"Do you like Amber?" Kelly asked, the edge in her voice was very clear.
Oh boy, here is where we pay for the fun.
The previous day, the three of us had crossed a lot of boundaries as Kelly, Amber and I had a threesome. I had lucked into the perfect moment, the intersection of lust, alcohol and repressed sexuality that exploded in a ferocity not typically witnessed by mortal man.
Kelly and I were seniors in college and her roommate, Amber, was a sophomore. Amber was a cute, but totally repressed, girl and last night, Kelly had kissed Amber, her first girl-girl kiss. Amber learned how to suck dick, mine, under Kelly's tutelage and discovered how to swallow. Amber and I sucked Kelly's tits and Kelly and I sucked Amber's tits. The night ended with Amber still a virgin but it was still an unbelievable night.
"Yeah, I like her. She's nice," I said with a casual smile, acting like I had no idea what was bothering her, so she stewed for a while.
Kelly and I had been dating for two years and I was devoted to her. Kelly was beautiful, brunette, slim and athletic with nice boobs. She was also sexually adventurous, although this was the first time we had ever done a threesome.
"You're
my
boyfriend," she finally said, venom in her voice.
"Yes, and I am the luckiest man in the world," I said with a grin, leaning over to kiss her.
She only gave me her cheek. I sat back and continued to watch the game as if nothing was wrong while she was fidgeting, trying to sort out her feelings.
"I don't want you fucking her!"
"Oh. Is this about last night?" I asked innocently.
"I know how you guys are. All you want is more pussy. Well, you're mine and if you do that slut, I'll cut your fucking nuts off!"
"Hey, now, last night was about youjust as much as it was me. I did that with her becauseof you, not in spite of you. If you'll recall, I fucked you, not her."
She pouted some more, and I pulled her over for kisses and snuggles, all the while letting her know that I was not going to run around behind her back. Finally, she relaxed and we started making out and before long, we were doing it, kind of like make up sex. She wanted to get her scent on me, to reassure herself that I was hers. Afterwards, I spooned her as we cuddled and watched the game.
"So, what was your favorite part?" she asked.
"Honestly? Amber's blowjob."
She glanced over her shoulder to me, displeased.
"Yeah, I really like blowjobs but I also really like kissing you. When you're blowing me, I can't very well kiss you. Kissing you while Amber was sucking me was great. It was like the best of both worlds."
She thought about it and relaxed a little.
"What was your favorite part?" I asked.
"You having sex with me afterwards," she whispered.
"Yeah, you really seemed turned on. Another favorite of mine."
"Yeah," she finally admitted.
"Well, I can see that this bothers you, so you're in control. I don't want to cause any problems between you two, so I'll wait for you to guide me."
She seemed satisfied with that and let the subject drop. When I finally came over to their apartment, I spent a few moments complimenting Amber. She seemed more timid than usual around me. Sitting in the same room with her and remembering her lips wrapped around my cock was a bit awkward.
Amber is not a skinny girl, she has curves, but she's not fat, though she is definitely really self-conscious about her body. I can see that, somehow, in high school being thick and having braces made her feel like an ugly duckling but the recent years had been very good to her. She is in really good shape and works out daily at the gym. She has black hair, a sweet face and nice boobs. However, despite being quite attractive, she hadn't had a boyfriend for as long as I knew her.
Kelly seemed a little nervous about having Amber, a girl that we had played with,around but things soon got back to normal. Kelly and I talked about, maybe, having another threesome, with someone else, but Kelly wasn't really sure about things. Maybe we could meet some girl that wouldn't be in our circle to play with so the idea of going to the casinos upstate came up. Then, one night, we were watching Spartacus. There was a scene where the slave girl pleasured the woman, warming her up before the man took over.
"You know, we could do that with Amber," she said.
I looked at her in amazement.
"You mean, you would want Amber to go down on you?"
She shrugged flirtatiously.
"Well, would you?"
I tried to hide my eagerness to no avail, leading to her pouting a bit. I definitely need to work on my poker face. Kelly played cool to the idea after that but it must have hit a nerve because she brought it up again a few days later.
"We could take Amber up to the casino, share a room and then share her."
My cock jumped for joy as I heard this coming from Kelly's mouth but I played it straight.
"Are you sure? How far do you want to go?"
"I'm still not keen about you fucking her but it was hot when we were playing around!"
I smiled on the inside while nodding in agreement.
"You know I'm happy just with you but if you want to, I'm more than game."
Plans were set into motion and over the Martin Luther King, Jr. holiday, the three of us took a trip north. It was late when I checked into a room while Kelly and Amber wandered around the gift shop. Kelly and I had a plan to get a single, king sized bed for the three of us. We had told Amber we would have separate beds but when I came back I said the hotel was out of rooms and we were stuck with a single king. Kelly started putting on an act, as if tickedoff at having only one bed for all three of us.
"Now listen, Amber. Just because we're sharing a bed doesn't mean I'm sharing Kevin. Hands off, understand?" she said firmly.
Amber nodded, mutely. She looked like a kid being told they can't have dessert.
"That goes for you, too, mister. You leave her alone! Got it?"
"But you're still fair game, right?" I asked as I blatantly grabbed her ass.
That night, Kelly settled between Amber and me to make sure we wouldn't try anything. As soon as we were settled, I steamrolled both of them in an effort to show how mature I was. The night passed slowly and Kelly swatted my hands off of her several times.
Our plan was to try something the next night but I could barely sleep with these two right beside me and a raging hard-on. Kelly finally gave in and gave me a hand job that morphed into a blow job. I looked across the bed as she worked on me and, studying the profile of Amber, wondered if she was awake and trying to stay still. I came hard in Kelly's mouth and, finally, I was able to sleep.
The next day was fun, playing a few machines, going for a hike and the girls went to a spa. That night, we went to dinner and then dancing at a club. Amber had never been in a club. The music was loud, the lights were flashing and bodies were pressed together. I took turns grinding on Kelly and Amber and Kelly took turns grinding on Amber and me. I gave plenty of inappropriate squeezes on both girls.
Although we each only had one 'real' drink, I was plying the girls with 'mixed drinks', in fact, they were all virgin and a fact Kelly was aware of. Amber was not an experienced drinker and, incredibly, was acting kind of loopy and leaning on me by the time we went back to the room.
