Sophia And Bennett

This is a sequel to the first story I ever wrote:

Lead Me To Love

. Thanks to that story, I got my start here on Literotica, and I still hold the protagonists, Aiden & Cassie, very close to my heart. When I finished the series last year, I stated I would revisit that universe at some point, so here it is.

That being said, this is ALSO canonically a sequel to another story of mine as there is also an appearance from a couple of characters from one of my previous works. So, I guess you could say LMTL & the other story share the same universe.

Now, it's not required you read the LMTL series before reading this, but I still highly encourage you to check it out. It is my sincerest hope that my readers, both long-time and new, enjoy this new tale.

Lengthwise, it's amongst the longest I've written to date. So, if you intend to read this in one setting, get comfortable.

As usual, all participants in this story are 18 years or older

- Alexandra

******

Love is like wildflowers; it's often found in the most unlikely places

-

Ralph Waldo Emerson

******

Sophia Novak-Schroeder stepped through the front door of her family's house in Centennial, Colorado. She had driven overnight, spending close to 11 hours on the road as she made the journey back from Tempe, Arizona. She was a student at the University of Arizona, where she had just finished her sophomore year in college.

She was tired from her long trip, so she just wanted to get everything back into her room and go to sleep for a couple of hours. Placing a couple of duffel bags on the ground, she loudly called out.

"I'm home! Bennett?"

Bennett was her younger brother by two years. He was a senior at Mountain Crest High School and was set to graduate next week.

"Ugh, where is he? He told me that he'd help me put my shit away yesterday." Her eyes scanned the room as she fumed to herself. She picked up her bags and headed upstairs to her room.

As she got to the top of the staircase, she once again called out for her brother. "Bennett? Where the fuck are you? Stop jerking off in your bedroom and help me carry my stuff in!"

It didn't make sense. Sophia had called Bennett numerous times before her arrival, but he had not picked up. Her brother's white Jeep was in the driveway, so he couldn't have gone far. Now getting pissed, she marched over to her room and tossed her bags onto her bed and grumbled to herself. "I'm going to kick his ass when I bust down that door of his."

Sophia was about to leave the room when she heard a noise coming from her window. More specifically, he heard a couple of people moaning coming from below her window. Curious, she crept over to the window overlooking the backyard, and her jaw dropped.

Below the window was a naked red-haired woman on her hands and knees on the lounge chair, while Sophia's brother held onto the woman's hips as he fucked her from behind. The sun reflected off the woman's pale skin, while Bennett's toned body glistened with sweat as he breathed heavily; His messy blonde hair made him look like he had stepped out of a Mad Max movie.

"Oh fuck... oh fuck... oh fuck." The woman cried out as Bennett thrusted aggressively into her.

Sophia's throat went dry as she watched her brother fucking the redhead from the window. It had been a long time since she had gotten laid, and she knew that this was something that she should not be watching. Her brother had a lean muscular body and, as much as Sophia didn't want to admit it, Bennett had a nice cock.

Sophia's body took over as she began to slip her hand inside her shorts. Her fingers brushed her small, triangle-shaped pubic hair until she reached her clit. Her breathing was hollow as she continued to watch her brother have his way with the petite redhead. Maybe it was the fact that Sophia hadn't gotten laid in a while, but it awoke something in her that she couldn't explain.

After a couple of minutes, Sophia felt herself close to cumming. She was about to do so when she heard her brother say something that shook her to her core.

Bennett panted. "You feel so fucking good, Kaylee."

Sophia's feelings went from lust to rage as her blood began to boil when she heard the name Kaylee, as it all came back to her.

Kaylee Forsyth was a couple grades behind her when Sophia was still in high school but had a reputation of being an absolute bitch to anyone who she suspected of speaking ill of her. To quote one of her friends: She's mean just for the sake of being mean.

For one girl, Jamie, the bullying had gotten so bad that she ended up switching schools just because of how terrible she had been treated.

And now here Sophia's brother was fucking Kaylee in their backyard.

Pulling herself together, Sophia ran downstairs to the garage and grabbed a large orange paint bucket and took it back to the kitchen. She filled it up with cold water from the sink before adding some ice from the freezer. Carrying the bucket in her left hand, she quietly opened the sliding door to their backyard, which had a pool and lounge chairs.

