The Family Mansion Redux Part 3: Lexi
By Charlie Flemming
Copyright 2020 Charlie Flemming
Lexi was Nathan's twin sister. They were both born on May 15, only a few minutes apart over 19 years ago.
Liz saw her youngest daughter, Erika, as being, more or less, just a younger version of her. This was mostly because Erika was the spitting image of Liz when she was her age. Erika had large breasts, soft features, black hair, and brown eyes, just as Liz did.
If Liz could see clearer, she'd see that Lexi was the daughter who had the most in common with her. They were both late bloomers, Lexi looking somewhat childish until she was about sixteen and then blossomed into a budding beauty. And now, three years later, she looked positively ravishing. Lexi had curly red hair, C-cup breasts, and a curvy and toned body that she seemed to have naturally as she didn't really work out as the other women in her household. She had an absolutely angelic face and when she smiled she simply lit up the room.
But, also like her mother, Lexi had almost no experience when it came to the opposite sex. Partly because Lexi was shy around boys and would just shut down around them. She never knew what to say or how to act. Really the only man she'd ever been able to talk to one-on-one without feeling like a huge weirdo was her brother, Nathan.
Truthfully Lexi was closer with Nathan than anyone else in their family, but there was still conflict between them growing up. This came because of Brooke. When Nathan and Lexi were born, Brooke saw Nathan as some kind of enemy but Lexi was immediately her closest ally. When Brooke was around, which was nearly always, Lexi would be just as mean to him as Brooke was. It wasn't until they were alone that Lexi would go back to being her brother's best friend in the world just as he was to her. And that, in part, was why she, still, snuck into his room at the end of every day and they slept together in the same bed almost every night. During these times they shared thoughts and feelings as intimate as lovers. This was Lexi's favorite part of any day. Something about it just felt somehow very romantic to her.
Which is the other reason Lexi had almost no sexual experience. For as long as she knew what love was, she had been in love with her twin brother Nathan. There was no man she felt closer to or felt that she had more in common with. She knew it was wrong, even from the first moment she felt this way, but she couldn't help it. Though Lexi knew she could never admit it openly, she resided in loving him in secret and never giving in to her feelings. Instead, she suppressed these thoughts and wouldn't so much as allow herself to fantasize about her brother in any way sexually.
Lexi's policy on not thinking about her brother sexually changed one day shortly after their 18th birthday. In their house, the second floor was a long line of 21 bedrooms, including the master bedroom, connected via a very long hallway. But on the opposite side of the hall was four bathrooms, each one equalling the size of five bedrooms. Though Lexi lived in room 14 and Nathan 15, so Lexi's bedroom lined up with the washroom next to Nathan's, the bathroom door closest was on one of the ends of the hall. Because of this, Lexi and Nathan tended to share the same bathroom unless one of them was already in it. Lexi usually knew this because the door would be locked.
But on that fateful day, Nathan had forgotten to lock the door and Lexi walked in and could see her brother showering (because the bathrooms were so big and the showers were on the opposite side from the door, it was very hard to hear the shower before one went in the room). The showers in their house only had clear, glass doors, so when Lexi went in she could see very clearly the naked body of her brother. This was before he started working out all the time as they were still in high school for another month and Nathan didn't start his obsessive exercising until the summer after he graduated. But Lexi was still awestruck by Nathan's nude form. A bit scrawny at the time, but complemented by a tall, masculine frame, a tight firm ass, and a humongous cock even though it was soft at the time.
Everything about her brother's body just screamed "sex machine" to Lexi's young mind in that instant. She was practically rushing back to her room to masturbate to thoughts of using her brother to satisfy what she saw at the time as "her own selfish needs."
Lexi felt guilty about these feelings for her brother but didn't stop sleeping in his bed almost every night. Though, once she was sure he was asleep she liked to run her hand over his chest and fantasize about them being together in a more intimate fashion. Sometimes she even traced the outline of his cock in his pajamas when she was feeling particularly naughty, but never for more than a moment and always through his clothes. Then, shortly after Nathan started developing some serious muscles when he started his exercise regimen, he also started sleeping naked.
"Um," Nathan had said to Lexi the day he decided to start going to bed in the buff, "I'm naked." Lexi had just barged into his room without knocking, which was common every night so Nate wasn't surprised, but he still looked worried as he told her that.
"What?" Lexi said, cocking an eyebrow, pretending this wasn't secretly exciting her knowing her brother was nude under those blankets, "Why are you naked?"
"Well," Nathan started, "because I'm an adult now and I'm too old for pajamas. Also, I kind of like being nude in bed at night. I mean, I know you like sleeping here but this is something I want to do for myself." Nathan was being very honest right then, something he only ever was with Lexi when they were alone like this. It was a side that only Lexi ever got to see and she loved him for it. Knowing she was the only person who knew the real him.
"Well, I don't mind." Lexi said, "I still want to sleep with my favorite brother. Unless you don't want me to..." She added with a pout, hoping that Nathan would see it her way.
"I want you to," Nathan said, reaching across the bed to hold her hand and pull her into bed with him. "But I just wanted to warn you so you know my wang in hanging out and you don't rub against anything you don't want to."
Oh, I want to,
Lexi thought as she got under the covers that night,
maybe I should suggest I sleep naked too?
But she realized that suggestion would only lead to her doing something very naughty that she would only regret afterward and she vowed to always wear pajamas when sleeping with her brother from then on. However, that didn't stop her in any way from taking the covers off them and ogling her brother's body when she was sure he was asleep. She vowed to never touch his nude form though and she only stroked his chest over the blanket from then on.
And that might have been that if not for the other person that Lexi felt she was closer to than anyone else. That was Lexi's BFF, Donna.
Donna and Lexi became friends on the first day of pre-school simply because they were the only two students with red hair. But that quickly blossomed into the two inseparable individuals. In actuality, though they shared the same hair color that was basically where the similarities stopped. Where Lexi was shy, Donna was extroverted. Where Lexi had no sexual experience, Donna had many boyfriends and even a few girlfriends, though she had yet to admit to her friend that she was bisexual.
This was because Donna had a secret. She and Lexi had been friends forever, so when Donna started to develop a crush on her friend she knew telling her about it was likely to destroy her friendship with her, and she just couldn't have that. But that wasn't the end to her secret. Donna also was very attracted to Nathan. Something she had already talked to Lexi about since the first day she said, "You know, your brother is actually very handsome."
To which Lexi replied, "Shut up, he is not!" But she blushed so hard that Donna realized that Lexi also thought as she did: that Nathan was an attractive male. But Lexi had snapped at her so hard and quickly that Donna also realized that Lexi had a legitimate crush on her own twin brother! This realization was so hot to Donna that ever since that day she wanted one thing and one thing only (aside from all those other things she wanted...) and that was to have a "twincestuous" threesome with Lexi and Nathan.
Donna was sure that her fantasy would never happen, but that didn't keep her from pushing her friend a little bit at a time almost every time they hung out together.
After Lexi masturbated to Nathan's body for the first time, she called Donna on the phone, "Donna?" She said feeling weak. She needed some advice, even if she didn't want Donna to know she was the one who needed it.
