📚 the missing piece - Part 1 of 4
Part 1Next →
the-missing-piece-ch-01-1
TABOO SEX STORIES

The Missing Piece -

The Missing Piece -

by Arcadia
19 min read
4.34 (8900 views)
virginmale virginvirgin brotherolder sisteryounger brother
Loading audio...

This is a very slow-burn story with a softer-than-soft-femdom sort of vibe. I hope you enjoy! Whether you do or don't, I always appreciate feedback about what worked and what didn't (: All characters are over 18.

***

My sister and I always got along pretty well. Charlie's 22, and I'm 18, so we were always juuust far enough apart in age that we didn't really get on each other's nerves at school or anything. But also we never really ran in the same circles, which helped too. She's always been more confident and outgoing, and I've always been more...shy and nerdy, I guess is how I'd describe it.

It's not like we were best friends or anything, but still, I missed her being around while she was off in college. For three years, it was just me and our parents at home. It was kinda weird at first, but it became the new normal -- only seeing her around holidays or school vacations.

The previous few summers, she and her best friend, Samantha, stayed in their dorm and then their apartment in their college town a few hours away.

But this year, ahead of her senior year, Charlie came back to stay the summer with us in her old room down the hall -- still decked out with posters of U.S. Women's Soccer players and concerts she'd been to, and home to all manner of stuffed animals and other things I was never allowed to touch on pain of death.

All that's to say that I hadn't gotten used to the idea of needing to lock my bedroom door.

I mean, I thought it was pretty good just for me to have

closed

the door while engaging in the summer afternoon pastime of teenage boys. So when she knocked, I only had time to hastily stuff my hard-on back into my underwear before the door opened and Charlie stuck her head in.

"Hey Danny, Mom texted me and --" she stopped short when she saw what I was doing, stricken with a look of bewilderment and horror -- probably a lot like the one on my own face.

Then she started laughing and took a step inside. I was still frozen, in shock, sitting off-balance in my computer chair with my shorts around my ankles and my hand trying in vain to obscure my only partially stuffed-in dick that was straining to break through my boxers.

"Caught you

red-handed

, you might say!" she said, chuckling to herself. "Well, I was going to say that Mom wanted me to pick something up for dinner...but I see you've already got your hands on some sausage!"

Har har.

I was sure I was red as a tomato from the embarrassment. And why had she

come in

!

"Jesus, get

out!

" I stammered, trying not to fall out of the chair and make the spectacle even worse while I grasped for my shorts.

She just smiled wider.

"So, you'd definitely be okay with

beef strokin'-off

for dinner, then?" she retorted, grinning the grin of someone who could not be more pleased with themselves.

I groaned. "Oh my God, this is embarrassing enough, please just

leave!

"

"Oh okay," she said, sighing. "I was gonna try to work in 'beating your meat' but I hadn't come up with a good setup yet. You'll just have to fill in the blanks on that one I guess."

She gave one last laugh, but, mercifully, backed out the door. I heaved a deep sigh of my own, letting my half-raised shorts fall back down in a heap.

Just before the door closed, though, Charlie's head popped back in, this time with an inquisitive look, not a mocking one.

"Wait a second, is that...?" she squinted her eyes at the computer screen, then took a step back inside.

Fuck. Please don't see --

I stood up and tried to block the screen, then realized that only gave my sister a full-on view of my underwear, though at least my boner had completely subsided. That was the least of my worries now.

"Oh my God, are you jacking off to

Melissa

?"

She didn't look angry, thankfully, more...mischievously intrigued, like she'd just heard me say that I like to drink raw eggs from a glass each morning -- something that makes you go "eww, that's disgusting...

tell me more

."

She took another step closer and leaned to the side so she could see around me. But the damage was already done.

There was no doubt she could see the whole screen now, filled with the bikini-clad bodies of two dark-haired college girls. I'd met Charlie's friend Melissa one time when she'd brought Melissa here a couple summers back. To see the sights I guess. Never asked why. Certainly never asked Melissa.

She was, as the French say,

hot as fuck

, the sexiest woman I'd ever seen in person, and I spent the couple of days she'd stayed here trailing her around the house and petrified any time she talked to me. Or really just noticed me, even. She had long, chocolate-brown hair, breasts that I wouldn't have been able to fit in my hand and a body that was toned and tanned. I'd spent many,

many

a free afternoon and night stroking myself to her pictures on Instagram after she'd left. Okay, and the nights she was here, too.