Sophia moved quietly behind the two lovers, who were facing away from the door. This, of course, gave Sophia the element of surprise. As she approached, Kaylee cried out repeatedly, pleading with Bennett to fuck her harder, which made Sophia angrier.

Now standing right behind the two, she lifted the orange bucket up with both hands and brought it above her shoulders. With a quick motion, she stepped forward and dumped the freezing water onto Kaylee's naked form, to which she let out a blood-curdling scream as Bennett jumped back in shock.

"Okay, you've had your fun, you cunt. Now get the fuck out of here!" Sophia tossed the bucket on the ground and placed her hands on her hips.

Kaylee rolled over off the lounger and stood up, covering her small breasts with her right arm and her pussy with her left hand as she shivered. "What the fuck, you b-b-bitch!"

"The only 'b-b-bitch' here is you!" Sophia mocked her. "I always thought that you were an asshole and a bully, but how you convinced my brother to hook up with you is beyond me."

Bennett had covered himself with a towel and tried to intervene. "What the fuck, Soph?!"

"You shut the fuck up and go inside before I decide to tell mom and dad about you sneaking a girl into our house." She pointed at him angrily in a raised voice.

Her brother, deciding not to anger his sister further, huffed as he stormed back inside, slamming the sliding door shut behind him.

Sophia turned her attention back to Kaylee. "You have some fucking nerve showing here, you know?"

Still covering herself up, Kaylee retorted. "Aww, what's the matter, Groot? It's not my fault that Benny Boy wanted a little piece of me."

Kaylee immediately regretted saying those words as Sophia slowly stepped towards her with clenched fists.

Groot was the nickname that Kaylee had given Sophia when they were still in high school together. Like her mother, Sophia stood at 6' 1'' and was the star volleyball player on the team, compared to Kaylee's short height of just 5' 2", but even Sophia's popularity didn't make her immune to Kaylee's name-calling. While she was able to ignore her taunts, she knew full well that it wasn't as easy for other kids.

Sophia reached over and grabbed a handful of Kaylee's red hair and started to pull her towards the pool.

"Ahhh! Let go of me, you fucking cunt!" Kaylee screamed out as her body twisted and arms flailed, trying to take a swing at Sophia with no success.

When they got to the edge of the pool, Sophia grabbed Kaylee's left shoulder and heaved her nude body into the pool as it made a large splash.

As Kaylee resurfaced, her now-wet red hair clung to her face, and her small breasts with erect pink nipples were floating on the surface. While she tried to clear her vision, Sophia grabbed Kaylee's discarded clothing and tossed them into the water before squatting down to look at the angry redhead.

"I am Groot!" Sophia proudly proclaimed, as the redhead fumed at her.

"BITCH WHAT THE FUCK!" Kaylee shouted at Sophia.

However, Sophia was undeterred by her shouting. She narrowed her blue eyes towards Kaylee and laughed at her. "Oh my god, I've always wanted to do that."

"Once I get out of this pool, I will fuck you up!" Kaylee snarled at her.

Sophia once again laughed at her. "Please, I can bench press more than what little waifs like you weigh, so you aren't going to do shit. Here's what you're going to do, though. You're going to put on your clothes, walk your sorry ass out of my backyard and never talk to my brother again. Understand?"

"And what? You expect me to walk home wearing these soaking wet clothes?" Kaylee questioned her with a hint of venom in her voice.

Sophia smirked at her. "You can either leave now with whatever dignity you have intact, or I can have the cops called and have you arrested for trespassing. If the rumor mill is to be believed, I'm sure the police would love to know why someone, who briefly spent time in juvie, is sneaking onto private property."

Kaylee understood from Sophia's tone of voice that she wasn't messing around. With that, she grabbed her clothes, which floated on the water's surface, and climbed out of the pool.

Now blushing from embarrassment, Kaylee put on her wet black bra-and-panties, jean shorts, and blue shirt. She grumbled to herself as she let herself out through the gate leading to the front yard of the house. Sophia watched from the backyard as Kaylee disappeared out of sight.

Sophia let out a long sigh of relief as she placed her hands on her hips and shook her head. "Jesus, Benny..."

-

Sophia knocked on the door to her brother's room with a sense of urgency. Bennett called out to her. "Fuck off, Soph. Why do you always have to ruin everything for me?"

