Judi was thinking about what else Molly had that was virgin, and it hit her. Molly's ass was still virgin, come to think of it, so was Judi's. Judi wanted to see David claim that last bit of her sister's virginity, but she felt that before she could get that to happen, she would have to lose her ass virginity also. After all, she'd have to have it done to her, fair is fair, and if she could take it, she was sure that Molly could too. Molly seemed determined to match Judi in the sexual skills area of pleasuring David, and Judi felt that she needed to have her ass virginity broken first, to make sure it wasn't too painful for Molly.
Early in the afternoon, while her parents were at work, she swiped a Valium from her Mom's supply. She figured she might need the Valium fuzz, to mask some of the pain. Before David came to pick her up, she was in the shower, with all the steamy hot water and soap, she lathered up a washcloth, washing her asshole as clean as she could. She wanted David to lick and finger her asshole before he fucked it, and a not clean asshole would really kill that mood. Although she rarely wore one, tonight she wore a skirt, she felt extra sexy, extra girly, and she knew David would get an almost instant hard-on from the view.
David arrived, exchanged pleasantries with her parents, her Mom and Dad were home tonight. Judi walked downstairs, and she smiled as she saw David's eyes light up, the subtle shift in his body position, to cover the quickly growing bulge. Although they said they were going to the movies, that was a cover story, they were going to his parent's cabin out by Lake Chacasco, to hump each other like wild, and fuck like rabbits in heat. Which is exactly what they did, clothes flying off, their naked bodies thrashing wildly under the covers, grunts, growls, and cries of passion filling the cabin as they fucked each other to orgasm, Judi crying out wildly as she felt the glorious burst of her orgasm, and the pulsing throb of David's cock, and his growl of pleasure as he pumped his juicy load deep inside Judi's horny cunt.
Judi was determined to get her ass taken tonight, so, she took the Valium with a glass of water. Relaxing in the post-orgasmic glow, she waited until the soft fuzz of her Valium dose started to fill her brain, then Judi decided to take the plunge.
"David, I hope you don't think it's gross, but would you...like...to fuck my asshole?"
Hearing that, his cock answered for him, throbbing back to majestic glory.
"Ohh, you must really like the idea, have you ever fucked any other's girl's asses?" Judi asked, in a teasing voice.
"Never had any other girl ask me, and you are my first", David replied, "And I can't just walk up to a girl and ask her if she'd like a no-strings-attached ass reaming!"
Judi giggled, and said, "Well, Molly and I have that last vestige of virginity left, I want you to take my sister's asshole virginity, but I want you to bust my asshole cherry first. It seems only right that I do it before I have you do my sister."
Judi stacked up the pillows and rolled over onto her tummy. The pillows lifted her hips and rump up nicely. She reached back, grabbed her cheeks, pulling them open so David could see the tight pucker of her virgin hole.
"Now, I want you to lick and finger my asshole, do it for as long as I want, then, I want lube, lots of lube, I have a tube of KY gel in my purse. And, when you start to fuck my ass, if I can't take it, and I say no, I mean NO! I don't want an asshole rape to be my lasting memory of losing my last vestige of virginity."
David lowered his face, the tight twitchy pucker of Judi's last virgin territory drawing his mouth. His tongue snaked out, and he licked at the tightly puckered rim, flicking the tip of his tongue back and forth. Judi's growl of pleasure told him he was doing it right.
Judi was almost speechless, holy fuck, the touch of his tongue licking at her back door was like nothing she'd ever felt before. If she'd known it felt this good, she would have gotten him licking her asshole the first time they'd fucked.
Judi grunted, "Fuck, oh my god, fuck, feels so fucking good! Keep rimming me David, my god, I never knew it could feel so good!"
Rimming her asshole made David's cock harder than ever, fuck, licking her ass was making him almost crazy horny. He slid her fingers into her soaking pussy, then slipped one finger up her tight asshole, Judi babbled incoherently from the wild burst of pleasure assaulting her body as David slipped another finger in, gently stretching out her virgin ass, getting it ready for his cock.
Judi gasped, "Now, lube up my ass, then your cock, I want it now!"
David squeezed a thick line of KY gel right along the tight rim, then his fingers worked it in, spreading the slippery gel around and around her tight walls, working to stretch her open, and get that tight hole to relax, it was going to be more than tight. He felt her muscles relax a little bit, and Judi pulled apart her ass cheeks as much as she could, wanting to spread that tight little hole as much as possible, so her asshole could be fucked.
David's cock was almost painfully erect, the idea that he was going to fuck Judi's asshole made his cock a steel hard pole. With his cock glistening with a liberal coating of lube, he nudged it against her tight hole and prepared to push.