📚 brother nightingale Part 3 of 4
nightingale-ch-03
GAY SEX STORIES

Brother Nightingale

Brother Nightingale

by Finleydixon
19 min read
4.8 (2900 views)
incestthreesomegay oralgay analspit roast
Loading audio...

Despite his best efforts, Timmy couldn't get the sensation of Frank's cock out of his mind. The flavor of his brother's cum swirled around his tongue. He was rock hard again, wanting more.

In high school, he heard other boys joke about 69ing. As he imagined Frank going down on him while he got his face fucked, a glob of pre-cum dripped from his slit.

He pictured someone else joining him and his older brother--a third body tangled between them, new hands, new lips. His dick throbbed, but a knot of uncertainty formed in his chest. Would he feel jealous? Would it still feel special if he had to share Frankie?

Timmy's cheeks flushed as his thoughts spiraled. He desperately wanted Frankie's dick again, to taste his brother's come. Blow jobs, though incredible, didn't scratch this new longing inside him--a longing to press his lips against Frank's, to feel his firm body pinning him down, to give his brother pleasure in a way that went beyond just his mouth.

His heart raced as his imagination ran wild--to feel what it was like to give himself to his brother completely. The thought sent a jolt of heat through his body.

Sleep eluded Timmy, the ache between his legs radiating through his body, buzzing in his head like static. He shifted as much as the casts allowed, trying to ease the pressure, but it only seemed to make it worse.

Memories flickered through Timmy's mind.

A younger Frank, standing tall in ear protectors and a singlet, his body taut with muscle, sweat glistening under the bright gym lights. Their parents cheered from the high school auditorium stands. Timmy right there beside them.

Would he have developed Frankie's build if he had wrestled instead of swum?

Since high school, Frank had only bulked up more, his broad shoulders and muscular arms filling out, while Timmy had stayed slight. Lean--almost delicate, next to his big brother. Just like most of the girls at school, Timmy stared in quiet awe at his older brother's physique, trying to ignore the tingle that sometimes surged between his legs..

They roughhoused often to their mother's irritation. Frank pinning him down, their bodies tangled in a playful struggle, their breath ragged from exertion. Timmy loved it--had thrived on the feeling of being beneath Frank, held in place by his strength--until the day it gave him a boner.

After that, he resisted Frank's invitations to sporadic playfulness.

Had Frankie noticed? Ever wondered why Timmy suddenly stopped engaging, why he twisted away when Frank tried to wrestle like they used to?

Would they have done stuff sooner?

Would he have still tried to serve a Mormon mission?

The front door creaked.

Timmy's ears perked up. Frankie was home.

His big brother stumbled in, the sound of his keys clanking against the entryway.

"Shh, man," he mumbled, followed by a quiet chuckle.

Timmy's stomach twisted. He wasn't alone.

A second set of footsteps followed--lighter, more careful. A hushed voice murmured something Timmy couldn't make out, and Frank laughed softly in response.

A vortex of excitement and apprehension bubbled in Timmy's gut. He strained to hear more, his heart hammering. Was this really happening?

-

Frank felt the warmth of alcohol in his veins, numbing the hesitation he might have had if he were sober. He wasn't wasted--just loose enough to stop thinking so damn much.

He barely remembered how it had happened. One drink after closing. Then two. A conversation. A hand on his thigh. It was nice to be reminded that others still wanted him.

Because this thing with Timmy? It was getting dangerous. The way Timmy looked at him. The way Frank caught himself wanting him back.

So maybe this was a test. Maybe if he brought someone home, felt someone else's body against his, this would all fade. Maybe he'd wake up tomorrow and this thing between them wouldn't seem so... so heavy.

-

Timmy held his breath as he listened to them.

Timmy's heart clenched. He had imagined this moment--wondered if he'd feel jealous or indifferent. But now that it was real, a sharp, hollow ache settled in his chest.

He turned his eyes back to the TV, but the screen blurred.

Maybe Frank needed this. Maybe

he

needed this.

He glanced down at his immobilized body. Weeks would pass before the casts came off, leaving him vulnerable and stuck. Did Frankie tell him? Would the guy he brought be into that? Would Timmy just have to watch?

The thought sent another lance of tension through his chest, leaving him breathless and tingling.

Frankie appeared in the bedroom doorway, his grin wide and mischievous. He stepped aside, gesturing toward someone just out of view.

A thin, black-haired young man stepped into the room, dressed in a black tank that clung to his chest and tight, ripped jeans. His grin was hesitant, his gaze mostly fixed on the floor, though his dark eyes flicked up to glance at Timmy before darting away again.

