"I'm not taking 'No' for an answer. We're picking you up at 6:00. Be ready." Elena's scolding glare leaves no room for debate. I guess I'm going to dinner tonight with her, her husband Oliver and her cousin Ramon. Ramon is here in Chicago because of a big conference at McCormick Place on Monday. Elena invited him to come in early for a weekend visit. He's staying with them. He flies back home to Portland first thing Tuesday morning.
Elena has been my best friend since we were both ten years old in the fifth grade. She's done so much for me making it impossible to say "No" to her perfectly reasonable request. We text about a thousand times a day but she also calls me every Tuesday and Thursday night, forcing live human interaction. I've also committed to our regular Saturday afternoon lunches, which is what we're doing right now. I think that she thinks that if she didn't drag me out of my apartment every Saturday afternoon, that I'd hole up and become a shut-in. And while that does sound tempting, I'm not quite as fucked up as she's afraid I might be.
I have a job, though I do work from home, as a financial advisor. I could order everything I ever need online and never leave, but I really don't want to be a recluse. I force myself to get out. I go to doctor's appointments, dentist appointments, I grocery shop once a week... What I don't do is anything social. With the lone exception of Saturday lunches with Elena, I do not go to bars, restaurants, movies, malls or anywhere that is not a necessity. Not for the last two years anyway.
Two years ago, Carter left me. Couples break up all the time. I get that. We weren't special. Except we really were. We were Felix and Carter. We met at age twenty in the middle of college, became friends, started dating and fell in love. Right out of college, we got an apartment together. We were everything to each other. We liked all the same music, shows, movies, books, foods, wines, sports... Elena met Oliver just after college and the four of us became inseparable couple-friends. Carter and I were deliriously happy together. Or so I thought. At least I was.
We were always among the first to try a new restaurant or bar, but we would have just as much fun ordering in and watching a movie. Or playing music. Carter wasn't a musician, but he could harmonize with the best of them. We would sit at my piano, coasters and wine glasses on the lid, his arm around my shoulder, one song after another. Happy songs for happy times. I still play piano every day, but now... Only the sad mournful songs. Played by myself, for myself. Songs like
I can't Make You Love Me, Someone Like You, And So It Goes
and
Strange Room.
I know... I really should sell my piano.
Two years ago was a year of celebrations. Four thirtieth birthdays and a ten year anniversary. The birthdays were all group parties, like that episode of
Friends
, but for our ten year anniversary, Carter and I celebrated alone. We had a lovely sushi dinner with an expensive white wine and a crรจme brรปlรฉe for dessert. Everything was perfect. We had talked about getting married dozens of times before. I honestly didn't think he was even mildly surprised when I proposed that night. I gave him a silver band for the fourth finger of his left hand. He, after jumping up and down while shedding tears of joy, carried me to our bed and gave me a "Yes" along with the blow job of my life. He brought an animal noise out of me that made our neighbor scream, "Shut up!" and pound on the wall.
That weekend, we began discussing dates and venues. We both wanted an October wedding with fall colors surrounding us. Every decision came so easily because we were essentially two halves of the same person. And then, just two short weeks later, I found myself holding his silver ring and watching his back as he walked out the door. Forever.
When he first told me that he was offered the job of his dreams, I was thrilled. Then he told me that the job was in New York. I was still thrilled. My own job had been transitioning more and more to working from home. I figured a move would be no big deal. And even if my company had a problem with it, surely there were hundreds if not thousands of financial advisory opportunities in NYC. Elena would be pissed that I'd be moving away, but with texts, calls and monthly weekend visits, she'd eventually be fine. I was 100% on board with being the supportive partner.
And then he told me that we needed to talk. It all became a blur to me but the gist of it was that this was a move he wanted - no, needed - to make on his own. It wasn't me, it was him. He had come to realize that he wasn't a "settle down and get married" kind of a person and that he didn't want to stand in my way of finding my own happiness.
Finding my own happiness?
Like I hadn't found that a decade ago. By that point, I could see his lips were moving but I could no longer hear what he was saying. Was it our engagement? Was it turning thirty - an early midlife crisis? He had said it wasn't me, but how could it not be? If it wasn't me, then he wouldn't have left me behind. His last kind act was that he had called Elena and asked her to come over. Within five minutes of him walking out of our door for his final time, Elena walked in through it.
Oliver really is the best husband, the most understanding straight guy and just the best person I know. His wife moved in with me for a whole week and he never once complained. Several times he brought over food and ate dinner with us, only to kiss Elena on the cheek and wrap me in a genuine hug before leaving us alone again. He just knew. I needed my best friend. And while he'd never have a reason to be jealous of me from a romantic standpoint, most guys would be at least a little jealous of the time our friendship took Elena away from him. But Elena and I were deeply bonded for two thirds of our lives. Oliver knew from day one that falling in love with Elena meant loving me too. Or at least accepting me? Tolerating me? Elena and I are a package deal and Oliver gets it. And I love him for that, among the long list of things that make him and Elena the dream couple that they are.
When Carter told me he was going to New York without me, his suitcases were already packed and hiding in the bedroom. The whole conversation barely lasted fifteen minutes. And suddenly he was gone. My life went from normal to nuclear disaster in a quarter of an hour. He told me that we'd keep in touch. That we'd always be friends. That this wasn't really goodbye.
It was really goodbye.
After a week of trying to figure out where I fucked up, what I did wrong and why this all happened, I found no answers and I had run out of tears. It was time. I kicked Elena out. She was willing to stay longer, but there was nothing else she could do. She needed to get back to own life, her job and her saint of a husband.
But that was the beginning of our rigid schedule of texts, calls and lunches. She let a whole year go by before she started pushing for me to get back out there. To meet and see new people. To go on a date. For the last year, she has been trying to set me up with a guy she works with - Miguel. I've never met Miguel, but he is her work friend. Her work husband, Oliver jokes. Elena, having grown up in a house full of sisters, as an adult surrounds herself with men. Friends - Felix and Carter (former). Husband - Oliver. Work Friend - Miguel. Even their cat, Cujo, is a boy.
Every time she mentions Miguel, I shut her down immediately. I am just not ready. Not even for something casual. A one-night fling would be too much right now. I am still a ridiculous mess and it wouldn't be fair to the other person - Miguel. I need to understand where it all went wrong with Carter. I obviously can't read people and I suck at being a boyfriend. I can't risk screwing up again. I can't go through this again. It will break me. Next time, I won't recover. Not that most people would consider me recovered today.
I had been making progress. A year ago, I really thought I was getting there. But then... My world exploded all over again. I didn't want to block Carter on all social media platforms, so despite the fact that we do not communicate directly with each other, he is still a connection. But even if he wasn't, I still would have found out. We have too many "friends" in common for me not to. Only one short year after leaving his ten year committed relationship with me, Carter, the guy who is just not a "marriage kind of a guy", got engaged. Wow. So... It wasn't the idea of commitment and marriage. It was committing to and marrying