Pastor Nate was in the middle of an impromptu threesome with two members of his congregation when there was a sudden and unexpected knock at the door.
Sarah, the single mother with longΒ blonde hair, big blue eyes, and a curvy figure, and Julie, an older divorcee withΒ shoulder-length brown hair, hazel eyes, and a slender figure, both ran around the corner to get dressed and compose themselves when they heard the knock on the door.
"Oh, hey babe! I didn't expect you to be home so soon..." Pastor Nates voice trailed off. Both women could sense a little bit of nervousness in Pastor Nate's voice.
"Babe?" Julie and Sarah thought to themselves...
Sarah whispered to Julie, "Is Pastor Nate married?"
"I've never seen a ring, and it's never come up in conversation..." Julie replied, trailing off in thought.
"What now?" Sarah asked.
The two women, now fully clothed, albeit disheveled, kept their cover around the corner as the listened to Pastor Nate interact with this mysterious woman, whom he referred to as "babe."
Pastor Nate's heart skipped a beat as he mentally cursed his poor decision to invite Sarah and Julie over for dinner. Trying to remain calm, he offered her a polite smile and invited her in. "Wow! What a surprise, babe! I wasn't expecting you to be able to make it over here for another few weeks!"
In walked Krista, Pastor Nate's beautiful and unexpecting wife. They embraced in the doorway, Krista obviously excited to see Pastor Nate after a long separation.
"Holy fuck!" Julie hissed to Sarah, "how do we sneak out of here unnoticed?"
Sarah looked at Julie, panic evident in her eyes. She didn't know what to say, how to react. Pastor Nate's wife appeared to be completely unaware of what had been going on. But how could they leave now?
They heard Pastor Nate addressing Krista, attempting to maintain composure, "So, babe, you managed to finish up your work a few weeks early, and decided to come surprise me?"
Krista's tone changed, becoming more serious, "Yes, I finished up early. But I must admit, I am surprised to see you with company.
Especially these two lovely ladies." He gestured towards Sarah and Julie, who were still hiding behind the corner.
Both Sarah and Julie were clueless as to how Krista had noticed them, but they both took a deep breath and walked out into the open living room.
Krista's eyes widened slightly, her expression registering confusion.
"Well, babe, I had some guests over for dinner earlier tonight, and they decided to stay for a late-night chat." Pastor Nate answered, attempting to sound relaxed and nonchalant. "We were talking about how to start a new Women's Ministry."
Krista cocked her head to one side, processing the information. "Interesting.
So, what exactly what was your contribution to this conversation with these lovely ladies, pastor?" Krista inquired cautiously, her eyes narrowing slightly.
"Oh, nothing much, babe," Pastor Nate stammered, his voice cracking under pressure. "Just some friendly ideas, that's all."
Krista raised an eyebrow, clearly unconvinced. "That's not quite what I heard earlier. I've been standing outside the door for a few minutes, and it sounded like a lot more than 'friendly conversation' was going on in here. And besides, why did you just start calling me 'babe?' I've never heard you use that term before."
"Errr..." Pastor Nate was clearly caught off guard.
Sarah's face flushed with embarrassment, she couldn't believe the situation she found herself in. Her cheeks burned as she struggled to assist in answering Krista's probing questions to Pastor Nate. "Umm, well, Pastor Nate and Julie and I were discussing church matters, and, um, we started to feel comfortable together...maybe it was the wine, but we didn't mean for things to go where they did," Sarah stuttered, feeling guilty and exposed.
"Really," Krista inquired, "and where exactly did things go?"
Her voice had taken on a sharp edge, her body language tense and alert.
Sarah squirmed under Krista's piercing gaze, "Umm, well, we just sort of started making out," she mumbled, looking down at her feet. "It all happened so fast, and then we ended up..." Sarah hesitated, unable to complete her sentence.
"Ended up what?" Krista pressed, her brow furrowed.
"You know, doing stuff," Sarah blurted out, her cheeks burning even hotter with embarrassment.
"You don't have to tell me the details," Krista said, a dark look crossing her face. "Let's just say I've already learned more than I wanted to about my husband today."
Pastor Nate swallowed hard, his throat dry. He didn't know what else to say. His thoughts were jumbled and chaotic, and he felt utterly helpless.
Julie stepped forward, trying to salvage the situation. "Look, Mrs. Harris, we apologize for the misunderstanding. We just got caught up in the moment."
It was unexpected and it shouldn't have happened." Pastor Nate tried to defend himself. "But you should know that I love you, babe." He turned towards Krista, reaching out to touch her hand gently.
Krista recoiled instinctively, pulling her hand back. "Love me? That's rich, considering you just cheated on me. With two members of your own congregation no less."