The one on the screen now was one of my favorites: Melissa standing on a beach, wearing aviators and a neon yellow bikini that hid very little, throwing her arms up in the air in excitement about...well,

something

. I liked to imagine something having to do with me, naturally. But it put her entire body, from head to toe, on display in a way I could never get out of my head.

And who would want to, anyway? The way her hips curved, how smooth every inch of skin looked --

mmm

. What I would do to get that bikini off her.

Still, I had to deny what I was obviously doing, even if it was plain as day.

"Err...

no

!" I finally retorted.

Whew, that oughta convince her!

It had seemed like the smart play, even though it was obvious I was jacking off to that picture. It would've been even weirder if I'd just straight up admitted it to my sister, though, right?

Charlie raised her eyebrow, clearly not even close to buying it, but still looking playful about it rather than enraged. That was good, at least. I think.

She leaned around and looked at the picture again, and her eyebrow arched even further.

📖 Related Taboo Sex Stories Magazines

Explore premium magazines in this category

View All →

"So...if not Melissa, then...jacking off to the

other

lovely lady in that photo are we, hmm?" her eyes flashed with obvious glee that she'd caught me in such an uncomfortable lie.

Wait.

The other...

fuck

.

"Bold choice, brother! Not every boy would have the..." she looked down at my hand trying to cover my bulging boxers in vain, "

balls

to just tell his sister to her face that he's masturbating to her! But nobody can say you're not a bold guy! Hmm, is 'bold' the right word...? Welp, in any case, don't let me stop you!"

She clapped me on the shoulder with mock encouragement, then made a show of leaving the room, triumphant and cackling, while I stammered out my protests.

Holding the door open another moment before she went into the hallway, Charlie turned around with that smirk still plastered on her face, and craned her neck to get another look at the screen.

"Could've at least picked a better photo though," she said, scrunching up her smirk into a thoughtful frown.

And with that, as mysteriously as she'd arrived, the door smacked shut again and I was left to marinate in my embarrassment, boner utterly gone.

Ugh.

She didn't really think I was jerking off to her...right?

Nah, she was joking. Had to be.

I let out a defeated sigh and looked back at the photo. Would this thing ever get me hard again?

Eh, who am I kidding, of course it will.

Honestly, I guess I'd never really thought about Charlie being in the photo with Melissa. I'd just always focused on Melissa, drinking in every little curve and pore I could make out, imagining what each centimeter would taste and feel like.

But truth be told -- in a strictly objective sense, mind you -- my sister

is

just as hot as Melissa, I thought while examining the non-Melissa half of the photo more closely than I ever had before. Melissa was all about curves, but Charlie was more athletic and compact.

Charlie was a little shorter, her frame smaller, skin a little paler, and had darker, blacker hair down to just below her shoulders. Her body was seemingly free of any and all extraneous fat but still...soft and pliable, like the runner she was.

And her legs...how I had never noticed how long they were, how smooth they looked? Suspended in a jet black bikini top, her breasts were smaller than Melissa's too -- though, personally, I liked them that way. I mean, I liked the way they looked and how I

thought

they would feel. I didn't actually have any real experience to compare it to. They seemed like they probably didn't need anything holding them to stay just as perky as they looked, though.

If she weren't my sister, honestly, sure, I'd probably have spent more time learning every little nook and freckle of Charlie's body in that photo instead.

Especially her eyes.

Damn.

Maybe it was something about the lighting, but the way her green eyes just seemed to pierce through the screen...it sent a shiver through me, the kind of shiver you get when somebody traces their fingertips along your neck --

that

kind of shiver.

It was like she was looking right at me, and for some reason, that felt...

adventurous

. I felt my hard-on get a second wind, and I gave in to the sudden urge -- no, not gave in, more like

encouraged

the urge -- to pull my dick out again and start stroking it.

I kept staring at those green eyes of hers, that smirk that looked so familiar. As her little brother, I'd always seen those smirks and devilish grins as warnings. But suddenly it was like I was seeing it from a different angle for the first time. Her half-grin, combined with her magnetic eyes -- it was like she was about to share a naughty secret with me...and

only

me, if I was good.