"Derek's never had a threesome," Frankie said, his tone casual but excited. "And he thinks messin' around with brothers would be super fuckin' hot."

Derek nodded, his grin widening slightly as his hands fidgeted at his sides. "Didn't tell me how cute your brother is."

Timmy's stomach knotted, his face burning. He flicked his gaze between Frank and Derek, unsure what to say, but the heat in his groin was undeniable.

Frank turned to him, his expression softening as he gave a questioning look. It wasn't demanding or impatient--just a quiet request for permission.

Timmy swallowed hard, mouth dry. His heart raced as he nodded, face pale with uncertainty, but his body betraying him with a tingling rush of anticipation.

"Can I?" Pointing at the middle of the hospital gown, Derek looked at Frankie first, then Timmy, which the little brother thought was strange.

Timmy gave a nod.

Derek crept toward the little brother lying on the bed, pinched the end of the gown, and lifted. He licked his teeth. "Mmm."

The dark-haired boy bent over and wrapped his thin fingers around the younger brother's shaft.

Timmy gasped. Somehow, just knowing it was someone new touching him sent a jolt from balls to brain. Derek's tongue lapped at Timmy's slit and circled it. Timmy shuttered as he closed his eyes. The technique and viscosity of Derek's mouth registered differently from Frank's in subtle and surprising ways. His skin rushed with a cascade of goosebumps.

The rustling of fabric and a bounce of Derek's body spurred Timmy to open an eye. Frankie stood behind Derek, ass already exposed, body bent over the edge of the bed. Derek moaned as Frank knelt and mashed his face into Derek's crack.

Timmy's dick twitched in Derek's mouth. For a moment, he worried all the visual and physical stimulation would push him over the edge too quickly, but Frank had been such a good brother, he wasn't pent up.

Just then, Frank climbed to his feet and fished out his rock hard cock from his pants. He pumped a few globs of lube on his fingers and rubbed it on Derek's backside, then slid the rest over his cock. Frank bit his lip as he aimed his tip.

Derek groaned around Timmy's cock.

Chest tightening, Timmy's breath quickened.

Frank pounded Derek. The slapping of his hips against the guy's ass rose in volume and tempo.

Derek pulled his mouth off Timmy's cock. "Ah, yeah, daddy, fuck me!"

One of Derek's hands reached under his hips, tugging. "God, I forgot how thick you are," He panted before bobbing on Timmy's cock again.

Derek and Timmy jumped when Frank spanked Derek's bare ass with a loud smack. Their guest squealed like a slutty porn star.

"You like that cock?" Frank growled.

Derek whimpered, Timmy's cock deep in his throat.

"I'm gonna breed that fucking ass."

Derek moaned.

"I'm gonna pump you so full you're gonna pop."

Frank's rate of ramming increased dramatically while Derek moaned with each penetrating thrust. Derek's entire body bounced. He gasped for breath through his nose.

Timmy's cock responded, imagining he was the one taking Frank. The pressure under his sack grew. "I'm going to cum!"

Derek squealed as he forced the cock deeper down his throat.

📖 Related Gay Sex Stories Magazines

Explore premium magazines in this category

View All →

Timmy yelled, hips thrusting as much as his casts would allow.

Derek pulled off, gulped down Timmy's cum, and cried out. "Jesus! I'm coming."

Frank growled. "Fuck, f-f-fuck! Fuck ya." His pumping slowed.

Out of breath, Derek rested his temple on Timmy's hip, softening dick still in his mouth. He glanced up at Timmy and gave the little brother's dick a smooch before he pushed himself off the bed, stood and turned to Frank, kissing him.

"That was so fucking hot!" Derek said.

Frank smiled and pulled Derek into another kiss, his little brother's cum still fresh on his tongue.

"No one fucks me quite like you." Derek brimmed.

In practiced efficiency, Derek pulled on his jeans, zipped them up, and squeezed into his tank. He winked at Frank and blew Timmy a kiss. "Don't be strangers."

And just like that, the door clicked shut behind him.

Frank lingered for a moment, listening to Derek's footsteps fade down the hall. His grin stayed on his lips, but something about the silence that followed felt heavier than it should have.

He strutted back to the bedroom, rolling his shoulders, forcing an easy smirk. He wasn't sure why he felt the need to perform for Timmy, but he did.

"So?"

Timmy pursed his lips, lifting a brow.

Frank chuckled. "How was it?"

Timmy nodded, a wide smile stretching across his face before he could stop it.

Frank bit his lip and nodded, running a hand through his hair. "We need to hang with him again."

He said it like a casual suggestion, but something about the words sat weird in his chest. Would Timmy want that? Did

he

even want that? He should. It made sense. Derek was easy, eager. No complications. No

feelings

.

