Will and I were over at Tyler's place after school. His parents were going to be out until late that evening and he had invited both of us over. It had been a while since he had extended an invitation to me, but I wasn't surprised to receive one sine he had been watching me and Will fuck. Even though he was still annoyed that Will wasn't allowing him to fuck me, he was happy enough to let one of us suck him off while he watched.
"You guys should sell videos of this shit," Tyler said as he sat back and watched me and Will make out.
Will pulled away from me and smirked. "You're the only porn star around here."
Tyler looked confused. "Huh? What?"
"Seriously?" Seeing Tyler not getting it, Will pulled out his phone and loaded the video.
Tyler groaned. "I forgot I sent you that. You can't show anyone. I gotta rep to maintain."
"Don't worry," Will said as he moved closer to Tyler. "You know your secret's safe. But it does make me think..."
Tyler narrowed his eyes and gave him a suspicious look. "What?"
"Let me and Walt fuck you. After that, I'll let you fuck him."
Tyler's eyes went wide for a split second then his mouth turned up in broad smile. "How could I say no to that? Sounds like it's nothing but win-win for me."
Not wasting any time, the three of us quickly stripped. It was the first time I had seen Tyler completely naked and felt like I could have cum just from the sight of him. His torso was broad and the skin stretched tight over and sharply defined his pecs and abs. Beneath his arms thick tufts of hair grew and other than a thin line that led from just above his navel to his trimmed bush, there was no other hair on it. Sticking out of his crotch, his cock was already swelling and jerking upward as it filled with arousal.
Even though I had seen the video and Will had told me about the things he and Tyler had done, I was surprised to see Tyler drop to his knees and take Will's dick into his mouth. He wasn't at all hesitant about it and was soon sucking my brother's dick with a passion that reminded me of how eagerly I had sucked him off.
"Don't just stand there," Will said to me. "Get inside his ass."
I got behind Tyler and took a moment to stare at his firm ass. Not even thinking about it, I leaned forward and swiped my tongue along his furry crack and heard him moan. Encouraged, I repeated the action and was soon eating his ass with gusto. It was sweaty, musky and funky from soccer practice and tasted completely like Tyler. His hole twitched each time my tongue moved across it and when I finally pressed a finger into him, I was surprised by how easily it entered.
"If you don't fucking put that dick in me, I'm going to turn around and show you how to fuck an ass."
I looked up over Tyler's ass and saw him glaring at me while he stroked Will's dick.
Above him, my brother gave me a half smile. "I know his ass tastes good but I'd do it if I were you. You know he's been after your ass and probably won't wait much longer for it."
"No, I won't," Tyler said darkly.
With the threat hanging in the air, I wasn't exactly reluctant as I lined up and pressed into him. Unlike Will's hole, Tyler's was surprisingly loose and supple. It wasn't gaping and unpleasant, it simply felt like a comfortable, well-worn pair of shoes around me. "Fuck, Tyler. How much dick have you had?"
"None of your fucking business. If you don't like it, you can pull the fuck out."
"Not until I drop this load," I returned as I gave him a particularly hard thrust.
He let out a mocking sound. "You think you know how to throw a fuck? Really?"
Before I could answer, I felt his ring begin to rhythmically flex around me while he took over thrusting and rolling his hips against me. I stared down in shock at Tyler's ass as he fucked me with a vigor I did not expect. "Oh, shit."
"You like that, Walt?" Tyler taunted me. "Think you're man enough to handle this?"
All I could do was moan while Tyler fucked his ass on my dick. Whatever momentary control I thought I had over him was gone. I was no more an active participant in this fuck than if he was laying on top of me pounding my ass with his fuckstick.
"Should've just fucked him," Will said with amusement. To Tyler, he said, "Go easy on him. He'll learn."