SUNDAY
I must have fallen asleep on top of Dana, because the next thing I remember, I woke up, in the dark, in her bed. I could feel Dana next to me, as we had, somehow, gotten into the spoon position during the night. I could smell her hair, mixed with the scent of sweat and sex. Her smooth back nestled against my chest and my limp cock was pressing against her ass. I looked at the clock, surprised to see that it was 5:30 in the morning.
I was surprisingly alert, considering Saturday's activities and my drinking. I began to replay the day in my mind, from Ariel's surprise visit and the pool sex, Dad's date with Mrs. Angelo, the party, Fred and Emily, maybe Gina and Hank, my interrupted flirtation with Natalie, and staying over at Dana's.
Thinking about all of that, and realizing that I was in bed, naked and spooning with Dana, I felt myself getting hard, and the tip of my cock poked between Dana's butt cheeks a little. Whether because she felt that, or not, she pressed against me tighter, so that I was even further in, her warm, soft skin enveloping my cock. Dana's breathing was slow and even, so I assumed she was asleep. I held her tight against me, and gently thrust my cock further between her legs.
Without turning, Dana whispered to me in a sleepy voice, "Are you waking me up at this ridiculous hour to fuck again?"
I thought I was busted, and stammered, "um, kind of, not really, uh, I guess."
She chucked softly and said, "Great idea," and she pressed her ass hard against me. I reached over with my free hand and started stroking her breasts and withdrew my cock slowly from between her thighs.
She lifted her leg and slid my cock into her surprisingly well lubricated pussy from behind. Unlike our active fucking the night before, this was slow and gentle. We stayed like this, moving in rhythm while I toyed with her nipples until I came. I realized that she hadn't, and reached down to try to get her off with my hands, but she pushed my hand away, saying, "it's O.K. I don't have to cum every time. I know that you aren't taking me for granted. That felt nice, and I'm glad you got off."
We cuddled and dozed for a while, until about 7, when Dana got up to go to the bathroom. When she returned, she told me that her mother's room was empty and her car was not in the driveway. I mentally high-fived my father, and then realized how weird that was. We got up and I took a quick shower and got dressed. I was feeling pretty confident with Dana at that point, so I decided to ask her something that was bothering me.
"Can I ask you something, and don't get mad."
"Sure," she responded.
"Um, yesterday, we had that talk about not being a couple and all," I started.
She looked at me and smiled, "and you want to know why I interfered with your attempt to get into Natalie's pants at the party?"
"Well, yeah, I mean, I wasn't even sure about her."
"No, I could see you liked her, and I really hope you pursue her."
"I don't understand," I replied, confused.
"I meant what I said yesterday. We aren't a couple, and both of us are free to see whoever we want. But here's a dirty secret about meâI am competitive. I have always used my looks to get what I want. I admit that. And when you aren't with me, you should do what, and who, you want. But in my house, when you have a choice between me and someone else, I always want you to pick me. You passed that test, and, I think, made out better than you would have if you had kept after Natalie."
I listened and thought I understood. I said, "So, what you are saying, is you are O.K. with me seeing other people, as long as I pick you when given the choice?"
"Exactly. I'm not proud of that, but that's the way I see it."
"I think I understand. I can live with that now," I said.
So, the bottom line was, nothing was different. Dana had, as she always had, the power to let me continue to fuck her, if she wanted, and I could do anything I wanted with anyone else, but if she wanted to have sex with me, and I chose someone else over her, I was finished. That actually seemed fair to me under the circumstances. We kissed and I stood up to leave.
As I was getting ready to leave the house, Mrs. Angelo came through the door, wearing no makeup, with wet hair held in a ponytail and wearing a t-shirt I recognized as my father's and sweatpants with his college logo on it. She looked a bit embarrassed seeing me leaving her house, but under the circumstances, she didn't say anything but "hi" and "goodbye" as I said the same. I drove home considering the awkwardness of that last exchange. It probably would have been even more awkward if Mr. Angelo had known that I actually had sex with both of her daughters the day before. I chuckled to myself, thinking of that, and cranked up the radio.
When I got home, Dad was sitting at the dining room table drinking coffee. I poured myself a cup of coffee and sat down with him.
He broke the somewhat uncomfortable silence by saying, "I take it that the party went well?"
"Yeah," I responded.
"You look tired," he said. "Uncomfortable couch?" he asked, with a little friendly sarcasm in his voice.
"Something like that," I responded, smiling broadly. "I saw Mrs. Angelo coming into the house when I was leaving," I countered.
Dad smiled back at me and looked a little embarrassed himself.
"I guess that meant your date went well," I said, jocularly.
"I guess it did," he said, grinned and took a swig of coffee. "There seems to be something irresistible about the women in that family," he mused.
"Maybe it is us who are irresistible to them," I responded.
Dad laughed, then turned quiet again.
"You know, Mom would want you to be happy," I said.
"I think you're right," he said, softly.
I got up from the table and went to my room. I had a bunch of stuff to get done. I needed to study for my final on Monday. I needed to check in with Fred and Gina and post-mortem the party. I needed to text Natalie, and keep the lines of communication open, and I needed to talk to Dana, just because. But first, I needed to sleep, so I got into my bed and passed out.
My phone awakened me a couple of hours later. It was Fred, texting meâ"meet me and Gina at the coffee shop."
I responded, "O.K.âhow'd it go with Emily?"
"Score!" he responded.
"Sweet!!" I replied. "See you in a few".
I got up and got dressed. When I came downstairs, Sarah was watching TV.
"How was the party?" she asked.
"Great," I said. "I was actually flirting with this girl, Natalie, and was doing pretty well, I thought, but then Dana sort of lured me away."
Sarah looked at me and said, "Good for you. I hope you didn't burn your bridges with Natalie, though."
"I hope not," I said, "I kind of liked her, but couldn't turn Dana down."
"I understandâgirls like Dana are hard to resist. By the way," she asked, "did Gina go to the party?"