It Started With Two Then Became 4

Part Three: Mom Makes Four

~*~

AN: Story Revised 1/2025 - With the blessing of the author, I have created this version of the My Sister Eva by dezurtdawg. If you haven't read that story I highly recommend it. All characters in sexual activities are 18 or older. Nitpickers, please accept that the narrative occasionally is first person from the POV of the main character and that the grammar is how I intended it to be. Thank you and I hope that you enjoy this story. Let me know what you think.

Story has been updated and revised from the original version.

~*~

~ November: The Weekend Before Thanksgiving ~

Life over the next three weeks settled into an exciting routine for the girls and I. Felicia being a senior was in the final part of her second to last semester. As such, she was swamped so when she had a free moment to spare I made myself very accessible to her. She was spending so much time in the library or just studying in her room that Amber and Evie would stop in to ensure she was eating or resting. When their schedules permitted they helped her with any work they could (as did I). It warmed my heart to hear that the girls were taking care of Felicia to the point the three had grown as close as sisters.

I have to admit that I have been laughing quite a bit these days. Why you might ask? Because due to the change in our relationship, my mother was going out of her mind. She did not know what to make of the sudden silence in the house. Evie and I were both still living with our parents, but all of a sudden Evie was no longer yelling at me every time I crossed her path. It actually got to the point that my mother checked Evie's temperature and asked her if she was on recreational drugs when that result turned out normal. Evie stated that she and I had come to an understanding, and as such we were on much better terms now. Still, my mother kept an eye on my sister during the day to ensure she wasn't planning something against me. Of course, the real reason for my sister's subdued behavior was the fact that every night that I wasn't with Felicia or Amber wasn't spending the night (My mother noticed that Amber's sleep-over activities went up dramatically since Halloween for some mysterious reason), Evie was in my bed with my cock either buried in her mouth, pussy, or ass.

Evie, Amber, and I managed to keep everything on the down low for the first two weeks of our new relationship. Eventually, the law of averages caught up with us on the third weekend. It was after midnight and Amber was currently in my bed, on her hands and knees and I was having my wicked way with my soulmate. Normally I make a nice eclectic music playlist to help mask any sounds we might make. Unfortunately, a brownout killed my sound system in the middle of the most powerful and loudest part of our lovemaking. Our nocturnal activities woke my mother who came up to see what all the racket was (as my dad tended to sleep heavy). Amber was in the middle of howling into my pillow when the door flew open and there stood my mother.

As I tended to go primal during my bouts with the girls, particularly in this position, I didn't hear my mother gasp, nor did I realize that she was even in the doorway. I was concentrating on Amber and bringing her to the brink of ecstasy. The room reaked of the auroma of sex, was filled with the sounds of flesh slapping against one another, my bed springs squeaking, and the muffled sounds of Amber screaming into my pillow. "Big... ooooohhh gawd, my man is sooo BIG!"

"I'm cumming!" I announce to Amber who is herself finishing her third climax of the night.

As she has the birth control implant I never wore condoms so I gave my lovely Latina a cunt full of cum which set her off even more. We have begun discussing our future and what I plan to do after high school. While I could go to college I was looking into tech campuses intending to do something in the tech field. Amber informed me that the birth control implant that she and Evie were on lasted for 3 years which would take her into her junior year. She told me at that time she would need to get a new one which I understood as she would have one more year of cheerleading to finish. She tells me that while she can't wait to make a baby with me she will get the replacement for her senior year and then cosplay model for the duration of the implant. After which she will never get another implant and we can go to work making our family. This was all information I ended up relaying to my mother at a later date.

Just as I pump the last of my sperm into Amber's receptive womb my mother screams, "Dylan Ryan Martin!"

That was enough to get me to pull my cock out of Amber and it was the first time in five years that my mother saw my cock in all of its glory. My mother froze in shock when she saw it as it had not yet deflated so she got to see me in all my glory. Her eyes moved to Amber who was lying face-first on my matress from exhaustion. Her head was tilted to the right and her glazed eyes more than likely saw my mother but based on our previous sexual encounters, three orgasms were her limit before she crashed out.

