Elliot's POV
I waited three days after catching him watching me and Shane before I confronted him. He'd been avoiding us since it happened, scurrying through the house like a scared mouse. I couldn't stop thinking about the narrow, hot look in his eye as he watched Shane worshiping my cock, as he did frequently. Jordan wouldn't have had a good view of the action but I couldn't adjust without alerting Shane. He would have scared Jordan away but I liked him there, the little mouse.
I knocked on his bedroom door and hoped he wouldn't hide. I wanted more of him and I was quite used to getting what I wanted.
After almost a minute of waiting, the door slowly clicked open. Jordan looked at me with wide, nearly terrified eyes through a four inch gap in the door. "Hi," he said, his voice small.
I smiled and tried not to make it look as hungry for him as I felt. "Hey. Can I come in?"
He seemed to think about this, surely trying to rake his brain for some polite reason to say no. But eventually, he gives up and sighs, opening the door wider for me to step in. "Sure."
"Uh, so. What's up?" he asked, frantically tossing dirty laundry from the floor into a hamper by his desk. I wasn't sure if this was because he was embarrassed by the mess, or if he was just looking for an excuse not to look at me.
I leaned my back against the door, making it a point to give him as much space as I could. He was a beautiful, handsome, nervous mess.
He was only a thin hair shorter than me with scruffy brown hair and a clean shave, a sharp jaw and anxious green eyes. His body was usually hidden behind thick hoodies but when he only wore a t-shirt, I could see the promise of the muscles underneath. During one of our chats, he mentioned that he liked to run. He had the long legs for it, the thick thighs and a lean body built for endurance that he refused to show off, for some reason.
"Just wanted to know if you enjoyed the show?" I asked and I knew it was too forward for the little mouse but I couldn't help myself.
His face went tomato red immediately. "I'm really sorry about that. I've never done anything like that before. I swear, it won't happen again." His horrified ramblings were falling out of him so quickly it was almost incoherent.
I tried to hide my own amusement because he'd think I was laughing at him. I wasn't. I was just delighted at how adorable he was. "I don't mind if it happens again," I assured him carefully, fully aware that this was a risk that might not land where I want it to. "In fact, you'd be more than welcome to join if you'd like. We don't mind sharing."
He opened his mouth then shut it again, stammering like a wordless fish. "I think... that's probably a bad idea," he finally said.
"Oh? You looked like you were going to start pushing Shane out of the way to take his spot. For a second, I thought you might try. But you're not interested?" I tried not to look unbearably disappointed but I was sure I failed miserably.
"It's just..." he trailed off before taking a breath, his eyes sealed shut so that he wouldn't have to look at me when he said, "I've never done that... been with a guy, I mean."
"Ah. Is this a grand moment of self discovery then?"
"Not really. I've known for a couple of years that I'm gay, I just haven't... like, figured out how to talk to guys, I guess?"
"You're talking to me just fine."
He scoffed. "I'm talking. I wouldn't say I'm doing fine. I'd say I've made myself look like a complete idiot. And a creep."
"None of those things," I assured him, taking one tentative step forward. Jordan noticed, his eyes glancing frantically at the new place I took up, but he didn't move away. "I thought it was really hot, you watching like that. I hadn't cum that hard in a long time."
Another bloom of blush rushed to his cheeks but once it settled, he cleared his throat and his eyes found mine. "Really?"
I nodded. "And it's nothing to be embarrassed about, not having been with a guy before. We all start somewhere. Plus, I'm a great teacher," I grinned. "We could start with the things you've done before and go from there."
He looked apprehensive but curious. A little mouse peaking his head out of a hiding place when he smells the cheese. "Like what?"
"Well, surely, you've kissed somebody before?" I asked.
Jordan nodded.