"I love your house. What do your parents do?" Melanie asked as she carefully dipped her tortilla chip into the guacamole that Nicole had set out. The four girls sat around the table in the downstairs recreation room. It was where Nicole's father often played poker with his friends in the neighborhood.
"Honestly, I have no idea. They've explained it to me a bunch of times. Finance, accounting, who the hell knows. Money stuff."
"I'll say," said Sarah as she looked around the spacious and modern basement.
All four girls remained in their bikinis as they sat eating and drinking. The alcohol was starting to flow as their conversations started getting more and more racy.
"Ok so tell us more about Brad, Melanie." Julie announced.
"What do you want to know?" Melanie took a sip of her Truly.
"Was the sex good?" Nicole asked.
Melanie blushed as she smiled. "It was good... Yup, he was really good."
The girls were not satisfied with Melanie's vagueness. "No, no, no. You're not getting off that easy. Brad's hot. We want to hear more about him."
Melanie giggled. "Ok, ok. Jeez. Ok so there are two things I remember the most. One was that the dude could go all night. I'm not even kidding you. He would be hard immediately after sex. Just like..." Melanie then made a gesture with her hands. She held one arm up straight and made a fist while clutching her elbow with her other hand. Indicating a rock hard erection.
"Wow. Well, what's the other?" Nicole asked, eagerly.
"Like I said before. His dick. Definitely his big dick," Melanie said with a serious face, nodding.
All Ryan heard was "his dick." He froze as he came down the stairs. Undetected by anyone, he stopped and listened to the conversation. Were they talking about him? Did Sarah tell them what just happened? He hoped this wouldn't ruin his chances with Julie.
"What about it?" Nicole asked. Ryan was intrigued to hear his sister weigh in on the topic.
"It was fucking huge! He whipped it out and I was stunned. Speechless, really."
"How big was it again?" Nicole asked impatiently.
Ryan's heart skipped a beat. They had to be talking about him. He suddenly regretted showing himself to them when Nicole left the pool. Now he would seem like a pervert.
Melanie thought about the question before holding her two index fingers up. The girls studied her response before making a guess.
"That's like, what? Seven?" Julie guessed.
"Had to be." Melanie responded.
Ryan exhaled. They weren't talking about him. He was much bigger than seven inches.
"Felt amazing. I love big guys," Melanie admitted to the group. "Such a full feeling."
Noticing the coast was clear, Ryan headed for the girls. "Hey guys." As he rounded the corner, the girls looked over.
"Ry guy!" Julie cheerfully greeted him, patting the open seat between her and Sarah. He happily sat down. Sarah shyly made eye contact with him. He could have sworn she blushed a little.
"What were you guys talking about?" Ryan asked as he cracked a beer and took a sip.
"Big boys," announced Melanie. Sarah and Julie giggled.
"Big? Like tall?" asked Ryan.
"Let's play a game!" Nicole interjected, hoping to change the subject now that her brother was there.
"I like games," said Sarah as she sat up, getting comfortable. "What should we play?"
"Oo oo! I know. You guys wanna play Quarters?" Julie asked as she jumped up and headed for the kitchenette.
"How do you play?" Ryan asked.
Nicole rolled her eyes. "Ryan you have got to get out more. It's a drinking game. You bounce a quarter on the table and have to get it into a glass. Last one loses."
"Yeah it's super fun actually!" Sarah added. She smiled at Ryan. There was no doubt some chemistry was forming there. Ryan pictured her expression when he orgasmed earlier and it caused a tingle in his crotch.
Julie arranged five highball glasses on the table. One in front of each of them. She then handed out quarters to everyone.
"Ok. Last one to get it in loses, but what do they lose?" Ryan asked as he carefully stacked his quarters.
"They have to take a drink!" Melanie suggested.
Julie rolled her eyes. "That sounds like a reward more than a penalty. Hmm. How about they have to take an article of clothing off!"
Sarah and Melanie loved the idea, especially since it may mean getting to see Ryan's dick again. But there was one problem. Nicole was there. Everyone looked at her to get her reaction to the proposal.
"I don't know you guys," she said hesitantly. If she lost, she'd have to bear it all for her brother, but if he lost she'd have to see him naked again.
"Ninz, easy. Just don't lose!" Julie suggested to which everyone, even Nicole laughed.
"Seriously we don't have to take clothes off. That's fine, Nicole. Not if you're uncomfortable," Melanie said.
Ryan had yet to weigh in, but thought it'd be best to side with Nicole even though he desperately wanted to see the girls or, better yet, show himself off again. "Nicole, she's right. It's silly. Let's just play for fun."
After a long pause, Nicole took a long swig from her drink and looked up at the group. "Fuck it. Let's do it. If I'm getting naked, Ryan we're blindfolding you!"
"I'll blindfold myself!" Ryan exclaimed. Everyone laughed. The game was on.
The girls granted Ryan some practice since he had never played before. After a few rounds, he seemed to be getting the hang of it.
"You ready?" Julie asked eagerly. Ryan nodded "Yeah let's go!"
Julie laid out the rules which were simple. Everyone had to sink five quarters into their respective glass. Last one to do so would have to remove one article of clothing. With the girls all in bikinis and Ryan in a t-shirt and bathing suit, everyone started at an even two articles.