As Amber is still hunched up on her knees my mother can't help but see my lover's pussy on display. Amber's legs are parted and just as she is about to collapse my Mom sees a large stream of my cum trickling out of Amber's pussy. This is of course from me packing my lover with my life-giving seed two previous times. Once her body is down I pull the covers over Amber's naked body and once my mother finally comes to her senses she shakes her head and glares at me. I knew this day would come eventually and I always hoped that Amber or Felicia would be the one she caught me with first. So with no shame whatsoever, I turn around, find my boxers, and pull them on. Clearing my throat, my blushing mother turns and gives me a look.

"How could you? How could you have sex with your sister's best friend? How long has this been going on?"

"Amber and I are in love, Mom. We have been together since Halloween. Evie not only knows about our relationship but she is ok with it." I inform my mother.

"Based on the last six years I really have a hard time believing that." My mother informs me.

"Feel free to ask her yourself in the morning," I tell her.

"What about the fact you are not using protection? Didn't your father have that talk with you... or your school when you were younger?"

"Sure they both gave me the facts. However, Amber has a birth control implant in her body. As such she has forbidden me from using any contraceptives. What's a man to do Mom?" I ask.

My mother is partially relieved that one of us is taking protective matters but she scolds me and reminds me the only real contraceptive is abstinence... or surgery. I remind her that someday she might want grandchildren so surgery isn't an option for now.

"Send her back to Evie's room and get to bed." My Mom states.

"Sorry, Mom... Amber's currently in an orgasmic coma. She'll be dead to the world for the next few hours."

Curious at this statement, Dylan's mom walked over and looking at her daughter's best friend, saw that she was indeed dead to the world from sexual exhaustion.

"I promise you that I will just be snuggling my lady love so you can sleep." I move Amber into my loving embrace and she reflexively smiles and wraps her arms around my body. "We will see you in the morning."

My Mom left the room after I made my declaration. She probably wasn't happy with me but closed and locked my door.

As I stared up at my ceiling holding my Latin goddess in my arms I couldn't help but recall the look on my mother's face. I loved the expression of shock and awe at the notion her son was sleeping with his daughter's best friend. Amber moaned when her naked pussy came in contact with my dick once more. She her leg and knowing what she wants, I slide my cock back inside her pussy. She gasps aloud at the feeling of my inside her. I loved the feel of her massive breasts melded against my chest. Her legs intertwined with my own. Despite this I kept my promise to mom and didn't fuck my lover. Soon I drifted off to sleep, wondering how my Mom would deal with the realization that not only was her little boy not so little anymore but that he was a sexual creature.

I must have really worked over Amber that night as she was still unconscious when I got up at 10 in the morning. I quickly showered and dressed. When I walked into the kitchen Dad was already gone, having left to go golfing with my Uncle Ted. The pair had a golf tournament coming up with some of their work colleagues over Thanksgiving weekend so they were going to be at the golf course all weekend. Evie was sitting across from Mom. When she saw me my sister winked at me. I open the refrigerator getting out the glass pitcher of orange juice.

"Good morning Evie, Mom." I kiss them both on the top of their heads and make my way to my seat. Once seated I say, "Evie do you mind that I'm dating your best friend?" I ask my sister.

"Not at all." She answers honestly. "As long as you make her happy and promise to never hurt her... I'm happy for the both of you." Evie replies sipping her OJ.

My Mom gave the two of us a look like she was about to have a cardiac event. I decided to further mess with our mother by leaning over and kissing Evie's cheek. Evie blushed because when I leaned over to kiss her I snaked my hand into her shorts and squeezed her ass.

"Ok... who are you two and what did you do to my children?" Our Mom asks when the color returns to her face.

"It's quite simple Mom..." Evie begins, "Amber and Dylan love one another. Amber laid it out to me how rotten I had been to Dylan and now that they are in love she wasn't going to put up with my attitude and treatment of Dylan. Amber told me I had to either change my ways or they would both cut me out of their lives. So this is me turning over a new leaf."

