When the title of this story popped into my head I figured I'd unconsciously plagiarized it. It seemed too obvious not to have been used before, but when I ran it through Literotica's story search function I didn't find it. If you, the readers, recognize it, please let me know.
I've been carrying iterations of this tale in my head for years. It's based on a fund-raiser I attended where the fifty-fifty booth was operated by a beautiful young woman whose looks, clothes, and make-up epitomized teen-aged innocence. Of course, a more sexual interpretation took root in my mind.
There are (or will be) two chapters. The daughters are Josephine Robertson and her best friend, Salma Gonzalez. Both lovely young women have a thing for their Daddy's. Josephine, of Scandinavian descent, is tall, thin, lithesome, nicknamed Jo, and the narrator of the first chapter. Salma, of Mexican ancestry, is dark, short, buxom and curvy, and narrates the second chapter.
As always, all story characters engaged in sexual activities are eighteen years of age or older.
* * * * *
I was naked, standing before my full-length mahogany dressing mirror, using a curling iron to give my straight light-brown, almost blonde, hair some twists and curves, aiming for a sexier look than the one I'd worn earlier in the evening. Of course, almost any look would have been sexier, for I'd dressed the innocent, an eighteen year old girl with only the lightest touch of make-up, clear lip gloss, manicured nails covered with a clear color, hair long and straight, and wearing a maxi-dress that hung from my shoulders to my ankles. If you saw me in that dress you knew I was slim and attractive, it was the kind of dress only a slim attractive girl looked good in, but what lay beneath was left wholly to the imagination.
I'd been working at a fund-raiser sponsored by Daddy and some of his friends, including Mr. Gonzalez, the father of my best friend Salma. The money would be used for several local charities. Daddy and his friends were still there, shutting down, counting the proceeds, but I could tell it was the best year yet.
My job at the fund-raiser was to sell raffle tickets and this year I'd sold more than ever. Those men couldn't get enough of this beautiful, oh so innocent teen. They bought tickets and flirted with me, then bought more tickets. I'd respond as an innocent, giggling as if I didn't understand what they meant or wanted, supposing that they kept touching me and bumping into me (sometimes with their hard man-things, they were so naughty) by accident, accepting their compliments at face value.
Occasionally Salma, shorter, curvier, and bustier, would take over and I'd wander around, feeling men's eyes on me, making sure Daddy saw it all.
It was a role I loved playing for a lot of reasons, but for one reason most of all. Knowing all these men were lusting for his sweet daughter, fantasizing about her, set Daddy's libido afire. Daddy would come tonight, knowing men throughout the city were fucking balling their wives and girlfriends while imagining it was me, and fuck me til our bed shook and my bones rattled.
And there'd be other man, by themselves, jerking on their jerking on their man-things, spewing man-juice, imagining stripping me, laying me on their bed, entering my innocent tight teen-aged cunt, shredding my hymen, filling me with cum, and turning this wide-eyed child into a cock-hungry, their cock-hungry, whore.
But, of course, that could never happen. Daddy had already done it.
But tonight Daddy wouldn't come home to the innocent girl who'd sold raffle tickets. (Not that I didn't love playing the innocent, we played that game often.) No, he'd come home to the satyress he'd created. Caressing a stiff nipple, feeling it through my body, I walked to the bed I shared with Daddy, ran my hands on the lacy black silk bra and panties, garters and stocking lying there, imagined how I'd look in them with my five inch open-toed stiletto heels.
I put on my choker, then the lingerie, was painting my lips and nails a dark sexy red when my phone pinged. Daddy was bringing Mr. Gonzalez home for a drink.
I thought about Salma, his daughter. I knew most girls would kill for my body: 5 feet 11 inches, 121 toned pounds, dress size 2, 31-23-34, "A" breasts, but for a day or two it would fun to be built like my short, curvaceous, buxom Hispanic friend; it would be fun to give Daddy some variety.
I went to my closet, picked out the form-fitting dress I'd wear over my lingerie, returned to the mirror, put it on. My green eyes sparkled at the result.
When I heard the cars pull up I filled two sifters with the good brandy, placed them on a silver tray, met Daddy and Mr. Gonzalez at the door.
I admired Mr. Gonzalez. Not that his eyes didn't linger on me, all Daddy's friends' eyes did that, but his did for only the briefest second. Daddy's other friends would stare, make some comment, noting, at least obliquely, that the innocent girl of an hour ago was gone, that this girl oozed sex, but Mr. Gonzalez didn't.
Of course, he was used to having a hot teenaged daughter in the house.
I took their coats, hung them up, cuddled up next to Daddy, and listened as they recounted the evening. I'd been right; it was the most successful fund-raiser yet.
* * * * *
The day after I turned eighteen, the morning after I gave Daddy my virginity, I told Salma. Daddy didn't tell me we needed to keep it a secret until that night, after we'd made love again, so that first time I hadn't disobeyed him, but I did when I kept telling Salma. A girl has to tell someone.
So the morning after the fund-raiser, hanging with Salma in her pool, she asked, "So tell me, what happened after my Daddy left last night?"
"Well, my Daddy told me I'd been a bad girl, cock-teasing men all long night just to sell raffle tickets. I told him he was right, I was a bad girl, I wanted to be good but I had all these nasty thoughts, that I liked it when men stared at me, liked it when they pressed their man-things to me, imagined sucking their cocks, letting them fuck me, I needed to be punished."
"What happened?"
"He told me to strip and I did, doing a little dance for him, then dropped to the rug, the big soft rug I like so much, stuck my butt in the air, said he should spank me, spank his naughty little girl. He did, it got me so fricking hot, then he fucked me; I came, over and over, lost track of how many times, and then he came and filling me with Daddy-cum."
"I'm so jealous. I want my Daddy to fuck me."
I glanced over Salma's shoulder, saw Mr. Gonzalez looking at us through a window. All morning we'd been prancing through his house in tiny bikinis that advertised our nubile firm flesh. It was nothing new; for the past months Salma and I'd been presenting ourselves to Mr. Gonzalez as sexual objects and the look in his eyes told me it was working. Still, I'd need Daddy's help to bring my plan to fruition. When I asked him I'd have to confess I was bad, that I'd told Salma. Maybe he would punish me!
* * * * *
That night, my naked body nestled against Daddy's satiated form, I said, "I love it when you come in my ass Daddy."
"It's an amazing ass Pumpkin."
"I feel sorry for girls whose daddies don't fuck them, who waste their time chasing boys who don't love them half as much as their daddies and when they catch one, all they get is an inexperienced boy who doesn't know how to use his boy-thing."
"Well, there are few daughters are as wonderful as you Pumpkin."
"Thank you Daddy. Daddy, Salma and I were talking about Halloween, about the usual parties with the usual people; it sounded pretty boring. We were thinking it would be fun to dress up, go into the city, they close off the park for a party. But it might be dangerous, two innocent teenaged girls all alone. We were hoping you and Mr. Gonzalez could dress up, come look after us."
Daddy smiled and said, "You told Salma about us, didn't you?"
He knew! I stopped, not sure what to say, but I couldn't lie to Daddy.
"Yes Daddy, I was bad. I told her after our first night, I had to tell someone, I was so happy and she's my best friend and she knew how much I wanted you, but then I kept telling her, even after you said I shouldn't."
"Did you tell anyone else?"
"No Daddy."
"Has she?"
"She says no, and I believe her Daddy. She's my best friend forever, she knows lots of stuff about me and never tells anyone. I trust her."
"I do too Pumpkin."