It was Saturday morning and Sara had the house all to herself, her mom was at a weekend conference for work and had taken her step-dad with her. Colton and Wes had decided to go on a small camping trip before they went back to school. They had invited Sara, but unless it was Cabin camping, she wasn't interested.
With a cup of coffee, she went to her step dad's (Andrew) study to grab a book. As Sara was leaving, Andrew entered his office colliding with her causing her coffee to spill all over his dress shirt.
"Oh shit Andrew, I am so sorry, I didn't even know you were here, I thought you left with mom yesterday morning, are you ok?" Sara said apologetically.
Andrew tried to wipe the coffee off his shirt; it wasn't working so Sara watched as he just took his shirt off. Sara drew in a breath as she watched Andrew's shoulder and pec muscles ripple as he slid his shirt down his powerful arms. His abs worked their way down his body as if sculpted from marble. Andrew was in his late 40s and very attractive with dark hair and blue eyes. Sara was caught off guard, she new Andrew worked out regularly, but she had no idea that was what he looked like underneath his dress shirts. In the 5 years, they had lived together, she had never seen him walk around shirtless, but now that she had, all she could think of was, way to go, mom. He broke her daze when he responded to Sara's assumptions, "Yes, I'm ok. It's a good thing you don't like your coffee that hot." He said offering her a smile before he continued. "I was supposed to leave with Helen, but my damn flight from New York got delayed so I wasn't able to make it home till late last night. It's fine though she got a friend to go with her at the last moment. Hey, where is Colton? I need to have a little conversation with my son." Andrew said looking up at her.
Sara's eyes were still roaming over her step father's chest and didn't hear the question, until he called out her name for a second time, "Sara?" He had his left eyebrow cocked, and a hint of a smile as if he knew why she was so distracted. She blushed and looked away as she answered his question.
"Sorry, but he and Wes went camping, they won't be back until Sunday night," Sara answered.
Andrew studied Sara for a moment with a frown. "Has Colton brought any girls over during break?"
Sara answered, "No sir, I've been home all week and I haven't seen any girls in the house."
"Are you sure? You wouldn't lie to me would you Sara? Andrew asked narrowing his eyes at her.
"Yes sir I am sure, and no I wouldn't lie to you, why do you ask?" Sara asked afraid that maybe Andrew new more than he was letting on.
Andrew continued to stare at her for a moment before opening a draw in his desk and pulling out a blue lace thong. Oh shit, Sara thought when she recognized it as hers.
"I found this on the floor by my bookshelf Tuesday afternoon before I left for New York, and I know it isn't my wife's, and if Colton hasn't had any girls in here, then do you want to tell me how your underwear ended up in my office?" Andrew asked.
Sara took a deep breath and thought 'Ok so maybe he doesn't know that I fucked his son in his office, if that is true, then I can still work this in my favor.' Sara answered, "Sorry about that, it must have fallen out of my laundry basket when I stopped in to grab a book." Sara said nervously. There wasn't anything more embarrassing than being caught by a parent in a sex lie. She prayed he would believe her, but something about the look in his eye said otherwise.
As Andrew took a few steps closer; Sara took a few steps back which landed her pressed up against the door. Andrew looked down at her with the most serious faced she had ever seen on him. Crap was this the "dad" look that all her friends talked about? It was terrifying.
"Sara, are you bringing boys into my office to have sex?" Andrew asked her in a low voice.
"No sir, I haven't brought any boys over. The only boys in the house have been Colton and Wes. I swear I never brought Wes in here." Sara was beginning to panic, she didn't want to get caught sleeping with Colton, and she didn't like how close to home that Andrew's words hit. Plus he was standing so close she could smell the Irish soap that he used, and that smell was messing with her brain and her pheromones.
"I believe you, so that leaves you and Colton fucking on my couch," Andrew said as he crossed his arms. He said it with such certainty that Sara dared not deny it, but how did he know? Dropping her thong was a great story, so why wouldn't he believe it? Then a memory hit her, when she was home for Christmas break, Colton had thrown a party and money came up missing from Andrew's desk, she remembered him telling her mom that he was going to install a camera in his office in case it happened again.
"The camera," Sara breathed; she went cold with fear as she stared up at her stepfather.
"Yes, the camera. I was in my office at work when I got a notification that the motion sensor had been triggered in my office at home, so I logged on to make sure it was just you or Colton. Imagine my surprise when I watched Colton lay you down on my desk and lick your pussy." Andrew paused to look at her face growing redder by the second and smiled, "I watched the whole 45 minutes of it Sara."
Sara closed her eyes as she felt a panic attack coming on, what was she going to do? What would her mom say? "Did you show the footage to mom?" Sara asked as tears began to develop on the rims of her eyes.
"Not yet." He answered and sat on the same couch Sara had fucked Colton earlier during the week. "I haven't decided what I am going to do about it. You two aren't related so I wouldn't say your actions were disgusting, taboo yes, but who doesn't love a good taboo. I also don't want your mom freaking out and sending you both to counseling." He sighed and ran his hand over his face. "What would you do to keep your mom from finding out?" he asked her.
"I would do anything, anything at all," Sara said desperately, she knew what he wanted. She also knew he was too scared to ask for it. If she was completely honest with herself, she was kind of curious about being with him herself, so she took his hand encouragingly.