"Don't you think it's a little late for modesty, Kyle?" Mom asked as she glanced down at my feeble attempt to cover my obvious erection.
She took a few steps over to Kelly's desk and pulled the chair out. Then, turning it around to face me, she sat down and pointed to the bed. "Sit down." Mom said.
"Can I put some clothes on first?" I asked in return.
Mom shook her head and pointed to the bed again. "No." She said. "Sit down and just keep quiet for now."
As I reluctantly sat on the edge of the bed, I looked down at the towel and the silk ceremonial panties stained with my little sister's virginal blood. Just a few feet away were the two pair of panties my sister wore for me before we made love. I could see the wet spots on both of them. The vivid memory of how Kelly spread her legs, displayed herself and touched her pussy wearing those panties came back to me when I saw them, and just the thought of it all caused my cock to throb.
When I finally got the courage to peer up at my mother, she was looking at our sex wish list again. I could see her eyes as she read, shifting from left to right, reading each line. Every now and then, she'd look up at me and then return to the list. When she was done reading, she looked up at me. I couldn't bear to look her in the eye, so I looked away and then lowered my stare to the carpet.
"Take your hands away." I heard her say after a few seconds.
When I pulled my head up to look at her, Mom was holding Kelly's digital camera in her hands and browsing through the pictures. She stopped for a second and looked up at me.
"I said," she paused, looking me straight in the eyes, "move your hands."
Mom was serious. She had that 'Don't push me' look on her face – a look both Kelly and I knew very well. And when we saw it, we knew she meant business. So, I did what she asked, I moved my hands to my side, uncovering my hard and throbbing penis.
I saw her eyes drop to my crotch, staring at my cock for a full minute before she went back to looking at the pictures on Kelly's camera. I wasn't sure how many pictures we'd taken, but, I would say at least fifty or sixty. She must have gone through them two or three times, looking up at me periodically as she did. The whole time, she never once showed any emotion. I waited for her to yell at me, or make a face, but she didn't.
The fact that she wasn't showing any reaction to the nasty wish list or the pictures was beginning to worry me. I started to watch for signs that she was going to explode – perhaps throw the camera at me and maybe even the chair she was sitting on, but she didn't.
And, thankfully, while she was looking at the pictures my cock started to soften. I don't know if it was my embarrassment or my nerves, but I figured being naked in front of your mother without an erection was better than being in front of her with an erection.
Having seen all the pictures, my mother lowered the camera to her lap. Then, she pointed to the two pairs of panties lying on the bed. "I assume those are supposed to be for you?" Mom asked.
Ashamed to admit the truth, I nodded my head up and down instead of answering 'Yes'.
"I see. Like trophies or something?" Mom asked calmly.
Again, I nodded my head and lowered my eyes back to the carpet, preparing myself for the worst.
"Kyle," Mom began, "I want you to start at the beginning and explain all of this to me. And you better not leave anything out or make anything up. I'm going to speak to your sister after we're done, and if your two stories don't match perfectly, I'm just going to turn all this over to your father and let him deal with it."
"Fuck!" I thought to myself. "My father? Damn, if Mom was home from shopping, then Dad was home to!" I immediately started to panic, turning to the doorway and leaning as far as I could to see if I could see or hear him.
"Does he know?" I asked in horror.
"He's not here." Mom explained. "His work called while we were shopping. They have some kind of chemical leak at the plant. He won't be home for hours."
"So, what's it going to be?" She asked, as she sat back in the chair holding our sex wish list and Kelly's camera filled with our incriminating pictures. "Do you want to explain it to me, or take your chances with your father?"
There was no question about it. We all knew Dad was over protective about Kelly, his only daughter, and I can just image how he'd react after seeing the pictures, the towel, the wish list and the mountain of evidence against us. Without a doubt, I'd be disowned and probably thrown out of the family. So, as uncomfortable as it was, I was going to have to talk to Mom.
"I'd prefer you, Mom." I answered, as respectfully and clearly as I could.
"Okay, then," she replied, "I want the whole story. I don't care it if takes you three hours. No lying and no omissions. And, mark my words, Son..... if your story doesn't exactly match Kelly's, you'll be facing your father when he gets home. Understand?"
I took a deep breath and nodded my head. "Alright," I replied, "I understand."
I took a couple of deep breaths. "Well," I began, "we made the wish list about a couple of hours ago."