"Let me in so we can talk. Otherwise, I'll tell mom and dad that you brought that dumbass bitch over to our place. The choice is yours." Sophia gave Bennett her ultimatum.

The door flew open, and Bennett stood there with a scowl on his face. He had since changed into a pair of red gym shorts and a purple Colorado Avalanche T-shirt. Much like his sister, Bennett had inherited their parents' height and then some. Standing at 6' 4", he looked down at his sister.

"Fine, come in, but only because I don't want the parentals to find out."

He moved to his computer chair at his desk and sat down, while Sophia took a seat on his bed. Much to her surprise, Bennett kept his room spotless and tidy. She couldn't say the same about the dorms of her friends, where she had spent much of her free time when she wasn't studying or practicing.

"Nice room you have here, Benny. I never took you for a neat freak." Sophia tried to alleviate the tension with little success.

"Just chew me out about my poor life choices so I can get on with my day." Bennett folded his arms and looked at her.

"Look, the most important thing I want to know is: did you use a condom?" Sophia asked him.

"Jesus, Soph! Of course, I did." Bennett's face turned red as an apple at her question.

Sophia let out a small chuckle. "You're seriously embarrassed that I just asked you if you used a condom, yet you're unashamed that I caught you and Kaylee doing the nasty in our backyard."

"Ugh, enough! Look, I'm sorry I missed your calls to help you move your stuff inside, so you can stop twisting the knife already." Bennett threw his hands up in frustration. He knew his sister was somewhat of a free spirit when it came to sex talk, but he was more reserved.

Sophia shook her head and held up her hand. "Benny, I'm not pissed about the fact that you didn't answer my texts or calls. Hell, if it were me, I would've done the same thing. What I'm pissed about is that you were hooking up with that bitch Kaylee!"

"What's it to you? You suddenly know what's best for me? Maybe I should start calling you 'mom' since you're the all-knowing guru." Bennett retorted sarcastically.

"Kaylee is one of the shittiest people on this planet and a bully to almost everyone she meets! She once bullied this girl so badly when she was in the 9th grade that the poor girl she was tormenting ended up having to switch schools. Not to mention she would constantly talk shit about me and my friends for no reason at all. Plus, I know for a fact she was arrested for shoplifting back when she was 16 and did some time in juvie. The only reason why it's not on her record is because her parents are sleezy lawyers." Sophia yelled at him.

Bennett's brown eyes became wide. "Wait... she did all that? Shoplifting, bullying and talking shit about you? She never told me any of that!"

"Well, she did!" Sophia said in a matter-of-fact voice. "Seriously, what did you see in her?"

"She's cute, seemed like fun, and was interested in me..." Bennett was grasping at straws.

Sophia raised an eyebrow. "That's it? She looked cute and wanted to have sex with you?"

"I didn't say all that!" Bennett was quick to respond as his face became red once more.

She let out a long sigh. "Look, I'm sorry for doing... all of that. If it were any other girl, I would've just let you go about your business and let you go at it, but Kaylee is nothing but trouble. Plus, she would've started talking shit behind your back after you two had finished hooking up anyways."

"I'm telling you, Soph, I had no idea that she was like that. I mean, she's one of the more popular girls in school, and I thought that maybe Kaylee was into me when we started talking." Bennett tried to reason.

Sophia rolled her eyes. "She only wanted you because you play hockey and wanted to get one more notch in her belt before graduation. I don't know her as well as other girls, but I know enough about her to understand that she's no good. Besides, you want to fuck up that scholarship of yours because you decided to stick your dick into literal trouble?"

Bennett agreed that she had a strong point. Who knows what would've happened if the condom broke or, worse yet, somehow Kaylee had sunk her claws into him.

"No, you're right, Soph. I just... wanted to end high school with a bang... literally." For the first time since Sophia had gotten home, Bennett cracked a joke and smiled.

Sophia began to laugh. "Well, you certainly accomplished that. But seriously, next time you hook up with someone, make sure it's not someone like Kaylee Forsyth, okay?"

"Loud and clear." Bennett stood up, and Sophia went to hug him.

"I'm sorry for being a dick to you, Soph," Bennett murmured as his face looked over her shoulder.

Sophia giggled and broke the embrace. She tussled his blonde hair and smiled, "All is forgiven, Benny. Now, c'mon, help me carry the rest of my stuff in before mom and dad get home."