My Mom had to play referee for so long between us that I think she took the sudden detente at face value. I'm sure she was going to be watching us... Evie in particular, for any shenanigans. I drank my juice, poured another glass, and after plating food excused myself to go attend to my lady.

~ Thanksgiving Day ~

Thanksgiving Thursday was a very fun time this year for my family. My Uncle Ted Chambers, Aunt Jessica (mom's sister), and cousin Melissa were present. In addition to the Chamber's family, Amber and Felicia were joining us for the meal. Evie started bringing Felicia around the house and introduced her to my parents as a new college friend that she met at the Halloween party (a true enough story) and asked Mom if she could join us for Thanksgiving as she was staying at school for the holiday break. Mom found Felicia to be very pleasant and helpful so she welcomed the older girl and told her that she was more than welcome to join us on turkey day.

My Mom and Aunt prepared the meal as was their standard tradition. Evie and Melissa were drafted into helping this year as they needed to learn from their moms what goes into making a real Thanksgiving meal. While they were in the kitchen cooking my father and uncle went out to the driving range as they knew the owner and had arranged to have the place to themselves for four hours. That left me with the task of keeping Amber and Felicia occupied for the day. Using Evie's car I drove to Amber's home, collected my beautiful lover, and drove over to Felicia's apartment. Amber and I knocked on her apartment door and were told to enter. We were greeted by a dimly lit room, soft music, and Felicia wearing a black babydoll teddy.

I help Amber out of her clothes and insist that my lady have first dibs at Felicia. I love the contrast in Felicia's paler creamy complexion blended with Amber's tan complexion was a sight to behold. The pair kiss passionately, tongue's interlocked, and as their hands begin traveling along each others bodies. Looking at the pair you would never know that Felicia was completely straight a month ago. Amber and Evie have completely turned her into a bisexual girl who loves Evie and Amber as much as she does me.

As we are making use of Felicia's space and the fact she hasn't had as much loving as my other two ladies, I think it is only fair that she gets the first taste of my cock.

"Ooooooh God..." Felicia groans. I parted her and Amber's legs and slid my body into the opening and slipped my cock into Felicia's hungry pussy.

The three of us made love in various positions over the course of the next few hours. Both girls received two servings of my cock juice. I opted not to do three orgasms as I didn't want either of them comatose while we were supposed to be eating. I gave the girls first dibs at the shower but I watched their titillating shower play. Amber let Felicia stay in the shower and help me wash up. Once we were clean and redressed we make our way to Felicia's living room and sit on the couch snuggled together, kissing and just enjoying one another's company. When my alarm went off at quarter to four I get up and helping my ladies to their feet we bundle up and make our way to my house.

It was 4:12 PM when the three of us arrived at the house for the grand meal. My mother greeted us but she had an odd look on her face after hugging Felicia and Amber. I got the impression she wanted to say something to me but my father and uncle arrived right behind us so she didn't have time to. Thanksgiving dinner was amazing and as the Martin and Chambers women had prepared the meal, Felicia, Amber, and I volunteered to clean up the dishes and put away the leftovers. The adults were all planning to call it a night early as Dad and Ted were going golfing again tomorrow while Mom and Aunt Jess were getting up early for Black Friday shopping deals. They decided that they would be heading out tonight and staying at Ted's home as it was closer to the golf course.

This year Evie and Melissa wanted to go spend some of their savings and Amber asked to join them so she was sleeping over tonight. When she had a chance to corner her, my mother pulled Amber aside and insisted that she stay in her own bed tonight, particularly since they were getting up at 2 am. Evie suggested that the girls that were all going out shopping sleep down in the living room slumber party style. Aunt Jessica could have the guest room, and as Felicia wasn't going shopping she could have her room and I would take her home later tomorrow.

