I had avoided Annie for days after our crazy Sunday. I was sore and I knew Annie would insist on having sex. I was sure that the more I might protest the more insistent she would be. I could never resist my Annie's demands, and I knew that she would not be gentle.
I was angry with her as well. She had always teased Teddy, and once she realized that she could a rise out of him, in a sexual way, so long ago, she never let up. She was so bold about it too. She was not shy about who was around when she teased him. Darlene thought it was funny, but I never did. Annie said that Teddy enjoyed it and maybe he did. He always seemed embarrassed, but maybe that was because I was there. I knew that it was only a matter of time before she got into his pants, if she hadn't already.
After that incident in her kitchen, that Sunday morning, I had to wonder what happened between them when I was not around. Teddy had spent the night with Annie's brothers quite often and must have had a lot of time alone with her. I knew better than to ask Annie about it, she would only lie. I was sure that she had cheated on me and lied about it. I wouldn't ask Teddy about it and possibly force him to lie, to cover for Annie.
I was angry with her, for what she was putting me through and for putting Teddy in such an awkward situation. It was quite a twisted little triangle we had found ourselves in. I was in love with Annie and Teddy. Teddy was in love with me and I knew he'd always loved Annie too. I could only hope he loved me more.
Annie told me that she loved me and I believed her. God only knows what she whispered in Teddy's ear, and what she might have said to him when no one was around.
Teddy was so sweet to me. He slept with me that Sunday night and that was just what I needed. It was wonderful to touch his gorgeous body. I wanted so badly to make love to him, but not only was not I physically able that night, but I was afraid. I didn't know what I was afraid of, but I couldn't bring myself to let him in.
Teddy slept with me the following night, as well. He slipped between my sheets just after midnight, wearing a lose fitting pair of shorts and nothing more. I wrapped my arms around him and kissed him deeply. I have still never met anyone that kisses me as well as Teddy did. I was wearing a night shirt that buttoned up the front and satin panties.
I felt my nipples get hard as I pressed my breasts against his bare, sweaty chest. My panties got moist as I felt his hard cock pressed against my stomach.
After making out for several minutes I laid my head on his shoulder and stroked his chest, softly. Teddy slowly started to unbutton my nightshirt. Once it was unbuttoned, he placed his hand gently on my right breast. I heaved a deep sigh. He gently traced circles around my titty, starting near the edge and slowly worked toward the nipple. Once his finger reached my nipple, he took it between his finger and thumb. He gently tweaked it until I issued a tiny grunt.
"Did that hurt?" he asked.
"No, Baby," I said, "That feels wonderful!" I pinched his nipple and asked, "Do you like that?"
"Yeah! Oh Yeah," me moaned. I leaned down and took his little nipple in my lips and sucked hard. "Oh damn, that feels good!" he cried.
As I sucked his nipple he removed my nightshirt. We were both naked from the waist up. He rolled me on my back and took my left nipple in his lips and began to suck, softly at first and then harder. After a few seconds he kissed my stomach and then he buried his face in my wet panties. I wanted him to eat me out, but instead I blurted out, "Kiss me!"