Part One: The Sinclairs
Zack said nothing after Connor walked into the room. Connor viewed the scene on the sofa. Eddie and Billy were now sitting up, having seen their dad walk in. Zack was frozen in fear, like a deer trapped in headlights.
"It's okay Zack. No one here is going to hurt you."
Connor watched the boy lean forward, as if preparing to make a break for it. He sighed with frustration. This was not going to be easy. And his sons' inability to keep their dicks in their pants for half an hour was not going to make things easier. "I thought I told you boys to behave."
Eddie smiled with what he hoped was an innocent smile. "Sorry dad. We just couldn't help ourselves." Connor shot him a parental look that told him without words to shut it. Zack's eyes widened when he realized what Eddie had said.
"Dad? DAD?" Connor could see the panic in Zack's eyes. Both Eddie and Billy heard his heart racing faster and faster.
Billy lay his hand on Zack's leg, hoping to calm him. "It's really okay, Zack-"
Zack interrupted him before he could continue, pushing Billys hand away. "This was a set up! I can't believe I fell for this! I can't believe I had sex with you-both of you!"
Zack stood up and started frantically looking around for his clothing. Connor shook his head. He needed to take control of this situation before it went completely off the rails. "Ok, enough! Everyone get dressed. This will all go a lot easier if you all aren't naked. Zach, this wasn't a set up or a trick. I know you don't trust me, and I get that. But I think we have some important things to talk about."
"I'm leaving, unless you plan on keeping me here. Am I a prisoner or something?"
"Of course you are not a prisoner! Please, all I'm asking is for you to give us a chance to explain some things. Zach, I promise, you're perfectly safe here. No one here would ever harm you. What happened at your dorm room was inexcusable and I am deeply sorry for scaring you."
Zack hesitated a moment. He looked into the older man's eyes, and couldn't see the lie. He seemed genuinely sorry for what had happened. Yet Zack couldn't forget that beneath the surface of this attractive man was a dangerous creature. "I know what you are, sheriff."
"Yes, I'm a werewolf. Billy's a werewolf, so's Eddie. We are all werewolves. But I promise we won't hurt you."
Zack was taken aback by the sheriff's blunt admission, and the realization that the two guys he had just had sex with were also werewolves. He turned to look at Eddie. "You are?"
Eddie spoke. "Zack, I was the one you saw last week in the woods. I'm sorry I scared you." Zack shook his head in disbelief.
"Ok, Eddie, Billy, go in the kitchen. Give us the room."
Both boys grabbed their clothing and left. Zack was pulling on his jeans when he saw the sheriff take his sidearm out of the holster and place it on the sofa and stepped back.
"I'm going to put this here, okay? Would you feel better if you were armed? Would you give me the chance to explain? Take it. If I start shifting, you can shoot me. That's how desperate I am. I am begging you, Zack."
Zack looked from the sheriff, to the gun, then back. "Are there silver bullets in there?"
Connor let out a low laugh. "Regular bullets work just fine when we're human."
Zack nodded, pulled on his shirt, and sat on the sofa next to the gun, but not touching it. Connor went to the other side of the sectional, giving Zack plenty of space. He sat down. "Thank you, Zack."
"So what is it you need to explain to me?"
For a moment, Connor's breath caught in his chest. He was surprisingly emotional. It was time. He began. "I'd like to tell you a story, about myself, and about my sons. Will you listen?"
Zack nodded, and Connor continued. "Werewolves have packs, and packs are led by an Alpha wolf. My father was an Alpha, and so am I. Me and my sons, we are our own little pack. That's because when I was about your age I had to leave my old pack behind. It's a long story, and one I don't like telling. It's a painful part of my past. After I left, I had to start a new life, and I wanted children to carry on our heritage. Unlike what you might have seen in the movies, the only way to become a werewolf is to be born one. I didn't have or want a mate, but I did have resources. I was fortunate that when my father died, I inherited the means to live independently of any pack, and to pursue my own heirs."
"I had a friend who was a doctor, a specialist who worked with couples struggling to have kids. Hell, she wasn't just a friend. She was my best friend. She was older than me but we had a special connection. Her name was Ellie Byrne. Ellie knew that I wasn't interested in women, but wanted children. She agreed to help be a surrogate. I had two children with her, Edward and William. I can't express how grateful I was to have her in my life. After Billy was born, something changed. We sort of lost touch. A phone call here, a letter there, then nothing. I thought, at the time that she just wasn't interested in motherhood, and dropped out of my life. Turns out, I was wrong."
As Connor spoke, Zack couldn't help but notice a sadness in his tone that he had not noticed before. The man's voice was low, but carried a note of genuineness that he found convincing. He continued.
"What happened in your dorm room, that moment where I almost lost control, that was not normal for me. Let me explain what it is to be a werewolf. You see Zack, we have this primal force that lives inside us. It's always there, but gets stronger when the moon is fullest. That primal force is our wolf. It gives us strength, it heightens our senses, and gives us insight into things that normal people don't have. But it's a wild animal, and we have to always keep it under control. What happened in your dorm room was an unusual reaction that I didn't understand at the time. All I knew was that my wolf went crazy. It wanted you."
"Not exactly providing words of comfort here, Sheriff."
He laughed. "I can understand that. But my wolf wasn't trying to hurt you. Our wolves are part of us, but they are also separate beings. We share our lives with them, and they share their gifts with us. When I saw you, my wolf communicated a feeing, a possessiveness about you that made no sense me. There was something about you Zack. In fact, Eddie had already figured out that there was something special about you. We could sense it, smell it. We feel it when we touch you."
Zack shook his head. "But there isn't anything special about me."
"You are wrong, Zack. I looked into you, your past. I'm sorry, I know it's obtrusive."
"Don't feel too bad. I tried to do the same thing to you. They have this thing called social media now. People air all their dirty laundry. You should try it."
Connor smiled a melancholy smile. "Well, digging into a person's background is more effective when you are a cop. I found out some things about you. I know about your family, and that you were adopted."
Zack was quiet now, his tension starting to rise again. Connor knew that he had reached the moment of highest danger. He pressed on.