With the sleeping arrangements, all made everyone went to bed. Dylan made the rounds to make sure the house was locked up, kissed all of the ladies good night (some more thoroughly than others), and then announced he was locking himself in his room. About midnight the only two people in the house that were still awake were the only two not going shopping in a few hours. When the house was silent Felicia slipped out of Evie's room and made her way to mine. My door was unlocked an hour after I entered my room but Felicia rectified that after entering. Knowing we had to keep the noise down I made slow passionate love to Felicia's missionary style. While some find the position boring I really enjoy having my lover under me, skin pressed closely, and kissing as lovers do.

We had just finished making love for the second time when I heard a little jiggle of my door handle. I suspected that it was my Mom testing to see if my door was unlocked so I could partake in nocturnal activities with my girlfriend. Well, she wasn't wrong... I did have my girlfriend in bed with me, and we have been having sex, it just wasn't who she thought it would be. Of course, she couldn't get in without picking the lock but with time being an issue, she simply stopped when my aunt exited the guest room and went downstairs to see if Amber was there, which she was. Felicia and I listened to the five women trying their best not to make a lot of noise as they left the house.

From my room we heard muffled voices followed by the front door closing. I had my chestnut haired beauty release me so I could verify that my family and Amber were gone. After verifying that we had the house all to ourselves, I decided to be naughty. Collecting Felicia, I take my naked lovers from my room and brought her to my parent's king-sized bed. She was a bit nervous but I simply flipped the covers off of the bed, pull my beautiful older woman don't the bed, climbed between her legs, buried my cock inside her pussy. My lover quickly forgot about the idea of fucking in my parent's bed and soon rolled me over and was on top of me. My cosplaying beauty was soon riding herself to her third and loudest orgasm of the night so far.

However, I wasn't done with her. Planting her on her stomach I take hold of her wrists and before she knows it I have slipped a pair of handcuffs onto her pretty wrists. Where did they come from you asks? I placed them in between my parents boxspring and matress the day I fucked Evie here. I just never used them. With her arms behind her back, I prop her up on her knees. Felicia has a look of fear on her face as this is all new to her.

"You have the right to remain silent... but something tells me you are going to be waiving that right," I say as I grope her magnificent breasts.

Holding her up around her waist with my left arm, I fist my cock and dip it into her soaked pussy. Once properly coated I pull out of Felicia and force my cock up her ass. Felicia screams loudly as I begin roughly (but not too rough) fucking her sexy ass. Felicia had shared this little fantasy scenario with the girls during one of their girl talks and Amber relayed that information to me. As I want my ladies happy it was with great pleasure that I would do this for Felicia.

I fucked Felicia's ass for a good while until she reached her anal climax. As her ass milked my cock I flooded her bowels with the last of my seed and once exhausted, I released my lover's bonds. Felicia's body was limp and as tired as we were I couldn't allow us to fall asleep in my parents bed. So lifting her up, I carry this goddess back to my room. Once we were in bed I return, lock the door, then snuggled up to her. Felicia, near exhausted, climbs atop me and slept on top of me, and we stayed like that until we woke up six hours later.

Unfortunately, I did have to return my lover to her apartment as she was working on a project for work that was due Monday. So we woke up at 8:00 in the morning, showered together, and played a bit but nothing too heavy. Once dressed I made us breakfast and we sat like a newlywed married couple holding hands, chatting and kissing. While she collected her things, I packed up some leftovers for Felicia to indulge in for the next couple of days. Sadly, I driving her back to her apartment. We said our goodbyes and kissed in the car one final time as Felicia and I knew we would be too tempted to continue playing if I went up with her. I do have self-control but these three are very good at making me forget that little fact.

Feeling quite energized I went home and uploaded the next set of photos to the girl's website. It was a nice site that I had fun designing. The girls split all the subscription fees equally and gave me a stipend for my work based on their monthly total income. As Felicia's schedule was the most hectic we always did several costumes per shoot and divided them up over the month. Each month the numbers went up as I advertised their photos on all the major social media sites to garner interest in my ladies. A few free photos (all super sexy) are a good way to entice people to part with their hard-earned money and support three sexy college co-eds.

I thought it would be late afternoon when the ladies returned but I was surprised to hear the front door just after noon. From the voices, I guessed Evie and Amber had returned and from the sound of it, they were weighted down.