But Frank's stomach twisted. The memory of Derek's body beneath him was already fading, but the way Timmy was looking at him now--that stayed. That stuck.

-

Part of Timmy loved watching Frank get what he needed, what he deserved. But another part of him--a deeper, hungrier part--ached to be the one to give it to him.

There was still so much Timmy didn't understand about himself, so much he needed to learn.

The thought of Frank inside him--deep, twitching, filling him up--sent a slow, pulsing ache through his core. His breath caught, his fingers twitching uselessly against the ends of his casts. His stomach coiled tight.

Derek clearly

loved

it. The way his body moved, the sounds he made--it was obvious.

But was that only how bottoms felt?

What if Timmy wasn't a bottom? What if he

couldn't

enjoy it the same way?

His stomach knotted at the thought.

Frank leaned against the doorway, watching him. "What's the matter?"

Timmy blinked up at him, unsure how to put it into words. "Nothing."

-

Frank had been about to joke, to tease, but something in the way Timmy looked at him made him pause. There was hesitation in his little brother's expression, but something else too--something searching.

He forced another grin, pushing off the doorway and crossing the room to ruffle Timmy's hair. His heart pounded harder than it should have. He should feel good right now. Relaxed. Satisfied.

But all he could think about was Timmy.

Frank's gaze drifted to the doorway. "Gonna rustle up some grub, okay?" He strode out of the room, giving his little brother a smile just before he disappeared into the kitchen.

As Frank opened the fridge door and rummaged, Two voices echoed in his head. One saying he needed to lock Timmy down, the other said dating Timmy was absurd and he should prepare them both for the inevitable.

Frank's eyes burned at the thought of Timmy leaving. The burning traveled to his gut when he pictured him leaving with some sexy stranger. He shook his head. He loved Timmy in more ways than one, and if he really loved him, he should give him the option to leave, to experience men other than him.

Sure, he allowed someone else to suck Timmy's cock, but he was there. They used Derek like a doubled ended flesh light. It was hardly freedom.

Frank realized that once those casts came off, Timmy would want--maybe even need--to experiment. It was a rite of passage.

What would he do if the roles were reversed?

The thought amused him. He imagined a possessive, sulking Timmy, trying to keep him from hooking up.

Frank chuckled. Yeah, right? Timmy would never.

Still, the idea nagged at him as he made their sandwiches, slicing Timmy's into neat, bite-sized pieces. His little brother was too new to all this, and Frank knew firsthand how easy it was to get lost in something intoxicating.

"The sooner, the better," Frank muttered under his breath.

"What?" Timmy called from the other room. "Did you say something?"

Frank stiffened. "Noth--" He cleared his throat. "Turkey fine?"

"Uh huh," Timmy said.

Frank carried the plate to the bed, setting Timmy's plate on the bedside table. Like always, he fed Timmy first, lifting each square to his lips, wiping away any stray crumbs when necessary.

Timmy met his gaze, eyes warm, trusting.

Frank's chest tightened.

He had to do this.

"When do you wanna see Derek again?" Frank asked.

Timmy hesitated. "I don't know." His throat bobbed with a swallow. "How long have you known--how long have you been--?"

Frank blushed, mouth in a wide, thin smile. "A while."

A quiet lingered.

Frank glanced at his phone, checking the time. If he didn't say this quickly, he wouldn't say it at all. "You know, I feel bad leaving you here by yourself so much," he said.

"It's f--"

"I'm gonna ask him to keep you company tonight."

Timmy inhaled sharply. "What, n--Frankie, wait." His voice breathless, as if the words had been knocked out of him.

🔓

Unlock Premium Content

Join thousands of readers enjoying unlimited access to our complete collection.

Get Premium Access

🛍️ Featured Products

Premium apparel and accessories

Shop All →

Frank gazed at him, his expression unreadable. Soft eyes, steady voice--like he wasn't tearing something between them.

"He's not some rando." Frank said. "We kinda dated--or at least met up a lot."

A sinking feeling crept in Timmy's gut. "Are you--in--?"

"In love with Derek?" Frank chuckled. "Nah, just a quick, easy lay." He folded his arms. "What do you think?"

Timmy licked his lips. "I'm not sure." He looked away.

Frank tilted his head. "About what?"

"If I--" Timmy cleared his throat. "If I, uh, want anyone--"

His voice broke.

"If I want anyone else." Timmy's gaze dropped to his lap. He couldn't look at his big brother.

Silence.

Frank smiled thinly. "I know how you feel."

Timmy risked a glance at him, but the moment their eyes met, he looked away.