The thought of those eyes, of

her

, watching me jerk off...it made me harder and harder and I stroked faster and faster. Suddenly I wished that I'd admitted to it instead of deflecting, wishing that she'd known about the million times I'd cum to this picture, to the thought of her friend's tight pussy around my cock, taking my virginity.

I gasped and the count went up to a million-and-one, spilling into a tissue I'd hastily grabbed.

I slumped down in the chair and took a few deep breaths, processing what had just happened in the last five minutes.

What had turned me on so much? Just the thought of Charlie knowing I jerk off to Melissa? Or...Charlie

watching

me jerk off to Melissa? Or what? Of course, it wasn't Melissa I'd just jerked off to....

She hadn't fled the room when she saw what I was doing, instead she looked...curious. And amused. Something about that look just....

I shuddered, then gave out another little contented groan, still massaging myself.

Finally I shook my head, wiped myself off and pulled my shorts back up.

Too weird to think about. Let's not do this again.

***

When I heard Charlie come back to the house a while later, presumably with the dinner Mom'd asked her to get, I felt way too sheepish to leave my room until I absolutely had to. Even though we'd lived together my whole life prior to the last few years, I couldn't recall something as embarrassing as that ever happening between us before.

Ugh.

When Mom called up the stairs for dinner, I had yet to come up with a good excuse to stay in my room, so I opened my door and began the death march down to the kitchen.

Charlie and Mom were bustling about preparing dinner, and neither of them paid me much attention. Dad was at the table already.

Both parents greeted me without really looking up from what they were doing -- Mom taking plates out of the cabinet and Dad on his phone. I didn't look over toward the stove where Charlie was, but I had the uncanny feeling her green eyes were burrowing into my back and she was smirking. Maybe it just felt that way, though.

Soon enough everybody was seated at the table, ready to dig into the dinner Charlie'd made -- corn and hot dogs.

Real classy choices, Charlie.

"I didn't think you really liked hot dogs, Charlotte," Mom said as she filled up her plate.

🔓

Unlock Premium Content

Join thousands of readers enjoying unlimited access to our complete collection.

Get Premium Access

🛍️ Featured Products

Premium apparel and accessories

Shop All →

Charlie took a hot dog and held it up thoughtfully, dangling it inquisitively between two of her slender fingers.

"Eh, Melissa really turned me on to those bigger, like, bratwurst sausage things at college, and so I thought, you know, maybe just a little ol' tiny-bit-smaller-than-average hot dog would be pretty good too," she said, putting her hot dog in a bun and casually turning those green eyes to me. "Melissa turns a lot of people on, I hear. To new things, that is."

Jesus. Okay, Charlie. I fucking get it.

I rolled my eyes.

"Oh how

is

Melissa?" Mom asked, apparently oblivious to Charlie's wordplay.

Charlie paused and took a bite.

"She's holding up pretty well," Charlie said after chewing, her cat's-meow-expression replaced by something else. "I guess. I haven't talked to her since -- since the semester ended."

"Oh," Mom responded. "Well, maybe you should give her a call. I'm sure she'd like to have someone to talk to, too."

Charlie took a long time to finish chewing her bite. "Yeah, maybe," she said, then was quiet.

They started talking about something else, but I focused on my plate, determined to finish and get out before Charlie could think up any more "clever" innuendos to put me on edge.

After a while I felt a kick under the table and looked up at Charlie in surprise.

"Huh?"

"I said, did you help your sister with dinner?" Mom said, apparently repeating a question to me that I hadn't heard.

Charlie interjected.

"Oh yeah, he certainly

lent a hand

," she said, laying it on thick again. "Helped out, too -- he was buttering his corn practically

alllll afternoon

."

Wow. Did she buy corn...

just to make that joke?

I stared at her with a mix of incredulousness and awe at the commitment and planning that went into some lame double entendres that only I would get.

"But the corn wasn't buttered already," I heard Dad mutter, though he shrugged it off, thank goodness. Who knows what witty ripostes Charlie had prepared for any such follow-ups.

"So what have you kids got going on tomorrow?" Dad asked instead.

A teenage boy without a summer job and a proclivity for computer games, I unashamedly shrugged my shoulders. Hey, it was my last summer before college and I was determined to enjoy it.

"Nothin'," I said.

Dad didn't look surprised and turned to my sister.

