As the week started, I found it hard to focus. Images kept flashing through my mind. Emma's flushed face as she watched me fuck Syd's mouth. Syd having her moans silenced by Emma's kisses. Emma handing us washcloths to clean the copious cum off our bodies. Syd's grin as Emma admitted how much she loved what we've been doing.
This lewd PowerPoint would play in my head, and then I'd blink and realize I'd missed the majority of a lecture or forgotten a bar-goer's order. I did my best to snap out of it, but it was no use. The thoughts of my girlfriend and my sister together had become a drug. I was addicted.
Syd and I would make out passionately after work and then she would smile and push me away. "I want us to build some anticipation, babe. It'll be worth it. Just be patient."
I would grumble and walk away, but it was for the best. I'm sure Emma was feeling the same way, and a little more excitement could only improve things.
By Thursday I'd become so consumed with school and work that I was finally able to think about things other Emma and Syd. It wasn't like I'd forgotten about what we did or the upcoming surprise, but I was able to get through the day without getting so distracted with horny memories that I fully malfunctioned.
And when I returned to the apartment I was too busy thinking about something I'd just learned to notice Emma and Syd smirking about something they'd been discussing. They were making dinner, and it didn't occur to me until we were all sat down enjoying it that this might be the night of the surprise. Dinner conversation was fairly normal, for us at least. Flirty and familiar, but nothing special.
My hopes about the surprise were dashed when Emma said she'd be heading back to her room for the night to tackle some homework. She kissed each of our cheeks and then disappeared.
As we had a few nights this week, Syd and I ended up making out, this time on the couch in the living room. But this time Syd didn't pump the brakes once things started getting hot and heavy. I wondered if Syd was just too hot for me to keep up the anticipation game.
Soon enough Sid was on the floor, kneeling between my legs, desperately pulling off my belt and pushing my pants down. My cock was halfway down her throat before I knew it.
Usually this sequence of events would lead to a few minutes of enthusiastic cock-sucking before Syd would stand, disrobe, and impale herself on me.
But not this time. She was slurping, slobbering, gagging. Using every move. Once she heard me moaning she started using her hands and mouth in concert, the same way she usually did when she was trying to finish me off. I felt like a game being speedrunned. I might have said something if it didn't feel so fucking good. Sydney seemed incredibly excited that I was close. Despite still being fully dressed, her tits and pussy untouched, her moans, muffled by the cock in her mouth, were almost as loud as my own. I briefly felt bad for Emma, who must have been struggling to focus on her work. But at the same time we were all long past feeling shy or apologetic about the sounds heard through this apartment's walls.
When Syd heard me roar and then begin filling her mouth, she moaned so loud I wondered if she was cumming tantrically, untouched, just from witnessing my own orgasm. With each throb of my cock she'd growl out another moan. She looked up at me with fire and mischief in her gorgeous eyes. As the muscles in my groin stopped clenching, she pulled back, clearly being careful not to spill anything.
When I would have expected her to tilt back her head and make a big show of gulping, or perhaps open her mouth to show off the pool on her tongue, she instead reached down to knock in a rhythmic pattern on the hardwood floor.
As soon as she was done, Emma's door swung open. She came out wearing her normal pajamas, walking right towards us. Even just a few days ago I might have instinctively moved to cover myself in front of my sister, but we were beyond that now. And anyway, Emma seemed to only have eyes for Sydney, who was now standing and turning to my approaching sister.
I didn't realize what was happening until it was happening. Emma walked right up to Sydney, embraced her, and pulled her into a kiss. Not a peck. I couldn't see it happening, but I knew Syd was pushing my load into Emma's mouth. Emma didn't flinch. In fact, she groaned, as if her life depended on swallowing every drop.
Their kiss was a hungry, needy kiss, and it went on and on, my sister and my girlfriend moaning softly into each others' mouths. I imagined my cum trading between their mouths, back and forth, forth and back.
And when they finally pulled away from each other, Emma turned to me, opened her mouth, and showed me that all of that cum had ended up with her. Then she closed her mouth and swallowed.
"Thanks for dessert, bro." She and Syd exchanged a mischievous grin.
I was shocked. Stunned. Dumbfounded. And horny. So, so horny.
Emma licked her lips and made a yummy sound. Then she kind of shrugged. "... But I do actually have a ton of work to do." She pouted and blew me a kiss before retreating back to her room.
In stunned silence I turned to look at Sydney, who did an adorable little curtsey and said, "Surprise!"
I shook my head and blinked a few times. "That... was incredible. And not what I was expecting."
Syd plopped down onto my lap. "I know! What did you expect? Was this not better?" She grinned.
I laughed. "Much better."
"I thought about springing it on both of you, but I figured it was better to make sure she was into it. Luckily she was *very* into it." My heart skipped a beat at the thought that my sister had been so excited to eat my cum.
My eyes unfocused as I thought about that, but then I remembered I had a beautiful, horny woman in my lap.
I looked at her with intensity. "Get on the bed and take your pants off."
She gasped, then smirked. "Yes sir."
I ate her out until I was hard again, getting an orgasm out of her in the process. And when I was ready to go, I flipped her over onto all fours and pounded away. Knowing Emma, with my cum in her belly, could hear every moan, every spank, every grunt only made it better.
I fucked Syd to another orgasm, then filled her with cum. When I finally pulled out, some of my cum followed, dripping out and onto the sheets below. She collapsed onto the bed, her ass and pussy in the air, oozing a puddle.
"This is quite the sight." Syd giggled, and then turned to lay down with me. We were quickly asleep.