~~~ Chapter Notes ~~~
This piece is part of a series. The story will make more sense if you read it from start to finish.
All of the chapters in this series have been completed. They are submitted to Literotica as a bundle. They should appear at a rate of one per day.
~~~ Aunt Sarah ~~~
A week before the Thanksgiving break, Sadie's mom showed up at the house on Friday afternoon, unannounced.
The girls and I had just come home from our classes and were working on a few household tasks - knowing that we'd be starting dinner soon.
Grandma got Aunt Sarah a glass of wine. She sat at the dinner table as the four of us worked on preparing the evening meal. Most of her glass was gone by the time we got everything ready and brought it to the table. Grandma offered her a refill - but she turned it down.
Dinner conversation consisted of nervous chatter about schoolwork, jobs, and updates on family.
Finally, we cleared away the dishes and returned to the table.
I nervously ran my fingers over the sides of the water glass that sat in front of me.
Aunt Sarah turned to Grandma.
"I need to have a conversation with my daughter and Derek," she said.
"Unless it bothers you," Grandma replied. "Ellie and I would prefer to stay."
Aunt Sarah looked from my grandmother to my sister - who nodded - and back again.
"It's a ... rather delicate situation," she said.
"The kids and I have grown very close," Grandma told her. "I realize that Sadie is still your daughter but there's not much hidden around here."
"Then you are aware, are you, that the two of them are having sex?"
Grandma's facial expression didn't change.
"Yes," she said simply.
Her calm demeanor and lack of alarm caught Aunt Sarah off guard.
"I see," she said. "How long has this been going on?"
Grandma glanced around at the three of us. I don't know what Aunt Sarah interpreted from Grandma's look - but - what I got was: "We're only admitting to what she already knows. Keep the story straight in your head and don't mess this up."
"Shortly after Sadie joined us," I believe, Grandma said.
"Yeah, like the first night," I thought, thinking back to our sexy-time in the tent.
"This doesn't bother you?" she asked.
"They're exploring," Grandma replied. "They're old enough to make up their own minds and - if forced to hide it - might make things worse. She's on the pill."
"Ah ... yes," Sadie's mom stammered.
Her momentary bit of righteous indignation had been snatched away.
My first cousin and I were having sex. Everybody knew about it. Now what?
"My ... uh ... sister and my husband ... would not be so ... understanding ...," Aunt Sarah said.
Her words were somehow strong - and yet weak - all at the same time. Grandma cut to the chase.
"... and the price - for you to keep their secret - is that you wish to share your daughter's lover?"
"John ... John does not like to have sex anymore," Sarah told her.
"You can keep your excuses to yourself," Grandma said to her. "You came here - not to judge your daughter - but to taste the forbidden fruit for yourself. Do not sully the girl's image of her father in order to justify your lust."
"You're ... you're right," Aunt Sarah admitted, her head lowered.
"Derek, your aunt knows your secret. The price - for you to continue your relationship with her daughter - is for you to take the girl's mother to your bed."
Aunt Sarah's eyes shot up to mine. I looked at Sadie.
"Sadie?" I asked.
"What?" she said. "It's not like you can tell her 'no'. She's right that daddy wouldn't take it well."
Sadie turned and faced her mother - but she was still speaking directly to me.
"Make her scream your name as she cums on your cock and there will be no secrets for her to tell anymore."
If I thought Sadie's words would cause her mother to reconsider, I was wrong. Aunt Sarah turned back to look at me. The doubts and fears were gone - now that she could see her prize clearly.
"A word, Derek," Grandma said.
I got up and followed my grandmother to her room. She closed the door.
"Be kind to her. I know you and Sadie are a little unhappy with the woman right now, but I don't want you to retaliate in any way. I don't want you to belittle her. She will be your lover tonight. Show her the same love and affection that you show the rest of us. She's nervous, she's a little scared, and she's horny. Make love to her, my boy."
"Yes, Grandma," I said.
She hugged me and gave me a peck on the lips.
"Make her scream your name as she cums on your cock," she ordered, smiling at me.
"I will," I promised, smiling back.
We returned to the dining room and Grandma suggested that we play a few card games - which told the rest of us that we were not introducing Aunt Sarah to the hot tub.
We dug out a deck of cards and played a few games. Spoons was actually way more fun with five of us - but it was obvious that Aunt Sarah really had nothing on her mind except getting my cock inside of her.
I had to admit that I was actually getting a little worked up, thinking about fucking my mom's sister. I was already fucking my dad's mother and this would kind of even things out, in a weird way.
Thinking back to that night in Sadie's bed - and the noise that I thought I'd heard in the hallway - I decided that had to have been her mother.
We played another round or two of Spoons and then Grandma told Aunt Sarah to grab her bag and follow me to my room.
~~~
I wasn't sure how she wanted to proceed. She'd been fidgeting the whole time we'd played cards - wanting to escape from the others - so I stripped off my clothes and stood in front of her.