Frank exhaled, his voice thick. "I can't tell you how great it's been since--" His throat tightened. "Since you came to stay."

He forced a swallow, then another.

"But y-you'll be better before long, a-a-and there's so much world out there."

Timmy's chest squeezed. Frank never stuttered.

His big brother was strong, always strong. Seeing even a hint of vulnerability in him made Timmy ache.

Frank took a slow breath. "We shouldn't want a Mormon life."

Timmy huffed out a small laugh.

"You know what I mean," Frank said, running a hand through his hair. "Locked in monogamy, hoping the next life will be more interesting."

Timmy nodded, slower this time.

Frank's voice softened. "We have each other for the important stuff."

He hesitated, then reached out, tucking a stray lock of hair behind Timmy's ear. His touch lingered on his little brother's cheek.

"But there's a whole world I want you to see--to experience."

Timmy gulped.

Frank sat back, his voice quieter now. "I'll show you more, but I can't show you everything."

Frank's chin quivered. "No one can."

They both sat there for minutes, saying nothing--the words both spoken and not seeping slowly into their minds. This thing, whatever it was--was special and needed special care. They couldn't go by a script, let alone the Mormon one.

Relationships had a way of changing how people felt about one another. They didn't want to become like so many others, especially their parents--resenting, staying together out of sheer Mormon stubbornness.

Frank placed a hand on Timmy's good thigh. "Sleep on it." He gave his brother a tight smile.

Timmy dipped his chin with a nod.

Doubt swirled in Timmy's head as he struggled to get some sleep. Was his big brother right, or completely wrong? Would this ruin everything? Mormon's sex lives might be boring--vanilla. But they were happy, right?

Timmy's thoughts flashed with memories of their Mother yelling at their dad... their dad giving Mom the silent treatment... pretending everything was perfect for others.

No, they were never happy--none of them were. The church just told them they were because they were Mormon, and if they weren't, it was their fault--their sins--or lack of faith. You got good at pretending to be happy.

Timmy sighed to himself. He couldn't imagine the path ahead. It seemed so foreign, but a quiet voice in his head told him to trust Frankie.

***

Timmy blinked, taking a deep breath, wishing more than anything he could stretch his arms. The ache in his muscles mirrored the frustration curling inside him. Confined. Stuck. Dependent.

He frowned.

Frank was right.

He wanted Timmy to be free--to reach, to move. Not caged.

The realization settled over him like a slow wave, both comforting and terrifying. Breaking the mold they'd been forced into their whole lives wouldn't be easy. It would take time--maybe even effort--to unlearn the instincts drilled into them:

The instant jump to jealousy.

The need to possess someone fully, in every way.

Timmy's chest tightened. He still wanted Frank--badly. That hadn't changed.

But maybe... maybe they could have each other and more.

Maybe there was a way to be with each other without--without limits.

Through the open bedroom door, Timmy could see his big brother lying on the couch, cuddling with a throw pillow. He smiled to himself. It'd be nice to have company while Frank was at work. Someone to help him with the remote, a snack, or--a hard-on.

Frank yawned and sighed. Their eyes met, a grin breaking across both their faces.

A silent understanding forming between them.

***

Hours later, there was a knock at the door. Frank's voice met with Derek's greeting, back pats audible.

"Hey hot stuff." Derek strutted into the room from behind Frank, grinning at the bedridden brother.

"You get settled. Gonna finish getting ready for work." Frank said.

Placing a hand on Timmy's bare thigh, Derek leaned in and gave him a peck on the lips.

Timmy blushed. His cock swelled.

Frank said his goodbyes and closed the door behind him while the two boys in bed watched some reruns of "Will & Grace."

The series' piano theme played over the credits. Derek turned to Timmy. "Need anything?" He drew a circle around Timmy's upper inner thigh.

Timmy swallowed. What would Derek do with him now that Frank wasn't there to supervise? How well did his big brother really know him?

Timmy was still completely immobile, and helpless. Derek could take advantage.

"Water." Timmy said, his voice shaky.

Smiling, Derek winked, bounced off the bed, and darted out of the room. He returned moments later with a full glass, including a straw.

Timmy smiled and wrapped his lips around the tip of the straw.

Derek watched Timmy intently, batting his eyes. "Frank told me what a natural you are with your mouth."

Timmy choked.

"You're so cute." Derek giggled. His grin grew sinister. "I'm more interested in what you can do with this." He reached under Timmy's gown and squeezed his hard shaft.

Timmy drew a sharp breath.

Eyes locked on Timmy's, Derked moved his face closer to the younger brother's groin.

Enjoyed this story?

Rate it and discover more like it

You Might Also Like