"Yeah I dunno," Charlie said, playing around with some corn on her plate without seeming to look at anything in particular. "To an appointment and then, I dunno. Out. Probly won't be back 'til late."

Mom and Dad seemed to exchange looks, but I tuned out again after I was pretty sure nobody was talking to me anymore. I quickly finished up and went back upstairs without incident.

Whew!

***

By the time I got up the next day, Charlie was on her way out -- "seeing Sam," she said before slamming the door behind her -- so I didn't see her much, thank goodness.

I spent most of the day in my room, my headphones shutting out the world while I was on my computer, emerging only for meals and to pee -- so in other words, just the perfect summer day for a guy like me.

It was well after midnight when I took off my headset and quit my game, ready to call it a day. I went to the bathroom, then headed downstairs to grab a glass of water. The light was on in the living room, so I guess Charlie was home. I hadn't heard her come in.

Leaving my water, I went over to the archway that led to the living room, and saw just one lamp on next to Charlie, not enough to light the whole room. She was standing off to one side, bent over a card table that I guess she'd brought in there, staring at what looked like puzzle pieces strewn across it.

Wtf? What is this, 1954? Charlie is doing a puzzle? At like, 1 a.m.?

But the thoughts of the puzzle were fleeting, replaced immediately once my gaze moved up from the table to Charlie. Half in shadow, her eyes seemed to burn like green embers. She shifted her weight back and forth, thoughtfully considering the puzzle and, watching her from the side, I could see every tensing of the muscles in her long, sinewy legs. She was wearing a gray T-shirt with her university's name on it that would ride up when she leaned to the far end of the table for a puzzle piece, and dark blue boy shorts that clung to her skin as tightly as I suddenly felt myself wanting to.

It was impossible not to stare when she would reach like that, the small of her back and the supple bulge of her butt drawing too much attention to themselves to be ignored. Or that's how it felt anyway.

I must've been standing there for a full minute until she finally clued me in that she knew I had been there the whole time.

"Did you...want something?" she said in the kind of voice you use when it's 1 a.m. and you don't want to wake up your parents. But she continued to frown at the pieces on the table instead of looking over to me.

"Nope, just...trying to figure out why you're doing a puzzle," I said, walking over next to her and taking a look at the pieces on the table. I struggled, but managed to keep my eyes there instead of roaming my sister's body.

How had I never realized how fucking hot she was before yesterday?

She didn't look like the same gleefully needling sister who'd cackled about my masturbatory habits the day before. She wasn't wearing makeup, which wasn't weird since she was at home anyway, but only added to the effect of her being a little...softer. A little less guarded.

"Just felt like maybe it'd be fun," she said with a shrug.

"A...puzzle? Okay," I said, not really believing something like that could be

fun

when there were so many other things someone could do.

Like a puzzle on a computer, at least. Less cleanup! But whatever.

"What of?" I asked instead.

She picked up the box lid and turned it over so I could see. It was a 500-piece puzzle with Disney branding, a scene from some movie, I guess, showing a boy and a girl at the far end of a roughly hewn but ornate-looking wooden bridge.

"Bridge to Ter-a-bith-i-a," I sounded out under my breath.

"Yeah," she responded, returning the box top to the table. "It's a book too. I remember Sam saying it was one of her favorites as a kid."

She gave another little shrug.

"I dunno, looked fun. I don't remember doing any of them as a kid, do you?" she said, idly waving at the stack of puzzles precariously stacked on the shelf against the wall. "They just seemed like, part of the scenery of the bookshelf."

"Umm, no, no I don't...."

Probably because puzzles are boring....

I kept that last thought to myself and we both just stood there in silence for a while as she continued in her quest for edge pieces.

The late-night quiet seemed mesmerizing, making every sound -- the steady tick of the old grandfather clock against the wall, the far-off hum of a car engine, the refrigerator in the kitchen kicking on -- somehow more muted than usual, but at the same time, more distinct than ever.

"When Sam and I were roommates, she'd always take up a whole table with a puzzle," Charlie said to the table, breaking the gentle silence after a few moments.

"You aren't roommates with Sam anymore?"

She looked up at me, clearly a little annoyed that I'd bounced her off whatever train of thought she'd been on. "Huh? Uh, no, not when I'm living here, obviously."

I nodded in mock understanding.

Enjoyed this story?

Rate it and discover more like it

You Might Also Like