"How was it supposed to go?"
"Well, I would twist around, like I did, fall back on the bed and you would fall into my arms and kiss me. Then, during the kiss, I would remove your clothes so we could get started."
"Even though you might not have the right toy?" I panicked. Did I choose poorly? Part of me snickered as the line from that Indiana Jones movie popped into my head. That was dispelled as I frantically tried to figure out how I got it wrong. She leant down and gave me a passionate kiss. I lay there immobile. She stopped kissing me, "Aren't you supposed to undress me?"
I looked at the toy in my hand and back up to her. She smiled down at me, "You picked correctly." She went back to kissing me. I squirmed around a bit to get some relief from the toys poking me in the back. She figured it out and, without stopping her kissing, reached behind me and pulled the toys from under me. Where they landed, I had no idea. As soon as I was comfortable, I began my task of undressing my friend.
I started running my hands as far down her body as I could reach. When I reached the hem of the slip she wore, I pulled it further up her body. I gasped a little when, having pulled the slip over her ass, she started grinding her knee on my crotch. As my hands worked the nightie up her body, the grinding and the kissing intensified. I finally got the babydoll bunched up below her neck, but with her mouth attached to mine I couldn't move it higher. She, reluctantly, released my tongue she had been sucking on and leaned back. I quickly removed the slip and before she could move attached my mouth to one of her luscious breasts. I made gentle love to each of them. She clutched my head to her chest. But I wanted to do more. I broke free from her grasp and kissed my way down to her pussy. I flipped her on her back, this time it worked just like I had imagined it. She fell back onto my bed, her silky black hair spreading out on my pillows. I looked at her and wished I could stop and take a picture of this image, but I didn't relish in the sight long as I had other images in my head. Mainly of me between this beauty's legs.
I slowly licked around her folds. I kissed and suckled her lips. Then, tentatively, stuck the tip inside her warm center. I flicked my tongue a little before pulling it out. I flattened my tongue and grazed over her slit before sucking her exposed clit, just for a second, before I slipped my tongue back inside her folds. I giggled just then, mouth full of pussy and a stupid song came into my head. 'You put your left foot in. You put your left foot out. You put your left foot in and you shake it all about.' Except, I decided to go with it. I put my tongue in. Then I pulled it out. Finally I put it, but this time I thrust my tongue as far as I could manage and wiggled it about. I couldn't really do the hokey pokey, afterward though.
I soon felt hands on my head. Hannah was tugging me upward. Once my head was even with hers, she pulled me into a deep kiss and rolled me on my back. Breaking the kiss she said, "As much as I want you to finish me off, we still have this," she raised the double-ended dildo over her head like a might warrior princess might wield a sword, "to play with." She bent back down to trail kisses down my body. Reaching my pussy, she did the same for me. My juices were running. I had closed my eyes as I relished her tender touch on my southern lips.
I opened my eyes as I felt the shaft of my toy penetrate me. I watched as this exotic beauty shoved inch after inch of toy into me. When roughly half of it had disappeared, she angled the rest up and, standing over me, guided it into her own pussy. Some of the remaining length, angled as it was, went further into my pussy filling me fully. I was amazed when, fully inside of both of us, Hannah had closed the gap between our pussies. There was no evidence of the dildo stuffed in us.
She started to gyrate on top of me moving that toy around both of our pussies. I was mesmerized watching her. I had my hands on her hips as she did what looked like a slow, sensual belly dance on top of me. She leaned forward and pulled me back into a passionate kiss. Her hands were stroking my body as she ground our bodies on the dildo embedded in us. It didn't take long for our mutual orgasm to build up. She raised herself off of me and, holding my hands our fingers interlocked, started grinding herself on our shared toy. She came to a stop, cumming on her end of the toy, but I still needed a bit more. So I flipped her on her back and ground myself on the toy. Our hands were still interlocked as I rode the toy to my own orgasm. I collapsed on top of her. We were both panting.
I gingerly pulled the toy from our pussies and we rolled over, exhausted, and fell asleep in each others arms. I felt her extricate herself from my grasp at some point, but didn't bother to move or wake from my dreams. A short time later, I felt her slide in behind me and cup my breasts. I'm not sure how long we were like that when a loud crash sounded at my door. I grudgingly opened my eyes to see a moonlit figure in my doorway that looked oddly like Hannah. I groggily looked behind me to see my naked sister was the one in bed with me. It took my brain a few seconds to realize the predicament I was in. By that time, Hannah had bolted from my room. Nausea flooded my system, but this time there was no intervention coming. I had to face my deepest fear. I had to lay it all out on the line and hope Hannah didn't bolt from my life like she had my room.
I slipped on a negligee I found. The first one in fact, which happened to be the very one Hannah wore not that long ago. I noticed a broken glass of what used to contain water on the floor. Avoiding the shards, I walked out and found her sitting on the couchβher legs pulled up against her chest and her chin resting on her knees. I sat down in front of her on the coffee table. I reached out my hand to her, but pulled it back when she flinched at it. I really was going to lose this person from my life, I realized. I hung my head down low as tears streamed down my face.
We sat there, silently. Her watching me as tears continued to fall from my eyes. Breaking the silence, she asked, "Y-you're s-sister?" I merely nodded. "So you two have had..." She didn't finish the thought. She didn't have to, I knew what she was asking and I just nodded. We sat there again in silence as she thought about that.
"H-how?" I looked up at this question. I was confused. How what? I clearly wasn't thinking straight. I couldn't fathom what she wanted to know in my sleep addled, shocked as hell mind. She had a look on her face that I couldn't figure out. She took a deep breath when she realized I wasn't going to answer. Maybe she realized I needed more context, I don't know, but she asked, "How did it happen? Or rather how did it start?"
I slumped again on the coffee table. After I told her, I realized, could be a real problem if she decided to do anything with this knowledge. But if I had any chance to repair the damage done, I had to tell her. I breathed deeply, trying to gather the strength to tell her everything. I finally looked up at her and started the story, "Well...it started on Winter Break." I relayed the entire story of my sexual relationship with my sister. I told her about my sister finding me masturbating watching her do the same in a video. I told her about the sex while we were Christmas shopping. I told her about the days we spent with each other after school ended. I tried not to go into details about the sex just mentioned we had sex. I left out the orgy on New Year's Eve as well as my Spring Break activities. I figured I had given her enough ammunition to sink both Kaitlin and I already, if she wanted. I realized that if Hannah wanted to, I may very easily be forced to move away, possibly with Kaitlin. I may even lose my parents if she had any desire to tell them about our trysts. I didn't know how much this information might hurt my sister and I, but I knew it could destroy our lives if Hannah wanted to.
I was starting to cry again thinking of all the possibilities. Each one worse than the previous one. When I heard Hannah ask, "Why Kaitlin? Why have sex with your sister?" I thought about it. It didn't take long for an answer to formulate.
"I always felt loved and supported and protected by her. She's always been there for me. She's the one that has taught me the most about being a woman. And when I saw the video I just, I don't know, I thought this way it would be like she was teaching me this as well. When she came in, I wasn't thinking clearly, I guess. The whole holiday I never really thought about it. I just...it was the first time anyone had truly desired me and I never stopped to think about any of it. And now there's you and her and..." I broke down again.
"Me?" I nodded. This time she reached out to me and lifted my head gently. "What about me?" I wasn't sure. I had blurted it out without thinking. Hell, I hadn't even had a chance to rationalize what I felt about Kaitlin and now I had to rationalize my feelings for Hannah. My head was pounding. I had all these emotions and no way for my brain to come up with what these emotions were. "D-do you...love me?" I blinked my eyes a few times.