New Year's Eve for Tyler, Part 2
Over their heavy breathing, they suddenly heard the door at the top of the stairs open and footsteps start coming down the stairs. Eve quickly got off his lap, dropping beside him as Tyler threw the blanked over them again. They stared at the TV as if they'd been watching it all along.
"Oh, Tyler," Amy said when she caught sight of them. "I didn't expect you to be down here."
"Yeah... we're just...," Tyler said, stumbling over what to say, holding the blanket tightly... too tightly.
"Just getting ready to start a movie," Eve added quickly, smiling guiltily.
They both smiled at her, but Amy wasn't sure about their explanation.
"Next up, can Oxymin tablets really help beat cancer. After this," the TV announcer said.
Amy looked at the TV for a moment, seeing that it was an infomercial, then looked back at Eve and Tyler, sitting on the floor. Then she noticed his pajama bottoms laying in a heap across the room. Nothing was adding up. She knew something was going on.
Amy quickly bent over, grabbed a corner of the blanket, and forcefully pulled it off them even as they tried to hold onto it. The shock of what she saw, rendered her speechless. Tyler sat with his pants off, his cock hard, long, and shining with juices. Eve's robe was opened, showing only a little, but showing enough to know that she was naked underneath.
"Oh my God! You... animals!" Amy yelled, shaking her head.
"I just couldn't help myself," Eve said. "I'm sorry."
"How could you... do this?" Amy grabbed her head and walked over to a chair, sitting in it. She covered her mouth with her hands, watching the two of them, wondering what she could even say.
"Well... frankly it was pretty easy," Eve giggled, looking at Tyler. "His tab A shoving into my slot B." Tyler looked scared, trying to cover himself with his hands, and didn't appreciate her humor.
"Did you... enjoy it?" Amy asked, shaking her head.
"You're joking, right? Of course I enjoyed it. Very much," Eve said. "Your son has a beautiful, hard, young cock. But I would bet that you already know that." Amy blushed, remembering that she did know that. She'd felt that hard cock deep inside her pussy less than twenty-four hours ago. "Look at you! You're so cute when you get embarrassed."
"Evie... this isn't a game. This... this isn't right," Amy said, trying to be forceful, trying to sound reasonable. "Tyler's your nephew. He's my son for God's sake! We can't have you living here if this is what you're going to do. You need to leave."
"Oh... but YOU can live here after fucking him?" Eve asked sitting forward challengingly.
Amy blushed deeply, looking at the floor, shocked that her sister knew what she'd done. "Ok... ok, I did. I fucked him last night."
"Oh, my God!" Eve gasped, smiling broadly. "I had my suspicions but I never thought they were real. I was just spouting off."
"It was an accident!" Amy said, trying to explain. "He came into your room looking for you. But you were down here. And he... he ended up fucking me instead. I was asleep."
Eve nodded, smiling deviously. "Of course he did."
"Sorry... I... I didn't want to tell anyone. It's just too embarrassing. But I'm just not so good at keeping secrets," Amy said.
"Oh, you're the worst at keeping secrets!" Eve giggled. "Everyone in the dorm knew that I fucked my sister."
"That wasn't my fault!" Amy said, raising her hands in defense.
"Whatever... But it's ok... I didn't mind," Eve giggled. "It made me popular."
"Really?" Amy asked, surprised yet again.
"Uh huh," Eve nodded, then laughed. "It seems when people know you both lick pussy and suck cock, they want to be with you. I got a lot more dates after that."
Amy put her head in her hands and shook her head. She couldn't believe this was happening. She couldn't believe this was real.
"So, what did you come down here for Amy?" Eve asked, looking at her sister like she knew a secret. She seemed to know that Amy came downstairs for a reason.
Amy looked at her, blushing again. "I... I thought there might be something going on between you two." She prayed that the lie would work. Right now, especially with Tyler right there, the truth would be far too embarrassing.
"Did you, now?" Eve challenged her.
"Yes."
"But you said you didn't know he was down here."
"I... I think you misheard me," she said, unconvincingly. "I... I didn't mean it that way."
"Come on, Sissy," Eve said, rising to her knees. "Admit it. You really came down here to see me, didn't you."
"Yes... I mean... of course, that's... that's what I said."
"Not exactly," Eve said, crawling towards her sister. "See, I think you came down to see... these." When Eve was right in front of Amy, she sat up on her knees and slid her robe completely off, tossing it beside them.
Amy looked at her naked sister in shock and desire. Her breasts were so big, so... perfect. It'd been so long since she'd touched them. It'd been so long since she felt how warm and soft they were. "No... I... I..." she tried denying it.
Eve smiled. She knew the truth just by looking at Amy's face. "Yes you did. You came down because you wanted to see me... to feel me... to taste me again." She grabbed Amy's wrists and pulled her hands up, putting them on her breasts, pressing her hands to force Amy to squeeze them. "You came down because you want me to make you cum. Didn't you?"
"I... I...", Amy stammered, not knowing what to say or do. Her sister was right. She did come downstairs to see her sister... to be with her. There was something about having her in the house that was driving her crazy with desire.
Tyler's hand grabbed his shaft and he started masturbating while watching the two women. It was the most erotic thing he'd ever seen.
Eve untied Amy's robe and pulled the two halves apart, revealing Amy's delicious body beneath. Her nipples were hard and pointed. Eve leaned forward and started licking Amy's nipple, looking up to see her reaction.
Amy moaned softly. "Oh... yeah... fuck, that feels so good, Evie." Eve moved to her other nipple, making sure to give it the appropriate attention, making it just as hard as the first. "Oh my God."
Eve slid between her breasts, licking in her cleavage as she squeezed Amy's breasts into the sides of her face. "Mmmmm," she moaned, making Amy giggle.
"Fuck yes," Amy whispered and she looked up and saw her son masturbating, watching them. She couldn't believe how hot that made her, how much it made her pussy gush.
"Oh my God. I love your tits," Eve said, moving back to Amy's nipples, moving from one to the other, giving them both a lot of attention with her tongue and lips.
"Fuck," Amy moaned as Eve sat up on her knees again and the two kissed. "God, it's been years."
"I was thinking the same thing," Eve giggled. Then she grabbed her own breasts and moved closer, pressing them into Amy's face. "You like my breasts, too, don't you? You like them in your face?"
"Yes... God I do," Amy whispered, licking Eve's offered nipples as they swiped back and forth across her face.