******

An hour later, their father, Aiden, walked through the front door. It had been a long day at the volleyball clinic that he and his partner, Russell Khoury, ran. He had been brought on board 23 years prior, to work and help with marketing. After the previous owner, Victoria Khoury, retired, He had taken the reins as Owner/CEO. Now, the 5280 Volleyball Clinic was one of the most prestigious volleyball training centers in the country.

Sophia and Bennett were there to greet him in the living room. As Aiden saw the two, a wide smile across his face.

"Soph!" Aiden bellowed out a laugh. "I saw your car in the driveway, but welcome home!"

Sophia jumped up and hugged her dad. "Ooooo, I missed you and mom so much."

While Bennett inherited his mother's golden blonde hair, Sophia had gotten her dad's brown hair, of which Aiden had grown out over the past few years, along with his beard, somewhat resembling himself from his 20s. Or as Bennett liked to call it, the Keanu Reeves look.

Sophia stepped back from her dad. "Where is she, by the way? I thought she would be home by now."

Aiden smirked, "Ahhh, she's running a bit late. There's a prospective student named Emily interested in playing for the university, and she's extremely talented. Your mom really wants her to play for the volleyball team, so she's giving her the VIP treatment."

Aiden was, of course, referring to his wife, Cassie, or Cass as everyone called her. An accomplished volleyball player in her younger years, she played for the University of Arizona and was an outstanding volleyball coach. Cassie had been brought on board as an assistant coach for the Colorado State University volleyball team after Bennett had been born.

Now in her 12th year as head coach, she had brought home the NCAA National Volleyball Championship title four times, the most recent title being two years prior. In addition to that, she was also a part-time Sports Medicine Instructor at the university.

"Mom's got a silver tongue, so I have no doubt that she'll pull it off. After all, she was able to calm Aunt Tiffany down when the Red Wings screwed the pooch during game 7 of the Stanley Cup Finals a few years ago. You know how psycho she can get when it comes to that team." Bennett remarked as he lay on the couch.

Sophia began laughing as Aiden shook his head and chuckled. "Be nice, Benny."

"I'm just saying..." Bennett smiled as he stood up from the couch and walked to the kitchen to grab a bottle of water from the fridge.

-

An hour later, their mother, Cassie, burst through the front door and saw Sophia at the dining room table with Bennett and Aiden.

"Ahhhhh, Soph! There you are my baby girl!" Cassie cried out as she went to hug her daughter.

As the two finished their hug, her husband, Aiden, walked over and kissed Cassie on her lips.

"So, how did it go with Emily? Hopefully, she didn't have too many reservations." Aiden asked his wife.

Cassie shook her head as she discarded her cream-colored blazer and kicked off her white pumps. "Nope. When I gave her a tour of the facilities and had her meet some of the players, she was sold. I'm happy to report that Emily Contreras will be one of our new setters in a couple of months."

"That's awesome, mom! Nice work, you silver-tongued devil." Bennett joked as she sat at the table.

"Oh, I didn't do any of the talking myself. You have the university and the other players to thank for all that, but I'll take the compliment, Benny." Cassie said as she sat down at the table.

Aiden sat next to Cassie and placed his hands on the table. "Well, with this news and Sophia's homecoming. I think this calls for a celebration. What do you all think?"

Sophia let out a pained moan. "No offense, but as much as I would love to, I'm tired from my drive today. Maybe tomorrow instead?"

"None taken, Soph. How about we order some pizza tonight? What do you say, kids?" Aiden grinned as he pulled out his cellphone.

"Make sure you double-check that there's pineapple on ours this time, baby." Cassie winked at her husband.

Bennett's face soured. "Eww! Mom, you like pineapple on your pizza? What's wrong with you?"

"What can I say? Don't knock it until you try it." Cassie giggled.

******

After dinner, the family spent some time in the living room as they caught up on how the last couple of months of college went for Sophia, as well as talked about Bennett's graduation party, along with his plans to attend Boston College, where he had secured a full-ride scholarship for hockey.

Eventually, Aiden and Cassie decided to call it a night and headed up to their bedroom, leaving the two siblings on the couch as they watched TV.

"So, I guess I never got a chance to ask you this when I got home, but how are you feeling about graduating from high school?" Sophia asked Bennett as she curled her long legs underneath her as she sat on the far end of the sofa.