Note: As you may gather from the title, this is a continuation of the story "Sharing Marie - With Her Dad"
##
I.
I sat frozen on the couch for a long while, still processing what I had discovered. My sweet, nerdy girlfriend was fucking her dad. I knew, and she knew that I knew. What now?
Marie had left her phone behind when she fled crying from my apartment, so I picked it back up. I needed to know more. I checked the dates of the videos she'd filmed with her dad and saw that they had all been recorded when she went home for winter break, back when we were still just friends.
But the text messages continued long after we started dating. Two days after we first slept together, she sent her dad a message telling him that she missed the feeling of his hands on her body. From the hotel where we took our first romantic trip together, she sent him a photo of her fingers spreading her pussy. Just three days before I found her texts, they'd exchanged messages about needing one another.
I went back to the video folder and opened the final clip I hadn't watched. It was filmed from her father's perspective and showed Marie from the chest up. Her breasts shook with each thrust from her dad, her head was tilted back, and her pale skin was turning red. I recognized immediately that she was close to orgasm.
"Fuuuuck, daddydaddydaddy," I heard my girlfriend moan to her father. Even on the phone's small screen, I could see the muscles and tendons in her neck tense. Her body shook more with each thrust; her father must have been pounding her harder and harder.
Then she arched her back, thrusting her breasts up in the air. I knew that she must be cumming, that her tight, spasming pussy was squeezing her dad's dick, milking it. "Ahhh," I heard her father groan. I imagined him emptying his balls into my sweet girlfriend at that very moment.
The camera tilted down to show the place where there bodies were joined. Marie's dad slid his condom-less dick out of her pussy, and a beat later, I could see some of his incestuous seed dribble out of her. Then the video ended.
For the first time since I'd check Marie's phone the night before, I felt something other than dazed confusion. I couldn't explain it, but the proof was in my hardening cock: I may have been weirded out, but I was also turned on.
I knew I needed to talk to Marie. Since she'd left her phone at my place, I had to go out and look for her. I went to her dorm room, where her roommate told me that she had stopped by briefly, crying, to change.
"Did you two get into a fight?" she asked.
"Kind of," I said. I headed to the basement lounge in the chemistry building: on a Sunday morning, it would be a good hideout for someone looking to avoid human contact. When I entered, I saw that it was empty--except for Marie, curled into a ball on one of the ratty loveseats.
She sat up, startled, when she saw me. "Marie, please, can we talk?" I asked.
She shook her head no, looking like a little girl.
I walked behind the loveseat and put my hands on her shoulders. "Look, I'll admit, I have questions. But I want you to know that whatever your answers are, I love you and will love you," I said. I leaned down and kissed the top of her head. "So can we please go back to my apartment and talk?"
She didn't move and didn't talk for a long time; it felt like an eternity. Then she subtly nodded her head. I took her hand and led her up the stairs.
We walked back across campus in silence. What was she thinking? What was she feeling? Her face was hidden behind big, dark sunglasses, so I couldn't read her eyes.
As soon as I opened the door to my apartment, we melted together. Falling to the couch, we held each other tight. Marie was crying, her body shaking with each sob, and she buried her face into my shoulder. I pulled her closer to me and kissed her hair.
We stayed like that for a long while, until Marie could finally face me. "I'm so sorry," she said. "I didn't mean to hurt you. I don't know, in my head, what I have with him and what I have with you feel like such different things..it kind of, I don't know...felt like I wasn't cheating. I don't know," she said.
I nodded. "When did it start?" I asked.
"My senior year of high school, a few months after my mom died."
"Did he force you?"
"No, not at all! I wanted it. And I was 18."
"Are you going to keep sleeping with him?"
Marie didn't answer at first, but she bowed her head. "Yes. I wish I could tell you that I'll stop. But I know myself, and I know that I'll keep giving myself to him."
We were both silent for a minute. "I'm OK with it," I said.