely skinny-dip with my wife, Heather, in celebration of becoming new "empty nesters." But now, amazingly, I was going to go skinny-dipping for the first time in the back yard with my cute young daughter.
I couldn't wait!
As we finished breakfast and put food away, plates in the sink, poured more coffee, Cait asked, "So how in the world will we ever be able to bring Mom into this?" By "this," Cait specifically pointed at my naked penis and then her smooth shaved vagina.
I swallowed, thinking, and said, "I really have no idea, but, to tell you the truth, I don't know that we ever will be." Cait gave me a disappointed look, and I stepped closer to her and put my hands on her shoulders. "Cait, we have to be realistic. The odds of you and me, father and daughter, connecting like this and being okay with it...they are almost infinitely remote."
"And yet it happened!" Cait insisted.
"Yes, oh yes." I smiled, proudly, allowing my eyes to wander to her large, pert, youthful breasts. When I was able to pull my gaze back up to her face, I said, "And I am very happy for that. But you realize, of course, that this is one of the most taboo things in society."
Cait glanced down in thought, and it was her turn to stare at my nakedness. Her eyes were glued to my cock, which hung limply but still thickly between my legs.
I went on, "There's also the fact that I am technically having an affair on your mom."
Cait looked up at me. She seemed to sense that I still felt a good degree of guilt about what we were doing. She reached up and touched my cheek, saying, "And that's what I don't want. I don't want Mom to think you're cheating on her." To reiterate, she repeated something she had said earlier: "I'm not just some random slut that you picked up at a bar."
"Of course you're not, my love," I said, cupping my hand over hers. "But you are still another woman I am now sleeping with. Your mother would have to be okay with sharing me with another woman, and
completely
this time, not just a fun, one-night college fling."
I had recently told Cait about the 'two-and-half-some' I had had, years ago, before Heather and I had gotten married but were steadily dating. As a kinky sort-of pre-marital gift, Heather had offered to arrange a night where I could share a bed with two girls. The only catch was I couldn't have actual
intercourse
with the other girl. Nevertheless, it had still been a highly erotic night, with me getting more than one blowjob from the other girl, and getting to have sex with Heather a few times, always with my cock being guided into my future wife by the other girl's soft hands...
Snapping myself out of the erotic reflection, I said, "Convincing your mom to let me have sex with another woman is one thing.
Then
getting her to accept that the 'other woman' is
you
..."
I trailed off, seeing from her expression that she was getting the picture. She lowered her hand and turned from me, momentarily at a loss for how we could ever reconcile the situation. Despite the seriousness of our current discussion, I couldn't help but look up and down the back of her naked body and admire it. Her ass cheeks were tight, round, and had the gravity-defying perkiness of youth. It also brought a smile to my face noting once again that she had the same adorable (and sensual) little dimples just above her ass, just as her mom had. With Heather, I had nicknamed those dimples my "thumb grips," because whenever I did her doggie-style and gripped her hips while pounding away, my thumbs nestled just perfectly in those little skin-divots. Cait was much more petite than Heather, so I was sure her thumb grips would fit perfectly, too...
Cait was turning back to me, and I made an effort to meet her eyes. She said, "Okay, we know it's a longshot. A really,
really
long,
long
, longshot. But it's still